I like Jaipur Homme, but here are the criticisms I have read :
It is too floral in the opening with the heliotrope.
It is too feminine ( vanilla).
It is too vanilla-like smelling and resembles Le Male in a way.
It is too powdery ( some say it is creamy, however) in the dry down.
It is too dandyish in its style ( floral opening, a powdery barbershoppy vanilla dry down).
It is too sweet and sickly ( well, I would imagine on a warm or hot day it would not be a preferred scent choice).
Hope that helps.