Search:

Type: Posts; User: Bigsly; Keyword(s):

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.19 seconds; generated 16 minute(s) ago.

  1. Replies
    1
    Views
    95

    Re: Quorum Clarification

    The problem is that many of us who have been interested in acquiring vintage Quorum can't find bottles that still have their boxes. For example, the best formulation I've encountered is the one that...
  2. Re: A musing on layering fragrances on top of heavy compounds (warning: essay/ramble)

    Over the last few months I've done more layering than ever before, mostly to create complexity. My problem with iso e super, and probably other aroma chemicals that are large molecules, is that it...
  3. Re: An aromatic, herby perfume with lasting power

    It sounds like what you're seeking is something like Green Water, probably vintage. The new one has a lot of jasmine, but the vintage has the crispness that isn't too sharp to be clearly...
  4. Re: Azzaro Visit? Opinions of currrent basenoters are needed!

    If one reads the reviews here one can get an idea of what to expect:

    http://www.bulkapothecary.com/essential-oils/cedarwood-texas-essential-oil/

    Even more to the point, on the Fir Needle EO...
  5. Re: Azzaro Visit? Opinions of currrent basenoters are needed!

    If one reads the reviews here you can get an idea of what to mix together:

    http://www.bulkapothecary.com/essential-oils/cedarwood-texas-essential-oil/

    The thing is, so many people start thread...
  6. Re: Azzaro Visit? Opinions of currrent basenoters are needed!

    You asked for thoughts and there was very little information provided, so any response would have to be either presumptuous or irrelevant, it would seem. LOL. When you talked about wanting opinions...
  7. Re: Azzaro Visit? Opinions of currrent basenoters are needed!

    Sounds like it would come across as too "old" for you. Now if I were you I'd consider getting some cedar essential oil and mixing up my own scent.
  8. Replies
    31
    Views
    1,110

    Re: Kouros in summertime

    For me it's best in cool but not very cold weather, though lightly applied. My guess is that most of those who say it works great in hot weather sweat a lot and it dilutes the scent considerably.
  9. Replies
    10
    Views
    3,845

    Re: Rance 1795: reviews or feedback?

    Rance 2 impressed me as a unisex version of Egoiste Platinum.
  10. Replies
    38
    Views
    964

    Re: Tobacco Vanille... huh?

    Learn to do a half spritz! LOL.
  11. Replies
    11
    Views
    534

    Re: Perfume costs... 2%

    My impression, when I've seen such claims, is that 2% (or whatever the percentage given) is for the actual cost of materials. if the CEO makes a billion dollars a year because he is such a genius,...
  12. Replies
    11
    Views
    534

    Re: Perfume costs... 2%

    Don't you hire a guy who went to perfumery school for that? LOL. Seriously, I think it's more about trying to put together something that seems "new" but isn't that challenging, at least for the...
  13. Replies
    15
    Views
    429

    Re: Androgynous Fragrances

    The term used is unisex, not androgynous. My guess is that the answer to your question has too many variables, such as age, socio-economic group, etc., so that if you asked a question like, "what is...
  14. Re: Halston Z-14 (old formulation) vs (new formulation)

    Up to around 2008 you are probably correct, but the newest one is like an entirely different scent, and unlike past experiences, I am not sure I want to sell/swap it, because it is like some sort of...
  15. Re: My first experience with the vintage versus new formulations -- Hermes Bel Ami

    I don't think it would be wise to generalize about reformulations by using an Hermes scent as the example. When you see an Hermes scent selling at your local drugstore for under $20 and made by EA,...
  16. Replies
    16
    Views
    496

    Re: Stuffed nose and fragrances

    Another idea: get a nose job and make it bigger! LOL.
  17. Replies
    21
    Views
    747

    Poll: Re: Creed Aventus on eBay

    Or one can just "bite the bullet" and order AB Spirit Silver instead! LOL.
  18. Re: Have Reformulations ruined fragrances? : Dior Homme, Chergui, Timbuktu?

    I agree with this kind of "ignorance is bliss" notion. In fact, in early 2008 I couldn't tell the differences either. However, if one day you can, and you've got a closet full of reformulations,...
  19. Replies
    48
    Views
    2,701

    Re: Is Amouage watering down ?

    Well, if nothing else, such threads make me glad I spent more time than I would have liked "vintage hunting" in recent years! LOL.
  20. Replies
    5
    Views
    252

    Re: Really wanted to like MI...

    I felt similarly, but fortunately, Eau des Merveilles seems to get the job done for me.
  21. Re: Any high quality gourmands recently released?

    This morning I published a blog post on the topic of gourmands, actually. Do you really want to smell like something along the lines of a vanilla cupcake, or do you want a scent that has some...
  22. Replies
    13
    Views
    848

    Re: Original Formulation Givenchy Gentleman.

