Pros: Similar to GPH I. Smells great.
Cons: A bit lacking in the longevity department.
Initial impression was that this was very similar to Gucci Pour Homme I (2003). With that I love the fragrance, but it's hard to wear in the summer. This is not the case with Potion. It's not as dense and the projection is cut in half which makes it a wearable in the hotter months. I get about 3 1/2 to 4 hours out of this and the projection is acceptable for that amount of time. As far as the comparison's to Dirty English, I really don't see it and this is much better in composition than Dirty English. Overall I really like this fragrance and it will be something I will wear quite a bit.