Basenotes › Directory › Fragrances › Charogne by Etat Libre d'Orange, 2007

Charogne by Etat Libre d'Orange, 2007

Charogne by Etat Libre d'Orange, 2007
81% Positive Reviews
Rated #1680 in Fragrances

Posted
Opens as a mild chest embrocation before dying in a muddle of sweet like so many Etats do. One of those 'life's too short' perfumes.

Posted
Musky and plasticky vanilla with a strange note of decomposing flowers. I was expecting an edgier experience, but it's beautiful and nice. I can imagine a muse in Montmartre wearing this at the end of the XIXth century...

Posted
Eldo's politic when it comes to naming frags has always focused on provocation and Charogne makes no exception. So many times we witnessed a launch of one of their fragrances expecting to smell something "out of the world", "extraterrestrial", but too many times we just found that the majority of their compositions where anything but weird (Tom Of Finland, Je Suis Un Homme, Eloge Du Traitre, Antiheros, Fat Electrician etc. etc.). In this context, Charogne definitely makes an exception being one of the very few that lived up to its name (Vierges y Toreros, Secretions Magnifique, Jasmin et Cigarette). A rancid indolic accord joined by vanilla and animalic leather while white florals fly over very low. The overall effect is pretty odd but at the same time fascinating. There's something very intimate and private in Charogne, something you could only share with your long term partner, like chewing a bubblegum that just came out from his/her mouth. Not among my favorite fragrances but still a great example of a "weird-composition".

Posted
Something in the top notes is vaguely familiar.I know Ive smelled this stuff before, but where?? Then it hits me after reading the other reviews. It is a strong indolic scent that reminds me of work with it in chemistry lab. It is accompanied by a slight flowery note with hints of lavender that soften over time. At its base, vanilla with hints of leather take over. A bit of musk is in there as well. This is truly a unique scent and one that Id have to give a thumbs up for just this. Is it wearable? Not quite sure, though I bet there are some occasions it would fit in just fine.

Posted

Carrion huh? Well, I do get a hint of the obvious implication: I can recognize the stinky part of the opening, but it doesnt come through very strongly for me so I find it easy to not comment on that particular miasma. The bubblegum shows up a little later, though, and moots the whole point of carrion or bad breath or whatever. Ive experienced many fragrances with a bubblegum note (yawn), but this one offers a very decent one. This bubblegum comes with a light leather note that creates an accord that I find quite enjoyable: a little sweet and a bit animalic accord that is pleasantly conflicting, and, consequently, interesting. The florals of the heart provide another aromatic detour from the beginning malodor with a soft floral texture that is modern, engaging, and well done. The drydown is downright excellent in a soft, gentle vanilla, leather and musk accord. I thoroughly enjoy the basenotes of Charogne And they provide adequate sillage but could use a bit more longevity. All things told a very nice fragrance.

Posted
JUICY FRUIT chewed at an open-casket viewing.

Utter perdition and detritus mixed with the most tongue-smacking, sweet, candylike, smiling gustatory deliciousness.

Remember when British Saatchi artist Damien Hirst came up with his collection of paintings celebrating medicines, hospitals, capsules, flasks, pills, colored elixirs, medicine labels? This is the milieu to which CHAROGNE takes me.
But we must never forget that CHAROGNE is about Death. That Big Thing. By giving it that very name, it appears ELD'O makes no bones about the fact that there is a Death allusion underfoot. Some reviewers have even given CHAROGNE the nickname "The Exquisite Corpse". Not rotting--- but caught just in time....freshly embalmed with formaldehyde, powdered and cosmeticized. Pretty as you please.
It's kind of like Tim Burton's CORPSE BRIDE. She's so beautiful, so gracious, so sweet, so charming, so lovable, so attractive. But there's just one thing: She's Dead. Dance with her, caress her, court her, kiss her even.... but you can't marry her.
That's how CHAROGNE operates: Sweet, mixed- fruit-flavored CERTS scrounged from a kidskin purse, plastic toys, cellophaned flowers, and.....uh.......Death. Like Damien Hirst's genuine human skull, encrusted with thousands of real diamonds. It's beautiful, it's Art, it's precious... and it's Dead.
This, to me, makes CHAROGNE even more taboo and outrageous than ELDO's other bad-boy, SeCReTIONS MAGNIFIQUES. Yet it is anything but a dark or emo or Goth scent. Au contraire.
Do I love this Post-Modern fragrance? Like you wouldn't believe. Going on my third bottle of it.

