Search:

Type: Posts; User: drseid; Keyword(s):

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.06 seconds.

  1. Replies
    18
    Views
    787

    Poll: Re: Roja Parfums Diaghilev or Enigma?

    Both are great, but Diaghilev is superior to my nose.
  2. Replies
    18
    Views
    955

    Re: The Different Company

    Oud Shamash is my favorite, followed by Oud for Love.
  3. Replies
    30
    Views
    1,858

    Re: Promise by Frederick Malle

    This will surely be a blind buy for me. Ropion works wonders with Rose.
  4. Replies
    48
    Views
    3,609

    Poll: Re: Creed Royal Oud vs Spice and wood

    Royal Oud is good, Spice and Wood is terrible. Easy choice, IMO.
  5. Replies
    131
    Views
    8,361

    Re: Silentrich Tribute - Saturday 29th (7/29/2017)

    Boy, I had stepped back from perusing the forums for a while and had no idea of Rich's illness, nor his passing. So sad to return and see this thread. I wish I could pick a composition from his...
  6. Re: What are your top "heavy hitters" (please no sweet scents!) ?

    Just a few of many...

    Giorgio for Men (vintage)
    Portrait of a Lady (original formula)
    Bijan for Men (vintage)
    Polo (vintage)
    Norne
    Crown Imperial
  7. Replies
    54
    Views
    2,491

    Poll: Re: Which of these 8 fragrances is your favorite?

    Terre d'Hermès followed by Santal 33
  8. Replies
    2,658
    Views
    387,486

    Re: Fragrances that "WOW" you recently?

    Both Dryad by Papillon and Mem by Bogue were both winners from my latest sample order.
  9. Re: Considering another blindbuy - Javanese Patchouli

    I think it is not only a relatively safe blind buy, but also just a fabulous overall patch dominant/focused composition. If you enjoy soft patch presentations, it doesn't get any better, IMO. I...
  10. Re: Owners Only Deathmatch: Lauder for Men vs Antaeus

    This. Both great compositions in their original formulas.
  11. Replies
    7
    Views
    780

    Re: thoughts on Mendittorosa?

    Most of their line didn't impress, but Le Mat is the real deal and got me to buy. That is the one to sniff from the line, IMO.
  12. Re: Which of these three leather fragrances to go for?

    Bel Ami Vetiver
  13. Replies
    33
    Views
    2,464

    Re: Best oud fragrance with no rose?

    Oud Shamash by The Different Company
    Oud Luban by Aftelier
  14. Replies
    51
    Views
    3,807

    Poll: Re: Aventus vs Portrait of a lady

    Kind of a weird comparison, IMO. The two are so different. To me, at least, Portrait of a Lady is far superior. I think Aventus is mediocre at best.
  15. Replies
    57
    Views
    4,089

    Re: Patchouli - the best of the best

    Javanese Patchouli by Zegna for a patch focused play.

    Portrait of a Lady by Editions de Parfums Frederic Malle and Giorgio for Men (original formula) by Giorgio Beverly Hills for significant patch...
  16. Replies
    52
    Views
    4,611

    Re: Top 10 new releases of 2017

    Of those I have tried there is Superstitious, then everything else. Ropion creates another winner.
  17. Replies
    29
    Views
    2,299

    Re: Favourite zegna?

    Javanese Patchouli is the standout, but the whole Essenze line is terrific.
  18. Replies
    42
    Views
    2,550

    Re: Coolwater replacement?

    You can do a lot of gambling at the relatively low prices original formula Cool Water bottles go for compared to buying things like GIT and Chez Bond (not that there is anything wrong with either of...
  19. Replies
    29
    Views
    1,884

    Re: Drakkar Vs Giorgio

    This, although instead of Drakkar Noir in its current formulation, I suggest also sniffing Caesars Man which is similar smelling and less expensive. If we were talking original formulations it would...
  20. Replies
    9
    Views
    1,067

    Re: Bel Ami Vetyver and Aramis Calligraphy

    No similarities between the two to my nose,,,
  21. Replies
    70
    Views
    7,754

    Re: Roja dove overrated

    I find on the whole, the line is not overrated. Sure, the prices are lofty (too lofty for me in most cases) but the quality is there and I tend to like the smell of most of them plenty.
  22. Replies
    86
    Views
    6,660

    Re: Suggestions for Masculine Rose based scent

    Floris No. 89 may be the type of presentation you are looking for. Just try and seek out a vintage/original formula bottle if possible.
  23. Re: Will La nuit de L'homme ever be good again?

