John Varvatos- which edition is better?

    John Varvatos- which edition is better?

    post #1 of 13
    Thread Starter 

    Hello, all!

    I must buy a bottle of J.V., yet know not which is superior- John Varvatos, Artisan, Artisan Black, Vintage, 10th Anniversary, or Star USA.

    May I have your input, please, this must be done this week.

    I'm sincerely grateful!

    Pattease

    post #2 of 13

    In order:

    1. John Varvatos

    2. Artisan Black

    3. Vintage

    4. Artisan

    5. 10th Anniversary

    6. Star USA

    post #3 of 13
    I like Artisan Black but it just doesn't have much longevity on me.
    post #4 of 13

    Artisan is my favorite scent out of them, but longevity is horrible.

    John Varvatos is also a nice smelling one that lasts a little longer and works well in cooler weather.

    post #5 of 13

    I like the original John Varvatos best.

    post #6 of 13

    Black

    Star the worst

    None lasts

    post #7 of 13
    Personally I have tried a few from this house and have never found any I found appealing.
    post #8 of 13
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by DiamondflameView Post

    I like the original John Varvatos best.

    +1

    I seem to remember there being 2 versions -- maybe EDT and EDP?

    post #9 of 13
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by KaernView Post

    +1

    I seem to remember there being 2 versions -- maybe EDT and EDP?

    I wish there was an EDP, that would be awesome... maybe you are thinking of the Vintage version?

    post #10 of 13
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by mjones602View Post

    I wish there was an EDP, that would be awesome... maybe you are thinking of the Vintage version?

    I meant 2 versions of the 'vintage' when it first came on the market -- I'm probably wrong

    post #11 of 13

    The only one I remotely like is Artisan.

    Having said that, I don't own any of the J.V. fragrances anymorebecause the performance is sub-par like others have stated.

    post #12 of 13
    Thread Starter 

    Many thanks for your time and response.

    P

    post #13 of 13

    I like Vintage.

    class="

    9/1/13 at 10:05pm

    Pattease said:



    Hello, all!

    I must buy a bottle of J.V., yet know not which is superior- John Varvatos, Artisan, Artisan Black, Vintage, 10th Anniversary, or Star USA.

    May I have your input, please, this must be done this week.

    I'm sincerely grateful!

    Pattease

    9/3/13 at 12:07am

    mjones602 said:



    In order:

    1. John Varvatos

    2. Artisan Black

    3. Vintage

    4. Artisan

    5. 10th Anniversary

    6. Star USA

    9/3/13 at 3:43am

    bimmer1 said:



    I like Artisan Black but it just doesn't have much longevity on me.

    9/3/13 at 4:22am

    dougczar said:



    Artisan is my favorite scent out of them, but longevity is horrible.

    John Varvatos is also a nice smelling one that lasts a little longer and works well in cooler weather.

    9/3/13 at 4:23am

    Diamondflame said:



    I like the original John Varvatos best.

    9/3/13 at 5:29am

    Tony T said:



    Black

    Star the worst

    None lasts

    9/3/13 at 6:41am

    hednic said:



    Personally I have tried a few from this house and have never found any I found appealing.

    9/3/13 at 6:49am

    Kaern said:



    Quote:
    Originally Posted by DiamondflameView Post

    I like the original John Varvatos best.

    +1

    I seem to remember there being 2 versions -- maybe EDT and EDP?

    9/3/13 at 1:38pm

    mjones602 said:



    Quote:
    Originally Posted by KaernView Post

    +1

    I seem to remember there being 2 versions -- maybe EDT and EDP?

    I wish there was an EDP, that would be awesome... maybe you are thinking of the Vintage version?

    9/4/13 at 2:28am

    Kaern said:



    Quote:
    Originally Posted by mjones602View Post

    I wish there was an EDP, that would be awesome... maybe you are thinking of the Vintage version?

    I meant 2 versions of the 'vintage' when it first came on the market -- I'm probably wrong

    9/4/13 at 5:25am

    BoChosen said:



    The only one I remotely like is Artisan.

    Having said that, I don't own any of the J.V. fragrances anymorebecause the performance is sub-par like others have stated.

    9/4/13 at 1:49pm

    Pattease said:



    Many thanks for your time and response.

    P

    9/5/13 at 1:08pm

    sjg3839 said:



    I like Vintage.





Loving perfume on the Internet since 2000