post #1 of 34
Thread Starter 

I am not sure if I am keeping it or not.  The opening is really really nice.  My wife loves the opening as well.  I reminded us of a mix of Encre Noire, Cartier Declaration, and Terre D Hermes.  Encre Noir I really like except the dark dirtyness of it.  EN does have a bit of clean vibe to it which is what I really like/want.  Sycomore's opening has more of that clean vibe and less dirtyness.  Sycomore is something that I can wear year around.  The dry down of Sycomore to me is too woody and sweet.

 

BUT for $130, I don't know if it is worth it.  EN is much cheaper and I think the EN dry down is as good if not better than Sycomore.  EN also seems more complex.  Sycomore on the other hand blows EN away in the opening.  I only sampled EN years ago (sample is empty now but I can still smell) but it seems to be something that I only use on rare occasions kind of like Narciso Rodriguez for him.  NR I only where a few times a year.  I just can't pull it off most of the time.

 

 

Comparison

Price: EN $34 compared to Sycomore $130

Opening: Sycomore  much better

Drydown: Encre Noire

Projection: EN

Longevity: Both last long but EN longer

Versatility: Sycomore

Complexity: EN

 

Should I keep it?

Can or does anyone where EN in the summer?