After a rather iffy aromachemical impact at first, this eventually settled to become a ringer for Alexandre J.'s Rose Oud for me.
I find both a bit overwhelming. Rose Oud doesn't develop or change much over hours so Tobacco Rose may be more acceptable to anyone who wants something in the same vein with less persistence.
Thanks to the kindness of La Flaneuse I got to try this, from a dabbing sample vial.
For me, Salome recalls the drydown of vintage Opium, fading on your clothes from the glory that was Opium freshly applied a day or two earlier. Accordingly, I miss the spiciness and thus find Salome lacking.
I have vintage Opium galore, and even have Nohiba to enjoy, and they more than suffice so I shan't seek Salome to bring either to mind as a partial re-creation.
Not one to buy without testing it first because there's something in this house's scents that simply doesn't play nicely on everyone's skin or on their clothes.
It gave off an insistent and persistent metallic fug on me, and I'm sure it wasn't meant to do that! Very hard to clean off as well.
A rose garden, fresh and realistic.
I'm sure that there will be folk who like this scent. My only problem is that I've used a furniture spray polish in the past that has the same scent, and that's not ideal. It isn't the fault of the fragrance, of course, but it isn't a great association.
Tested from a dab on sample vial, which may account for why I didn't get any smoky or spicy notes.
Put me in the vanilla creme anglaise/custard camp for this sweet and creamy floral fragrance. Delicious, and long-lasting for a dabbed on sample (which I applied quite generously).
It wore quite close to the skin after a few hours, which is reasonable for dabbed on edt, but it was still delicious when I sought it out, with a golden quality, like warm sunshine. One to investigate further.
Testing a dab-on sample from teardrop (thanks!) on OH and me, we get coal-tar soap from the off; a dried-out creosoted fence; and the dry-down of Guerlain Vetiver/herbs. Nary a bit of leather to be had.
OH had hoped for some tobacco, given other reviews of this scent, but it was not to be.
I do like coal-tar/creosote/phenols but would I want them when I was expecting leather?
Results may differ when sprayed but when dabbed there's no leather.
It's a proper Perfume - a confident and elegant Perfume with a capital P. Charming, lasts very well, stays close to the wearer. Very Good.
I'm posting because I have a question: did no-one else get "green olives in brine" from SDV?
I tried it in the depths of winter, for comfort and lusciousness, and I sniffed it and it smelled just like "green olives in brine" on my wrists. I do like olives but I was expecting something very different from SDV.
I'll try it again (can't due to a cold at present) before the weather gets too much warmer, but did anyone else get any "olives" at all from SDV??
(In case it's weird chemistry, I'm not a smoker or drinker - I don't even drink fermented tea or any coffee - and I'm a vegetarian. Perhaps high-end French perfume isn't designed for someone like me?!)
Tried this at "The Perfume Shop" on a cardboard strip. It reminded me of another scent but I couldn't put a name to it, although it does smell like a bar of creamy 1970s soap.
Hours later, having left the cardboard strip in an enclosed dark place, the smell puts me in mind of the scent of just-ironed laundry, where you've used a steam iron or pressed the linen/clothes while they're damp. Maybe the smell that's in the back of my mind *was* a 1970s laundry detergent or bar of soap? I can't pin it down.
I'd love it if someone with a better memory recall would test this and say what I'm half-remembering.
I'm giving it a neutral rating because I didn't get to try it on my skin and because it seems to fit Ms Aniston's reported brief (not a "notice me!" Perfume but a gentle, quiet, soft ambience of cleanliness).
I understand that mention of cucumber - Donna Karan Gold, upon initial application to my wrists, has a cucumbery or vegetable squash-like aspect just at the start for a few seconds only. Typically, thereafter all is voluptuously creamy florals and heavenly decadence wafting from my wrists.
However, today, in the interests of finding out whether this unexpected aspect would occur or perhaps last longer if I applied Gold elsewhere, I spritzed the throat/cleavage area two times and - lo and behold! - a more cucumbery and then a gentle "just-finished freshly discarded juicy pear-core or apple-core" smell was apparent amidst the usual loveliness. (Can't express it any better, I'm afraid!) Again, I didn't find it off-putting but I hadn't encountered it before. This fruit-core scent is lasting with the scent. It has never been apparent during my usual wrists-only applications.
My wrists smell wholly different to my throat/cleavage using the same scent!
So did the others who found these unusual and unexpected vegetative or fruity scents use Gold on the throat, wrists, both, or elsewhere? (Well, I'm intrigued now ...)
Delicious, long-lasting on the skin under clothing. Utterly enchanting fragrance. 100% positive rating.
I tried this on its own and it made me think of BNTBTBB Breath of God and Superworldunknown, so I tried it again on my wrists with Breath of God in the crook of one arm and Superworldunknown in the crook of the other.
