Coal (2012)
    by Andrea Maack

    Average Rating:
    Not enough ratings.

    Your Rating:
    You need to log in or register to rate

    Coal information

    Coal is a unisex fragrance by Andrea Maack. The scent was launched in 2012

    Reviews of Coal

    + Add your Review

    Showing 1 to of 2 reviews.
    positive No Positive Reviews • neutral2 Neutral Reviewsnegative No Negative Reviews

    drseid's avatar

    United States United States

    Show all reviews



    Coal, Or A Lump of Coal?...

    Coal opens with a gin-like juniper berry and very subtle pink pepper tandem, as a sweet near sugary accord permeates the composition early. As it reaches the early heart the juniper berry disappears, leaving the pink pepper and slightly diminished sweetness to meld with a strong slightly synthetic papyrus and dark coal-like woody accord with hints of rough leather rising from the base. As the fragrance transitions to the late dry-down the woods and leather never quite recede as they now support newly uncovered patchouli that steals the starring role with the earlier underlying sweetness now all but extinct. Projection is below average and longevity is average at 7-9 hours on skin.

    Coal has an amazing list of published notes that I expected to love based on my similar preferences. What I did *not* expect was the rather significant sweetness that hits you right from the open, lasting well into the heart phase of the fragrance's development. What I also did not expect (or desire) were the tell-tale traces of synthetics used to approximate the papyrus and coal woody heart accord... My guess is it is my nemesis norlimbanol as the culprit. That said, the synthetics in Coal are much more skillfully integrated than the norm with the overall effect improving as time passes. The bottom line is the $135 per 50ml bottle Coal has its moments and is certainly a cut above the norm, but it never quite reaches its potential, held back by synthetics and overt sweetness, earning a "good" rating of 3 out of 5 stars.

    Pros: Different than most releases nowadays...
    Cons: Sweetness, and it's overt synthetic dark woody nature...

    08th September, 2013 (Last Edited: 13th December, 2013)

    onaluna's avatar

    United States United States

    Show all reviews




    Update: This last sample I tried from Luckyscent was sweet and lacked the crisp, smokey, incense aspects of the first 2 samples I tried. :(

    From the description, I expected this to be more bitter/dusty and mineral-like. But it opens with a rich, smooth, nutty note, edged with only hints of dry pepper.

    After this rather warm, creamy intro comes a crisp paper and coal dust accord. Oh! It really is like being in the studio, with — to quote Mark Behnke of Çafleurebon — the rasp of coal against the paper. It dries down to an amazing burnt sugar/lightly smokey white incense scent that lasts for HOURS.

    It's a perfect interpretation of Andrea Maack's coal on color line drawing (see link below). I want a full bottle, SOON! And I wish she would put her coal/color drawing on the bottle. That would be lovely.

    Video and
    Çafleurebon review here:

    Cons: Icky sweet."

    30th July, 2013

    Add your review of Coal

    You need to be logged in to add a review

    Search for on eBay

    Sorry. We couldn't find any products on Ebay at the moment. Some related products are below:

    Member images of Coal

    There are no member images of Coal yet. Why not be the first?

    You need to log in or register to upload images

Loving perfume on the Internet since 2000