This stuff is really really bad IMO. Personally I enjoyed Realities, Graphite Blue on the hand smells like dead flowers, mold, and crayons. That's the only way I can really describe it. I got a 3.4 oz bottle at TJ Maxx for 10 bucks, there's a reason they were practically giving it away, because it isn't even worthy of being on TJ Maxx's Shelves.
Although this smells nothing like previous Liz Claiborne failures such as Curve Crush and Mambo.. which are fruitier colognes, Graphite Blue is somewhat in it's own league, but not in a good way either.
I find the other reviews on this to be misleading, try Graphite Blue for yourself.. it's always on sale, there's a good chance you'll try to return it, sell it, or give it to someone as a gift. Graphite Blue gets an F in my book.