This aftershave actually came in 4 different scents - creatively named No.1, No.2, No.3 and No.4 !!
I have bottles of numbers 1-3 which are very rare to come by now and all beautiful old-fashioned aftershave scents.
The numbers related to the Body Shop perfume oils that were also available during the same period which were as follows:
No.1 = Samarkand - fresh citrus and lavender with petitgrain notes
No.2 = Woody Sandalwood - a very dark woody scent with hints of aged brandy
No.3 = Jamaica - no, she went of her own accord (sorry) - spicy, woody and rummy but still quite light
No.4 = Mostly Musk - the lost body shop classic fresh musk.
This was a divine frag ... very sandalwoody with vanilla ... loved it. When they announced it was being discontinued, I bought out the shop (5 or 6 flasks) and used it into the new century. Got complements from women and men.
After an exhaustive search, closest I found was Taylor of Old Bond Street Shaving Shop. I use it every day. Lovely!