Posted
WOW. Something familiar yet different. It is like smelling a non-descript flower. A new flower that has been recently discovered in a crazy landscape.
Maybe a flower that grows in Tim Burton´s Underland smell this way.
It is sharp, metalic, spicy, sweet and plasticky but not animallic. I don´t sense very much the indoles (as lot of people seem to do) I get white flowers, decaying petals, metallic incense (similar to that found in Nu edp).
It starts sweet and tart, like a mixture of bergamot leaves and Jasmine with a very spicy peppery edge. This is an incredibly different accord that I find very attractive.
Then a littler leather (suede like), white flowers bouquet and hints of vanilla and metatalic incense. Later on, the base is strong vanilla and some incense and flowers.
The final stage reminds me of Kenzo Amour.
I find a clear cinnamon accord, but not a typical cinnamon bark. It smells exactly like cinnamon candies, more precisely Altoids.
This is a very complex everchanging blend, long lasting (8+ hs) that proyects a lot during the first hour and then quiets down.

Posted
Etat scents are witty and companionable. (except Jasmin & Cigarettes......made me dizzy and faint). They are however actually often fuzzily similar the closer you look at them, the same notes roll across the varied scents despite the sometimes tiresome blurbs that try and spin a enticing world of cod-erotica. Judged as scents some are excellent. I do like Charogne, it has an off note i like, the scent of a clove orange on the turn, in a wardrobe with leather shoes and lived in clothes. Remember playing Sardines as a child? Perhaps crushed into that wardrobe with someone you secretly loved? The heat, the tensed excitement, bubblegum, shampoo, skin and the strange yet familiar scents of the space while a clock ticks and hearts beat faster.

I find it a little short in the lasting though, this affects my rating. Compared to Etat's Rien, which stays on despite decontamination procedures......Charogne falls short. A pity, i think the base lacks something. But for a little while it is rather beautiful.

Posted
Hmm. Very interesting. The first 90 minutes smell like somone with chronic halitosis who has tried to cover it up by chewing a piece of Double Bubble chewing gum. Candy sweet and slightly minty, which doesn't quite cover up the odor of gingivitis and tooth decay. I really didn't care for this phase, but Charogne eventually dries down to a more wearable floral musk, with a pronounced jasmine note on my skin. Very soft and subtle after that initial blast of stink.

I give it a neutral mostly for being so unique and layered. This is not one I would purchase and wear, but I enjoyed testing it.

Posted
It is difficult to cut to the chase, because each Etat Libre d'Orange fragrance comprises a name, a concept, a drawing, a narrative, a scent, and a cultural reference. If the word "Charogne" [carrion] does not inspire trepidation, then the association with Baudelaire's poem "Une Charogne" will give most scent samplers pause. In Baudelaire's 12-stanza memento mori, the poet recalls a warm summer day when he and his lover came upon a creature rotting in the afternoon sun. The poet points out that one day his lover will be just like that carcass, devoured and decomposed by the kisses of vermin; yet her divine essence will live on in the poet's immortal compositions.

The sample package of "Charogne" features a rose sketched in black and white with a drop of red blood at the center: perhaps a nod to Baudelaire's Flowers of Evil, or to the theme of death, beauty and the printed page.

But on to the fragrance.

Does ELO's "Charogne" smell like the putrid carcass described in the poem? Not at all. It is, like Baudelaire's verse, oddly seductive. Bergamot and ylang ylang provide an almost too sweet initial impression, soon tamed by the softest leather. Vanilla and incense emerge over ambrette and undefined "animalc notes". These are not the heavy doses civet or castoreum I would have expected. There is an undeniable warmth to the base, but it has the strange yet familiar indolic freshness of jasmine. The overall effect is that of layered fragility and earth. Like all of the ELO fragrances I've sampled, Charogne lasts a long time, without loud sillage.

I leave it to you to enjoy the little narrative in the sample package and on the web site. To me it reads as a metaphor of the scent's development over time on the wearer. I am nearly convinced by the last line: "How could one do without it?" But the scent in itself, without all of the words and images it evokes, would be pretty. Not striking. That's right, the "divine essence" that makes this fragrance transcendent depends upon the art of language.

Despite the beauty of the scent, I shudder when I think of the name, and in this way , too, "Charogne" echos "Une Charogne."

For a truly delicious and decadent experience, read the poem as you inhale the scent from your skin, or from the skin of another. You will be transported.
Charogne by Etat Libre d'Orange, 2007
Description:

Details:
DetailValue
Launched Date2007
GenderNeutral
PerfumerShyamala Maisondieu
AvailabilityIn Production
ByEtat Libre d'Orange
Base Notes
Bottle Designer
Middle Notes
Top Notes
Models:
Model Name/TypeMPNEAN/UPC
Start a guide on Charogne by Etat Libre d'Orange, 2007!
Basenotes › Directory › Fragrances › Charogne by Etat Libre d'Orange, 2007