    It never was good (or even mediocre), IMO...
  24. Re: Just don't get no respect!! What fragrances don't get the respect they deserve?

    Both excellent. Too bad their distribution is so limited outside the U.K. I also agree with the earlier Floris Elite mention by another member. I have no idea what it smells like now, but in its...
  25. Re: Creed Millesime 1849 or Clive Christian no.1 for men

    I am not really a fan of either, but strongly prefer No. 1 of the two. I personally can't stand 1849.
  26. Re: which fragrance in your opinion has the best opening scent

    This one for me, too. I am also partial to the natural orange and lemon opening of Crown Imperial by the late Crown Perfumery.
  27. Re: Which to pick: Hermes Equipage current formulation or Equipage Geranium

    I prefer Equipage Geranium.
  28. Re: Grey vetiver or Bel Ami Vetiver

    For me, Bel Ami Vetiver without question. I find Grey Vetiver mundane.
  29. Re: So-called 'classic' fragrances that are still in circulation that should not be.

    Two greats in their original formulas. Why would one want to snuff out greatness? At the end of the day it is all a matter of personal tastes. If these two classics don't appeal to you, wear other...
  30. Replies
    34
    Views
    2,880

    Re: Polo alternatives

    Certainly Polo Crest has similarities to original Polo at times, but from top to bottom, nothing really. Polo is one of a kind.
  31. Replies
    92
    Views
    9,128

    Re: Luca Turin on Frederic Malle

    For me the line is extremely solid, with Portrait of a Lady easily a five star caliber composition, at least IMO.
  32. Re: Giorgio Beverly Hills For Men......Red Or Yellow?

    In their original/vintage formulations both are great, though I strongly prefer the "Yellow". Hard to make a bad choice with these two, just make sure you don't buy the current stuff of either.
  33. Re: Is there a better masterpiece out there contemporary than this? In designer

    Well, as far as I'm concerned you picked one of the best... I would argue the designer composition Tzora by Anat Fritz takes the best elements of Terre d'Hermes and improves on its greatness further.
  34. Replies
    265
    Views
    28,048

    Re: Basenote Members who've come and and gone -

    All fine here. :-). There has been a bit of a dry spell where I haven't been excited about most of the releases the past year and a half. That said, the latest Ropion Malle collaboration has forced...
  35. Replies
    2,658
    Views
    387,486

    Re: Fragrances that "WOW" you recently?

    Superstitious by Editions de Parfums Frederic Malle. It has been pretty boring the last year and a half but leave it to Ropion and Malle to come up with another big winner and get me interested in...
  36. Replies
    131
    Views
    10,264

    Re: Finally got Bentley Intense for men

    This sounds more like a descriptor of the superb perfume I own and love. The one described in the OP couldn't be much more different. Maybe there was indeed a reformulation, but what is being...
  37. Replies
    16
    Views
    1,984

    Re: Geir by Geir Ness

    I detest it. Two words describe this creature "Pepto Bismol."
  38. Replies
    56
    Views
    6,169

    Re: Giorgio Beverly Hills for Men

    It is the oakmoss. There is plenty of it in the dry-down, but the other components are so well-blended it doesn't stand out like some. The strength is not a problem at all with the reformulation. ...
  39. Replies
    18
    Views
    4,355

    Re: CH Men v CH Men Prive

    They certainly are different enough, but the Prive smells completely artificial and awful. If you must buy one of these two, then the CH Men is far superior smelling, IMO.
  40. Replies
    9
    Views
    1,885

    Re: Fendi Uomo Vintage

    Yes it is vintage, a powerhouse and damn good! It is in the vintage Giorgio for Men realm, smell-wise.
  41. Replies
    52
    Views
    6,542

    Re: 2016 - In review

    Only one new release this year got me to open my wallet...

