Reviews of Barbier des Isles (1978)
by Comptoir Sud Pacifique

I loved this at first, but my feelings have cooled.

It is extremely crisp and dry, with excellent longevity and plenty of projection. To my nose, a sharp vetiver dominates, obstructing the rest of the composition. What I can detect besides that is dry and woody, almost like sun-baked cedar chips. The dryness sometimes reads as "powdery" to my nose. But it's a green and rather harsh powder, nothing soft about it.

Before I try it I thought it would be a light, fresh a little spicy woody-aromatic scent, judged by its notes. I'm fooled! This one is so thick and heavy and dull you almost can cut it with a knife! Where is the orange, where is my favorite bergamot? all I can smell was incense and some burnt spices. Oh and a hint of vetiver too but in this case it did not help freshen up this fragrance. I have never found CSP's scent I don't like but this is the one! I don't think I will try it again at least not in the near future. Disappointed!

This is a marvelous scent in the aromatic, spicy-wood line. It starts with citrus and warm spices, with hints of smoky incense. The elements are well blended, so it is a bit of a challenge to pick them out. However, I can say that the jasmine softerns the resinous incense and enriches the woody spices. Hints of patchouli add tangy complexity. Dry woods emerge, along with some grassy vetiver. Hey – no vanilla at all here! Excellent! I like this sort of scent and this is very, very well done. Much better than Corolian, and not as barber-shop/clovey as Rive Gauche. And I find Virgilo to be SO green and basil-y that I don't see the resemblance.

Just look at the variety of opinions! PaulSC says it’s a balanced powdery green fragrance; vadim calls it barbershop; robyogi says patchouli, vetiver, and Annick Goutal; nitram_naed says milk, lavender, and Coriolan; PaulG and tvlampboy say it’s a dry vetiver; flathorn claims aoud; JDBill — Aramis; and IPaid smells burning wood on a sandy beach. I find this very interesting because it shows how unique and individual our perceptions, our olfactory systems, and our skin chemistry are. Some fragrances have very consistent results among reviewers, others, like this one, have such variations in interpretations. I get two entirely different fragrances when I test this on paper and when I test it one my skin. On paper, after an aromatic / wood opening that lasts for almost an hour, I smell an incredibly beautiful vetiver fragrance – quite dry and, well… perfect. Unfortunately, on my skin BDI becomes an aoud sillage monster – it is almost pure aoud (myrrh wood?). I don’t get any citrus or florals. I get a little vetiver and a little spice, but, basically, I get an aoud like note that dominates the progression of the scent. This is a sinus clearing aoud, and to that extent, I think I am partially agreeing with IPaid as well as with Flathorn who was the first to cry, “Aoud.” My skin and/or my nose distort the aoud-like note into a dominance that I am not comfortable with. I still have a half of my decant left, so I will continue giving BDI further tests, and maybe I will overcome my resistance to it.

Bone dry vetiver with hints of verdant island fields. Crisp and sharp and impeccable -- definitely what I'd consider a "tailored" frag. I think of some stiff upper lippish Brit getting an old fashioned shave in Bermuda when I put this one on. (GREAT frag for warm climes, btw -- refreshing w/o being cloying -- it's ANYTHING but cloying.)

It's vetiver sans the dirtiness (Route du Vetiver), the tobacco (Guerlain's old formulation) the strong use of wood with vetiver (Molinard I) and the bubbly citrus (Guerlain's new formulation). Thumbs up, yes, but with the proviso that this stuff is very dry and VERY vetiver.

To my nose, BdI does a pretty good job evoking a 1960s barbershop in a sunlit and tranquil banana republic (if there ever was such a thing). A rather well-made and balanced scent, but too sweet and one-dimensional. I prefer my islands less sunny and with a bit more drama and intrigue (think Graham Greene). And, as barbershop scents go, Rive Gauche is a much better option anyway.

Oh what a disappointing stinker! Very, very earthy, dry, bitter. Patchouli overload...again (maybe my skin just doesn't like this note - man I can't stand it). On top of that, vetiver overload too! I don't get a lot of musk. Maybe some spices in the mix. Smells like something Goutal would have conjured up. Or a lesser version of MPG's RdV.

Verbena, woods, and shadows of Coriolan. Your rich vapours transported my being in dreams to a trim, courtly forest glade where Marie Antoinette played at shepherdesses with her courtiers. Among the artful rustic cabins, I spied the Queen and gallantly doffed my hat. 'Magnificently met, Your Majesty,' I cried. 'And Barbier des Isles: a true work of art: as refined as a palace, as woody as a pirates's leg!' 'Milk and lavender,' she cooed, giggling, 'milk and lavender for me!' 'Absolute rot, you tittering ninny,' I declared, 'verbena, woods, and shadows of Coriolan!' (de Charlus)

Dry vetiver based scent that is done better by countless houses. Plus the lasting power isn't the best (which in this case isn't necessarily a bad thing). There's a lot more unique and wearable selections from this house. Not my bag at all.

While I'm not a fan of most of this line (too much sweetness, fruit and tropical cliches), I like their earthier fragrances. I'm sort of addicted to the main note of Barbier Des Isles. It's not a fragrance I wear anyplace (I wear it for myself at home), and I've never received a compliment on it, but sometimes when I'm bored with my more traditional and often-used fragrances, BDI sort of clears my jaded olfactory senses, and resets my nose, and at times like that I enjoy it immensely. I always thought it had an unusual main note the ingredient list didn't explain, and after trying several Oud fragrances recently, it struck me BDI has a similar note. Barbier Des Isles gives me the impression of the dark hot dryness of equatorial loam and non-sweet raisins.
Ingredients: Bergamot, Orange, Jasmine, Incense, Clove, Patchouli, Wood of Myrrh, Bois de rose, Vetiver, and Musk.

If you like Aramis, you will love this. The Aramis is a bit sweeter. What a rip off.

Barbier des Isles came as a pleasant surprise to me. I usually associated bloated, sickening sweetness with CSP fragrances. Barbier des Isles is a very earthy fragrance. It comes off as a blend of dry woods and vetiver, with some subtle spices within. Whenever I smell BdI I imagine dry dying wood on a sandy beach. Great twist on normal earthy fragrances.