Reviews of Eau de New York (2004)
by Bond No. 9

A stunning citrus cologne opening, done very well without abrasiveness, a very wearable fresh-chypre scent soon emerges and I kept sniffing myself where I'd sprayed the fragrance, nodding appreciatively and wanting to find just something stunningly unique in there to tip the balance over from "very nice" to "it's worth this much money". Eau de New York is really lovely and I'd wear it, but perhaps not fall-in-love stunning for this price. If I was wealthy and money was no object, I would have bought a bottle with no questions asked. Perhaps that's the point?

EDITED 2009: I recently received a bottle of this as a gift. My chief gripe was that I couldn't justify paying the price for "nice". Now I don't have to... therefore changed from neutral to thumbs up.

The dominant notes I get are a lemon and lime accord and some nice woods. It is cool and refreshing. The only complaint I have is that those characteristics don't make it stand out from most of the others in the same genre. I admit, I’ve given thumbs-up to less pleasing fragrances just because they take artistic risks. This one, no. Very safe. So, I give it a qualified thumbs-up and recommend it to lovers of citrus.

Greener than I expected, but a little weak.
The citrus and greens are nicely done, but are lacking a 'natural majority'
Also lacking a cohesive base, and the base is does have is weak and unexceptional for the price.
Nice Bottle.

This has a gorgeous citrus-neroli opening. Verbena is quite evident too, with its distinctive green-citrus character. So far, it is crisp, fresh, very enjoyable… just a beautiful scent. When these beautiful notes burn off, there is a grassy vetiver chord, along with some synthetic notes which are a bit metallic. Also there is an animalic musk note that sometimes is intriguing, sometimes a bit irritating.

I smell the tangy, bitter grapefruit and mandarin opening with grassy undertones.....the fragrance doesnt develop much sticking to its fresh tangy roots yet becoming sweeter as it progresses.......nicely done summer fragrance but nothing to write home about.

Nothing out of the ordinary. I found myself spraying it on me a few times throughout the day because it disappeared completely. The moment had already passed before I could get what the fragrance was about. Very fleeting. Oddly sweet and fruity yet smooth like some kind of drink and kind of confuses me.

This is a great fragrance - the reviews below describe it well. My only complaint is that it is not really unisex, or at least it's on the most feminine end of the unisex spectrum. Unlike other B9 unisex offerings, like Wall Street, there isn't much that can salvage this for a man who wants to smell masculine.

While I haven't completely changed my mind about this scent, I must give it more credit than I did in my previous review. It has more going for it than I originally thought. While I initially only detected bergamot, I've come to the realization that this has a pleasant lemon grass note along the same lines as Eau Sauvage. While I still wouldn't drop the cash to buy this scent, I would definitely wear it in the spring and summer months if it were cheaper.

Eau de New York is very nice scent — it has quality accords and is excellently structured as are all Bond No. 9 fragrances. The very well done grapefruit / citrus / Petitgrain opening is clean and bright and quite long lasting. The citrus top stretches itself by including in the middle notes some clean and bright neroli and verbena, which are, in turn, supported by a very clear, non-heady white floral accord. The base is an excellent lightwoods / oakmoss creation which is artfully proportioned to the top levels of the fragrance. There’s no doubt that what EdNY offers is quality in an attractive smelling fragrance. But this fragrance is not very much different from many other very good citrus scents – and those others sell at a small percentage of what EdNY costs. This is a fragrance which carries a premium price, but there’s nothing superbly superior here, nothing innovative or incredibly unique. But it’s a very nice scent ...

I am starting to get the feeling that all Bond No 9 fragrances are reincarnations of used-to-be-in-style with a slightly modern twist. And by modern twist I mean a lemony/citrus opening.
This particular fragrance goes back about 25 years. It opens very dry and dark green, with a citrus sweetness; it conjures images of a tweedy flannel fabric. Then the green comes alive, still dark, until it transitions into a metallic green, the citrus still lurking in the shadows (but much brighter at the point of contact with the skin). Nicely done. One of the better unisex frags on the market.

Gorgeous, light and airy. Easily unisex, too (as it was meant to be). Easily one of Bond's best.

Bond No. 9’s Eau de New York does not suggest New York City to me. But it is a wonderful fragrance with a citrus-floral opening. I detect the bergamot, petitgrain, neroli and especially the jasmine. Then there is the gradual emergence of oakmoss-vetiver in the base. Definitely unisex, clean and crisp. If you go to the Bond No. 9 website like I did today to try to learn more about Eau de New York, you will go through 3 or 4 pretty web pages only to find the following terse statement – NOTES: neroli, white lily, vetiver. I think that is a bit of an oversimplification to say the least. I forgive them (this time) and give it a hearty thumbs up!

Absolute favorite of mine. Unique and fresh. Total smell of quality oils as oes most Creed fragrances but has such a contemporary vibe that creed lacks -probably only negative about Creed I can think of..... At first I did not understand what made this smell the scent of the city (I am a resident New Yorker) but as i wear this scent - albiet expensive and longevity is weak - it makes me smile with every use and evokes happiness and gives me a sudden burst of energy.... And isn't that what this great city does for true NYers?!

Quality, but a bit boring and too typical. It starts off quite floral - the "blossom" in the orange blossom is apparent here. Dries down nicely, the floral-ness of the florals somewhat softens, the scent rounds off a bit more and what you are left with is a crisp, greenish, floral, citrus scent. I'd say unisex, but leaning feminine in my opinion. Decent longevity, but nothing mind-blowing. Overall, it's nice enough but nothing that would part me from my hundred or so dollars.

Bergamot and Jasmine - not really unique but pleasant to smell! I like the musk dry down. Yes, it is expensive but it is well-blended and more refined than a lot of other similiar scents.

I find the fast-paced stimulation of large cities to be comforting. I know that's unusual. Atmospheres typically considered to be "comforting" give me anxiety attacks. I had one sitting on a beach on Maui, staring at the ocean... After that trip, when my plane landed at LAX, I felt like kissing the asphalt in the gritty parking lot. My last trip was more my speed (pun intended). I visited the city that's been my lifelong favorite - New York. I was inspired to give Eau de New York another try, and I'm glad I did. Eau de New York doesn't smell like New York. It smells citrusy, clean, and bright; all notes which I find to be energizing and stimulating. So, for me, Eau de New York is a comforting fragrance, even though the notes do not connote a specific olfactory memory.And I love that fabulous bottle.

I think this scent is wonderful! So fresh and with lasting power like no other! Reeks of quality and craftsmanship. Very unisex indeed!

I am suprised by the negative and neutral ratings. This is a favorite of mine, so fresh. I am an orange blossom, petit grain and neroli devotee, so perhaps that is why it is on my top list. Not too sweet like some petitgrain scents can be, this is clean with a interesting, hard to pin down drydown fragrance.

This was very strong and sharp on my skin. I had to wash it off after 10 minutes. It smelled like some ally that the winos had been using for a toilet to my nose. Maybe I'm just not sophisticated enough for this juice but I know what I don't like and and this is it.

I'm starting to realize that vetiver just isn't my note! Especially when it's mixed with a green base. I like the citrus notes in Eau de New York, but the veviter just totally overtakes them on my skin. Not one, I really care for on me. I added one lippie to my rating for unbelievable lasting power & sillage. This would smell better on a man in my opinion. Tho, I don't think it would be sexy on a man. Better suited for my grandpa or dad.