Niche or not matters little to me, I'm not the peculiar nor snobbish type. Just hoping for more than one option.
Thanks again, and as always all!
I am going to assume that you are looking for a "masculine vanilla" that is distinctly gourmand in character as there are a ton of male fragrances that have a perceptible vanilla note but which aren't particularly "foodie" (like AMen, for example)
For a straight up vanilla, check Serge Luten's "Une Bois Vanille" or Givenchy "Pi".
For a maple-y vanilla, try Christian Dior "Eau Noire"
For a coffee vanilla, try "Michael Jordan Legend" - super cheap but very good - $12.99 at Ross