There aren't many bad reviews on this guy. It's a nice scent but way too sweet and nowhere as classy smelling as some people make it out to be. In my opinion this stuff is a perfect choice for the 'mature' high school students. Not necessarily for someone who wears a suit and tie, but for the kid that wears nice fitting button-ups and jeans/chinos.
I'm sorry if I've offended one of your favorites but I just don't get why this is gets the praise it does. Am I alone here?