    Adjatay by The Different Company -- a great floral leather
  42. Re: Ralph Lauren did Oud Supreme edp right... niche like

    Far from earth shattering, but I found it a very pleasant surprise when I tried it. I never bought a bottle, but did think about it. One of the best things Polo has released in ages.
  43. Re: Best Cedar and wood prominent Fragrances What do you guys think!?

    Classical by Anat Fritz
  44. Replies
    26
    Views
    2,687

    Re: Davidoff Leather Blend

    No way near their best perfume in a long time to my nose. It took me forever to track it down and paid a steep markup to have it shipped from overseas only to give it away. Needless to say I was...
  45. Replies
    30
    Views
    3,610

    Re: Bogart Pour Homme ?? thoughts

    I think it smells great and is an exceptional value. That said, don't try and convince yourself to like it. It may just not be your kind of perfume, and there is nothing wrong with that...
  46. Replies
    11
    Views
    1,564

    Re: House of Santi Burgas?

    One of the most disappointing houses I have come across. I disliked most of what I sniffed from it, and was indifferent to pretty much the rest. Very cheap smelling stuff, IMO.

    As to the perfume...
  47. Re: Dominique Ropion creates Messy Sexy Just Rolled out of Bed for A Lab on Fire

    Yikes, that was one of the worst things I have ever sniffed! If this smells even a smidge like that stinker, I will be seeking a nose clip pronto.
  48. Re: Dominique Ropion creates Messy Sexy Just Rolled out of Bed for A Lab on Fire

    I love Ropion, but this doesn't sound like anything I would want. Gourmand+A Lab On Fire = Auto Avoid
  49. Replies
    73
    Views
    9,664

    Poll: Re: Favorite Niche Fragrance House? (Poll)

    Editions de Parfum Frederic Malle
  50. Replies
    4,861
    Views
    376,622

    Re: Your vintage SOTD

    Vintage Bijan for Men
  51. Re: Frederic Malle collaborates with designer Alber Elbaz for upcoming launch, Superstitious

    Malle... Ropion... Deal me in!
  52. Re: If I didn't like Bentley Intense.. what are the odds I will like regular "For Men"?

    I would say the odds are strongly against. I love them both, but as was mentioned, there is a lot of overlap, and if you disliked the Intense (the better of the two, IMO), it is highly unlikely you...
  53. Re: NEW : Natura Fabularis - Six New Scents by L'Artisan Parfumeur!

    Ditto.
  54. Re: Santal 33 by Le Labo worth to be bought blind???

    It is a spectacular composition by one of the best noses around. That said, while it was love at first sniff for me, it can be polarizing so sampling first is recommended.
  55. Replies
    52
    Views
    7,051

    Re: Dirt cheap 'quality' scents

    Montana Black Edition can hold its own with just about everything out there, selling for around $20 a 125ml bottle.
  56. Replies
    5
    Views
    1,342

    Re: Anyone familiar with Mendittorosa

    Le Mat is the standout, and it smells great. The rest are forgettable.
  57. Replies
    40
    Views
    3,716

    Re: Most complex cologne you know

    Vintage Red for Men by Giorgio Beverly Hills comes first to mind... Dia Man by Amouage is another.
  58. Thread: Roja Dove ?

    by drseid
    Replies
    26
    Views
    3,014

    Re: Roja Dove ?

    Risqué (pour Femme)

    A close second is Diaghilev.
  59. Re: the most interesting scents issued in the last 2 years

    Scent & Chemistry Kiss My Ass by O'driù is the first one that comes to mind as interesting.... and damn good.
  60. Replies
    15
    Views
    2,753

    Re: Polo black vs double black

    Skip vs. double skip.
  61. Replies
    520
    Views
    58,864

    Re: Today I bought September 2016

    Adjatay by The Different Company
  62. Replies
    31
    Views
    5,077

    Re: Bel Ami vs Bel Ami Vetiver

    I love them both near equally. I would own both.
  63. Replies
    56
    Views
    6,169

    Re: Giorgio Beverly Hills for Men

    The late dry down is quite different now, and destroyed (among other things).

