I love the top, every time I smell it I feel like I need to buy. But then after a while it falls apart on me, I am not a fan of the base, which is ok but not as exciting. Which seems to be the case of all the frag of the jardin noir. Good top, but then they lose themselves. it almost looks like they were a hurried job - good basic ideas not properly worked out. In any case, OdH is my favorite among the 4 too.
That said, Paco Rabanne Metal, also based on hyacinth, is on another planet.