I don't see much love for these two. I own both (I only own three colognes, the other being GIT) and absolutely love them. To me they are somewhat similar but different enough to warrant owning them. I get incredible longevity out of them and better sillage with of Himalaya. I can't tell you how many times I've received compliments on these two, with Chanel probably edging out Himalaya in the compliment department. Anyways, thought I'd see what everyone else thinks.