    The age of the vintage bottles in all the ones I have tried has not had any negative effect (except changing the...
  64. Replies
    56
    Views
    6,169

    Re: Giorgio Beverly Hills for Men

    Smell the original and then you will understand.
  65. Replies
    2,658
    Views
    387,486

    Re: Fragrances that "WOW" you recently?

    Adjatay by The Different Company, a stunning floral leather.
  66. Re: giorgio beverly hills for men 1984(original)VS giorgio beverly hills for men(re-issue

    Yes, that is the original release. Better lock that bottle in a safe. ;-)
  67. Replies
    56
    Views
    6,169

    Re: Giorgio Beverly Hills for Men

    That is the bad reformulation I am familiar with (showing both oak moss and tree moss on the box ingredients list). If they destroyed the composition further and removed the oak moss entirely...
  68. Re: New Fragrance from The Different Company - Adjatay!

    Apart from both being excellent floral leathers, there is not much in the way of similarity between the two to my nose. This one leans much more heavily on the florals than Cuir Pleine Fleur. So, I...
  69. Re: New Fragrance from The Different Company - Adjatay!

    It does lean "feminine" by most standards, but not overly so, IMO. The florals play more of a role than the underlying leather, but the whole thing comes together rather nicely, IMO. Great work by...
  70. Re: Ever have a fragrance that you try where other people like it more than you do?

    Plenty of times, and it doesn't bother me at all. As for the perfume in question, I would say just about *everybody* likes that more than I (even those that can't stand it).
  71. Thread: New: Dusita

    by drseid
    Replies
    34
    Views
    5,541

    Re: New: Dusita

    Just tried all three of the ones at Lucky Scent...

    All three are high quality, but the Oud which many are enjoying the most is a bit too animallic for my tastes. That said, I do understand the...
  72. Re: New Fragrance from The Different Company - Adjatay!

    I didn't know what to expect with this one, as the perfumer, Monet, is relatively new on the scene (and tuberose is not a favorite note of mine, at least not on *me*)...

    Hesitancy aside, I am...
  73. Replies
    56
    Views
    6,169

    Re: Giorgio Beverly Hills for Men

    I wouldn't buy the current formulation of this. It is a tremendous perfume in its original formula, but the reformulation ruined it. Save up some additional money and buy one of the...
  74. Poll: Re: Have you ever bought a scent because it was hyped as "sexy" ?

    No.
  75. Replies
    23
    Views
    3,703

    Re: La Nuit de L'Homme vs Aventus Creed

    Hmm... One mediocre offering (Aventus) versus an absolutely atrocious smelling one (La Nuit de L'Homme)... I guess mediocrity "wins," when comparing the lesser of two losers...
  76. Replies
    33
    Views
    2,862

    Poll: Re: For anyone who's tried all 3

    This, word for word.
  77. Replies
    62
    Views
    8,483

    Re: Aventus Creed or Grey Vetiver Tom Ford

    Two average compositions that will never be in my collection. That said, I prefer the über bland Grey Vetiver by a hair.
  78. Replies
    19
    Views
    2,022

    Re: Pineapple in Valentino Uomo ?

    Absolutely, no.
  79. Replies
    13
    Views
    1,715

    Re: Chanel's Pour Monsieur, better in the past?