Naturally the initial smokiness of BoG chimed with the gentle smokiness of The Smell of Weather Turning but the mint of TSoWT sang out clearly throughout: each scent differed and I couldn't figure out why the new one had prompted thoughts of the earlier scents. I'll have to try it again and keep trying.
I didn't get the idea of the weather turning, sadly, but that might come in time. It is great to find compelling and challenging scents readily available at pretty modest prices, by which I mean scents that don't give up all their secrets at the first test.
(In my group test, Breath of God was the most compelling of the three. It really has rewarded patience and is definitely worth trying - in a small area with a small amount - and allowing time for it to change and change and change again on your skin. Irresistible.)
A lot of oomph! If you like jasmine, get a sample and give it a whirl. It lasts and lasts.
This is delicious. Honey, blossom honey, honeyed florals. Long-lasting and evocative of sweet, rich summer warmth. Yum.
Delicate and delectable, warm and reassuring. A hug in a bottle.
The weirdest scent memory occurred to me today. I put on Jil Sander Style Pastels Soft Yellow for the first time and it immediately called another scent to mind. After racking my brains - the other scent's name was nearly on the tip of my tongue but wouldn't fully emerge! - I finally hit upon it. It smells like Poeme after Poeme has mellowed down for a few hours.
I like Poeme, in small doses and on the right occasion, and I didn't expect that immediate "scent echo" from Jil Sander Style Pastels Soft Yellow. Does any other Basenotes reviewer find the same thing?
I've since seen that there are internet-supplied notes in common: orange blossom, freesia, vanilla, amber, but did anyone else get this experience too? It isn't just me is it?
Very very potent bright satsuma citrus - great for cheering one up on a grey wintry day. It is true that it lasts and lasts and lasts and then lasts some more. I like it occasionally, and it is great in the room fragrance oil version (one drop alone in the oil burner does the job for the house!). Good value because the merest hint of it suffices. For citrus-lovers only.
It is very good. Softest citrus and gentle woody/musky base, with good longevity as it fades and mellows and softens but never disappears. An absolute bargain for a summer scent.
This was one of the first Penhaligon's fragrances that I took to immediately. The spices balance and also enhance the richness of the lily scent. Very moreish. (I must compare with Donna Karan Gold.)
Fresh and refreshing - another great scent for reviving a flagging soul on a sultry day. Very well-priced too. A trip to the seaside when you can't take time off!
Feminine and comforting - the heliotrope is responsible for the luxuriously comforting quality, I think. Lasts very well and doesn't overpower the wearer or the people around them. A truly charming fragrance.
The one to go to for a wake-up call. Fresh ginger, freshly grated so it has the sharp lemony tang - wow! So refreshing.
I've given away the EdT of this which is probably lighter, airier than the EdP.
The scent is delicate and sweet in the air, but it isn't "right" on me.
I didn't realise it had so many fans. I had it shut away before giving it to someone who loves it!
14th May, 2010 (last edited: 17th March, 2012)
Glorious and uplifting lemonade rose. It's a tonic for the body, with real rose oil and dazzlingly zesty citrus. It isn't overwhelming, just fresh and revitalising all day - it has real lasting power too, mellowing but staying true for hours and hours. I can't for the life of me understand why this was discontinued.
Essential for a hot, busy day - wearing it is like carrying your own private garden with you, the roses soothe and the sparkling citrus keeps you alert and ready for anything.
My remaining half-bottle is my treasure. I wish it was still available.
A gentle white floral. Very feminine and subtle. I wish I had the nose that would enable me to pick out the notes for you - apart from "rose" and "orange blossom" and "fragrant white flowers" I'm stuck!
(I haven't tried the new formulation which sounds intriguing. A comparison would be great. Luckily I have a practically full 50 ml bottle of the original so I don't have to panic if the reformulation does away with the original.)
I found this to be a delicate floral with hints of fruitiness. It was lovely, on a cold, snowy day, to catch hints of this as I soldiered along on busy city streets: it seemed warm and colourful on a cold bleak day. There was no way for me to identify individual notes as it seemed to keep changing. Very likeable, for me. (It must be different on different people.)
Definitely give this fragrance time to develop - the initial smokiness is compelling and I certainly couldn't stop checking to find out how it would change (even *when* it would change!). Compulsive and intriguing.
Ravishing. Glorious. Not to be missed.
Much better than Berkeley Square's aggressive Fig and Cherry, which overpowered me with sweetness and fruit that went on forever. This has soft. light, delicate almost sparkling notes in comparison, which is delightful and fresh in the summer heat.
(My review just disappeared: I'm new to this so forgive me if this goes wrong.)
White Tea by Berkeley Square would be delightful whilst listening to nightingales. It is everything that Fig and Cherry wasn't. This is soft, light, delicate and almost sparkling with bright but not harsh top notes; it mellows and develops but stays delightful and fresh on a hot summer's day or sultry humid summer's night. The hand cream that accompanied my scent is well-perfumed and long-lasting too. All in all, a much better offering from Berkeley Square.