    There's a 2 ounce vintage on ebay now for $30 total (looks 70% full) though it's a splash.
  23. Replies
    21
    Views
    747

    Poll: Re: Creed Aventus on eBay

    Why not read the old (and long) threads on batch variations?
  24. Replies
    45
    Views
    904

    Re: Bond No.9 - what is full bottle worth?

    I haven't come across one that I think is worth the price, but that doesn't mean you won't. If you are wealthy, go for it. If not, I don't know why anyone would blind buy a B9 bottle.
  25. Replies
    18
    Views
    662

    Re: Vol de Nuit- AMAZING!

    I've got vintage EdC and it has very good longevity, though the sillage is certainly hot huge.
  26. Replies
    18
    Views
    465

    Re: Would you wear fake cologne?

    You can spray it on cloth or paper and then put that in a shirt pocket. Spraying it on skin is a really bad idea.
  27. Re: Another "Heads Up:" $5.21 for 1 oz Set Sail St. Barts !

    It's not the kind of scent I usually like, but I this one works for me, and it's going for nearly the price most people pay for shipping when they swap a bottle. LOL.
  28. Re: Have Reformulations ruined fragrances? : Dior Homme, Chergui, Timbuktu?

    It's a common claim, but I stay away from recent batches unless I purchase a lot of different ones and they are included. I have noticed that some scents do seem very similar but considerably...
  29. Replies
    11
    Views
    497

    Re: Mr. Bill Blass safe blind buy?

    It had a new aroma chemical in that bothered me the second time I wore it, and I don't remember a strong, clear leather note.
  30. Another "Heads Up:" $5.21 for 1 oz Set Sail St. Barts !

    Just grabbed one on ebay, and it's new and from a seller I've bought a few things from in the past. That is $5.21 total !!!!!!!!!!!

    UPDATE: This appears to be "vintage," if that matters, and the...
  31. Replies
    61
    Views
    3,115

    Re: "Official" Mugler - Pure Wood reviews thread

    Sounds like PW will be a real dud - there doesn't seem to be that much interest at Fragrantica either. Very surprising to me!
  32. Re: Discontinued Armani Attitude for under $12 shipped for 100ml, too good to be true?

    If you want something in the general ballpark and don't care if it's weaker, less complex, or a bit "synthetic," then the clones are usually great (though it does depend upon the composition and...
  33. Re: Discontinued Armani Attitude for under $12 shipped for 100ml, too good to be true?

    So will your next post be "Le Male for $3 per 1.17 ounces," though you really mean Cuba Gold? LOL.
  34. Replies
    18
    Views
    582

    Re: Moschino Pour Homme?

    There was always something about it that didn't seem quite right, and sometimes it was irritating. I sold off my bottle several months ago, after giving it a few regular wearings over a long course...
  35. Re: Anyone else get nothing but patchouli in Amen?

    No for me it's mild. Have you tried Borneo 1834?
  36. Replies
    5
    Views
    342

    Re: Better version of DG Pour Homme?

    That's what vintage formulations are for! LOL.
  37. Re: HUGE LIST: Mens/Womens/Samples; Really looking to sell so make offers!

    BUMP: More added.
  38. Thread: canoe by dana

    by Bigsly
    Replies
    41
    Views
    890

    Re: canoe by dana

    I think when you make this kind of claim, at least about the original formulation of a scent like Canoe, you should be very clear about what you mean. Many scents that cost $200 or more would likely...
  39. Re: Is there a feedback thread or forum subdivision for warning about ebay scammers?

    I think it is permissible to say what happened to you with a particular ebay transaction, and to provide your opinion about what at least one seller there might be doing, just so long as you don't...
  40. Replies
    26
    Views
    784

    Re: Lomani AB Spirit Platinum

    Seems like it's a "fresh leather" idea according to those guys. Might be similar to Cereus #7, but overall it doesn't sound like something I would like so I won't be blind buying that one.
  41. Replies
    26
    Views
    784

    Re: Lomani AB Spirit Platinum

    The Fragrantica reviews suggest a "new" leather type smell. Is this an "homage" to Tuscan Leather?
  42. Replies
    61
    Views
    3,115

    Re: "Official" Mugler - Pure Wood reviews thread

    I'll add that for $90/100 ml, it's got to not only be different, but have a different base, and one that I like. Too many just go into a gourmand base, sometimes without much trace of the opening...
  43. Replies
    61
    Views
    3,115

    Re: "Official" Mugler - Pure Wood reviews thread

    Wow, it's Saturday evening and I thought that by now there would be more commentary here on this scent !
  44. Replies
    85
    Views
    2,510

    Re: Are the Cheapies Really Worth It?

