Review by jtd
Is this the intermediate species between the classic amber oriental and the Lutens cedar oriental? Its 2002 birth date tells me no, but my nose says it could be. Histoire dEau is a smoky, spicy cedar/amber. There is just enough sweet amber to fall into the Shalimar camp, and enough cedar and fruit to be an SL Bois. It also has an opacity that sits right between Shalimars richness and SLs transparency. Unfortunately, the middle ground is not necessarily the ripest locale for inspiration. I cant help but feel with a few tweaks, this could have been spectacular. Ive only smelled SLs Daim Blond once, and while HdE does smell like it a bit at the outset, it doesnt hang together like Daim Blond. It doesnt so much fall apart as become flatter over the course of the heart. It rallies a bit in the drydown, leaving a pleasant but unexciting spicy cedar.