I can only comment on Aomassai as I haven't smelt the other. I had a sample of Aomassai for about a year and loved it on every testing. Finally bought a full bottle a few weeks back ready for the Autumn/Winter. Worn it a few times in the evenings and loving it, i really like the sweet hazelnut, caramel, liquorice and vanilla vibe. I think this is going to do great in the cold.