    I own both versions (of the regular stuff). The vintage is superior for sure. The Concentré that many call "Pour Monsieur" is a different composition entirely.
  80. Re: giorgio beverly hills for men 1984(original)VS giorgio beverly hills for men(re-issue

    Not that I could perceive (assuming we are talking against the US vintage releases)
  81. Re: giorgio beverly hills for men 1984(original)VS giorgio beverly hills for men(re-issue

    There were a small batch that were made in France. Like I said, they are *extremely* rare.
  82. Re: giorgio beverly hills for men 1984(original)VS giorgio beverly hills for men(re-issue

    Well, certainly the originals had the "Extraordinary Cologne" moniker, and not edt. If it is a splash, that would also be a good sign as I don't know of any current splash bottles (that said, all my...
  83. Replies
    15
    Views
    2,464

    Re: La Nuit de l`Homme blind buy

    I think this is being overly kind to this highly unfortunate release.
  84. Replies
    73
    Views
    8,329

    Re: Your favorite patchouli?

    Giorgio for Men (vintage), Giorgio VIP for Men and Javanese Patchouli top the list.
  85. Replies
    121
    Views
    30,137

    Re: Jeremy Fragrance controversy or not.

    While I share the video's very low opinion of Jeremy's videos and find their content cringeworthy, the allegations don't seem to have much backing them up. In the end, it is just one YouTube...
  86. Thread: PHLUR - Anyone?

    by drseid
    Replies
    17
    Views
    12,524

    Re: PHLUR - Anyone?

    A lot of synthetics used in these (which is no surprise, considering their big pitch about them not causing allergy problems). Of the two I received, neither was bad, but Greylocke's synthetic...
  87. Thread: PHLUR - Anyone?

    by drseid
    Replies
    17
    Views
    12,524

    Re: PHLUR - Anyone?

    I have no idea if they are any good, but have samples of Greylocke and Olmsted & Vaux on order. I do like their packaging and fairly priced bottles. The most important thing that remains unproven...
  88. Replies
    8
    Views
    1,504

    Re: Is it just me.....

    Yes, it is just you. ;-)
  89. Re: giorgio beverly hills for men...which version?

    Yep, that is definitely the reformulated stuff. Longevity and projection are just fine with the current stuff. The problem is the dry down is now far inferior to the original (and even...
  90. Re: giorgio beverly hills for men...which version?

    It is one of the greatest perfumes ever created.... Far from a "stink monster". It is a very strong powerhouse composition that does not need tons of sprays to get the job done, however. As for...
  91. Re: The Many New Releases From Pascal Morabito ???

    I blind bought Or Star when it was first released and was extremely disappointed. Not only was the bottle itself super cheaply constructed (and fell apart), the scent itself was a moderately sweet...
  92. Re: Lady Compliment Getter: Chanel Bleu EDP Blows Away Aventus

    That sums it up nicely.
  93. Replies
    66
    Views
    10,437

    Re: What fragrance would a "player" wear?

    Yeah, just check out those previously mentioned videos (AKA nothing I would ever wear or recommend).
  94. Replies
    68
    Views
    19,763

    Re: == NEW == Amouage Bracken Man

    The recent slate of Amouage offerings have disappointed, but this one looks promising. I will definitely sample soon.
  95. Replies
    13
    Views
    2,796

    Re: Vintage Cool Water: Do Any of You Wear This?

    The vintage is excellent and I still wear it. The current stuff still smells good, but nowhere near as good as the vintage.
  96. Re: Battle of the Citruses: Paco Rabanne Invictus vs. Versace Man Eau Fraiche

    Surely this!
  97. Replies
    14
    Views
    1,833

    Re: Slumberhouse Kiste - safe blind buy?

    It is a superb smelling composition and rather tame by Slumberhouse standards, but "safe" would not be a descriptor I would use for Kiste. Sample first, but definitely *do* as I think it is a real...
  98. Replies
    42
    Views
    4,262

    Re: Virgin Island Water worth owning?

    This pretty much sums up my own views.... Very expensive, but pleasant smelling tropical suntan oil. I would pass.
  99. Replies
    26
    Views
    3,179

    Re: Bottega Veneta Pour Homme=Terre D'Hermes?

    No, not even close.
  100. Re: Wearing Sample from Le Labo "The Noir 29". My thoughts so far.

    Probably just as much as *I* can't understand how anyone could like it... ;-). The bottom line is we all have different tastes.
Results 1 to 100 of 500
Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4



Loving perfume on the Internet since 2000