Fragrance Reviews
Fragrance Reviews by Sardu
Showing all 14 reviews
Ho Hang Club by Balenciaga
Unlike its predecessor Ho Hang, which is a masterpiece in subtlety and takes at least two sprays to work, this one comes out full bore and has more in common with something like Trussardi. The whole thing is coated with the exact same honey note found in the much lamented Balenciaga Pour Homme. Great scent for the unafraid.
30 May 2007
Déclaration by Cartier
I declare... what? That I am a cardamom pod? Get Cacharel's Nemo instead, which uses this ingredient properly.
19 January 2007
Rykiel Homme by Sonia Rykiel
A friendly berry scent that gives off lots of sweet emanations, and evokes an overall ambiance of happiness and good feeling. But at the same time it remains dry at its core, and scores a perfect zero on the sappy/cloying scale. This means that it is the ONLY acceptable berry-based scent for men. All of the others (Wings, Dunhill Desire, Disel Zero Plus....) should stay in your bathroom, preferably as toilet fresheners.
05 November 2005
Hummer by Hummer
Hypermasculine mix of woods and spices is, curiously, completely non-sexual. (Thus it's safe for daytime wear). Then again, what would you expect from a cologne named after a jeep? Clearly designed for the man who prefers outdoor to bedroom adventures, but on those terms it's pretty good.
19 August 2005
Lolita Lempicka Au Masculin Fraicheur by Lolita Lempicka
I too like the original version better, but let's face it -- that stuff blows people away. I remember when I got a spray of the original on a card. I took it to the bar and gave it to the guy next to me to smell. He took a whiff, recolied, and asked me if I was trying to kill him. So that's why there's a need for this lighter version. It has just enough of what makes the original great, but you can wear it during the day without embarrasment; you can even wear it in summer. Watered-down Lempicka is regular strength when compared against most other colognes.
19 August 2005
Habit Rouge by Guerlain
Great stuff, but I really don't see what's rouge about it. I rather think that this is white: I wear one spray of this (no more -- it's strong) to work when there's a foot of snow on the ground, which is most days between December and March here in Ottawa. It's just so appropriate for winter.
25 May 2005
Van Gils by Van Gils
More patchouli horror. Not as offensive as Givenchy Gentleman, but that's not saying much.
09 May 2005
Ungaro III by Ungaro
Probably the best fragrance I own. I am unable to disentangle all of the flowers, woods and who-knows-what-else that are in here because they have been blended so expertly. Everything hits you all at once and fires up a wide range of receptors, making this fragrance compelling and addictive. The only possible downside is that this is too rich and elegant for daytime use.
26 March 2005
L'Essence de Must de Cartier by Cartier
True to its billing, this is stronger, longer lasting, and easier to sense than the original. But by ramping everything up like this, you lose the subtle, soft elegance that is the original's reason for being.
26 March 2005
Weekend for Men by Burberry
Extremely sharp citrus blend. Some might find this relaxed or casual, but I just find it crass.
26 March 2005
Antaeus by Chanel
The dominant patchouli note brings to mind Givenchy Gentleman. But, unlike that vile, loathesome brew, this one doesn't punch you in the nose. The patchouli here has pleasant, complementary things mixed with it, making the cologne a bit more restrained and a lot more refined. If you wear, or are thinking of wearing Gentleman or some other patchouli horror, do yourself and those around you the favour of wearing this instead.
26 March 2005
Safari for Men by Ralph Lauren
100% masculine, but easy on the nose: it has absolutely no elements that are jarring, boorish or overbearing. Just perfect for the office.
14 January 2005
Intuition for Men by Estée Lauder
There is nothing wrong with this intrinsically. The problem is that this is labeled as a men's cologne -- it is most assuredly only for women. A man who wears this is sending the wrong message. I wouldn't hesitate to ravage any woman who had this on. But then, wouldn't a woman be better off with the original version?
18 December 2004
Givenchy Gentleman by Givenchy
This will certainly get attention all right. But you could also get attention by, for example, rubbing dog urine all over yourself. Extremely unpleasant, and I can't think of anyone for whom this cologne would be appropriate -- not even the "old men" to whom we usually relegate scents we don't like.
10 December 2004











