From the ratings I see, hardcore Le Male lovers didn't like it, but that doesn't mean that should be so much hate about this just fine fragrance. It doesn't smell cheap or bad, expect nothing and you'll be never dissapointed.
About the fragrance, it truly reminds of L'Instant Eau Extreme drydown, but it has more of a chocolate vibe instead of the cacao from the Guerlain's, and the fig note make it quite different.
A simple fragrance for people who don't want to smell like everyone else.
Already said, but Parfum edition is more natural reformulated and surpass this one.