Luckyscent is great, nothing but good stories about them. If you want to try them in person they carry them at most Barney's (though they do not carry the eau de colognes there in my experience)
My personal favorite s Wonderwood, with CdG 2 Man at a close second. Almost grabbed a bottle of that today actually...
CdG 2 is also quite good if you're comfortable with florals. I wear floral frags a lot, but I found this too feminine for my tastes. Great scent though.
I'd also recommend at least sampling the incense series, as one of them (can't remember off the top of my head which it was) is quite good
In august they're also launching a trio of new frags, a blue line. An incense, a cedar and a santal. Worth a look when they do come out. I know I'll be sampling