Sugar Cookie is a miss as far as Iím concerned. I get a rather solid synthetic note, but the worst of it is that I canít identify the smell with the smell of the sugar cookies Iím familiar with: I donít perceive sugar cookies as being spicy. I am used to the plain sugar and vanilla cookies and thatís all I want to smell: sugar, butter, and vanilla. I guess things can go wrong when you try to olfactorily duplicate memories from childhood: Everyoneís memories are a bit different, all use their own recipes. On my skin Sugar Cookie has the poor longevity typical of most Demeters.