    Okay now I get it. However, by contrast, I wouldn't say that a scent such as TdH is "bad," but I would say that I find it atrocious in terms of what I'm seeking, which is a pleasant and interesting...
  45. Replies
    85
    Views
    2,510

    Re: Are the Cheapies Really Worth It?

    You would have to be more specific here. I do agree that some of the recent Bogart and Lapidus releases are not worth the $15 or so per 100 ml, and there is also the reformulation issue with some,...
  46. Replies
    85
    Views
    2,510

    Re: Are the Cheapies Really Worth It?

    You have confused me even more (as to your position) so I will just quite while I am behind here! LOL.
  47. Replies
    19
    Views
    693

    Re: Chanel No. 5 + Shalimar = Men's What??

    The closest, at least in the US, would be Aramis I'd guess (not quite over 50), but when you say "highest quality," isn't that more of a BN type thing? AFAICT, the quality seems reasonably good, at...
  48. Replies
    85
    Views
    2,510

    Re: Are the Cheapies Really Worth It?

    I would appreciate it if you would clarify your notion about Carven Homme. In what way do you consider it "cheap," putting price aside? And do you also consider scents like Envy, Heritage, and Bois...
  49. Replies
    85
    Views
    2,510

    Re: Are the Cheapies Really Worth It?

    Yes, most designer scents have very nice bottles that must have cost quite a bit to manufacture, and of course all those ads help make the scent smell better when you spray it on. LOL.
  50. Re: Does Shalimar have something to do with Habit Rouge?

    For me, Heritage is the "male version" of Shalimar.
  51. Replies
    85
    Views
    2,510

    Re: Are the Cheapies Really Worth It?

    As you can see from the responses, there is no one definition of cheapo/cheapie to the extent that some seem to think that getting a scent like Egoiste at a garage sale means that it's a...
  52. Thread: canoe by dana

    by Bigsly
    Replies
    41
    Views
    890

    Re: canoe by dana

    If you like that one you might also like vintage British Sterling, which you can get at reasonable prices on ebay. I prefer it to Canoe because I like the strong spice notes.
  53. Replies
    85
    Views
    2,510

    Re: Are the Cheapies Really Worth It?

    Some "cheapos" may be a kind of training wheels, especially for newbies, but at some point you know what you want and "cheapos" may or may not be part of whatever that is. These days, though, it's...
  54. Re: Does Shalimar have something to do with Habit Rouge?

    Some might say they are "powdery" but it's not in the same way, IMO (HR is more herbal/orange blossom whereas Shalimar is more ambery/iris). HR also has a kind of old/hard leather quality, so while...
  55. Replies
    10
    Views
    436

    Re: Aramis 900 and Z-14

    Z-14 is a lavender-dominant scent (and has been pointed out, has clear citrus too) but even the floral notes don't match up well with these two. Study them over time and I have a feeling you will be...
  56. Replies
    329
    Views
    18,220

    Re: Ab Silver Lomani - the next Aventus clone?

    I wonder why Lomani didn't call it something like Adventure for Us. Or did they think the word would get out quickly enough online?
  57. Replies
    42
    Views
    1,793

    Re: The very best clones

    Sun Java White is supposed to be similar to SMW. The Cubas seem to all be "homage" scents, just read the reviews and relevant threads. Adidas Victory League seems somewhat similar to Allure Homme,...
  58. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    The question about what makes a post to a thread off topic is interesting, but itself is likely off topic. However, I think it could be argued that the thread itself is "off topic" because this...
  59. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    Yes, and I could also give all my assets away and live in a cardboard box! If you want to fund it, then we can move forward. Otherwise, I have already said more than once that I am not going to...
  60. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    No, it would be their study not mine, and they would have to figure out how to fund it. However, if you go to them with the funding already secured, it will be a lot easier to get at least some of...
  61. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    But I'm not a sociologist and I'm not going to fund it. If someone wants to fund it I can contact some sociologists who might be interested in doing it, or they might refer me to grad students who...
  62. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    It sounds like we are just going to have to agree to agree then! LOL.
  63. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    Sure, I'll read about such anecdotal evidence, but it's not a social scientific study. Moreover, one would need a bit of BdC and a bunch of other scents that are at least somewhat similar, even if...
  64. Replies
    115
    Views
    3,708

    Re: I'm done with Bond No. 9

    I can understand their attempt to restrict available samples, because it seems that there are quite a few people out there I'd call "chronic samplers." One of them buys the sample, and then it gets...
  65. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    Sure, you fund that study and I'll organize it.
  66. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    Sociological studies are something a sociologist does. I simply do not have the qualifications, nor the money. I don't know the methodologies that are considered acceptable. I'm not going to...
  67. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    I think I'll just stick to my current position. If someone wants to contact Chanel and get a wonderful form letter (or whatever) I'm sure they will.
  68. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    It would basically be product testing with a sociologist overseeing it. Or it could be a grad student's Ph.D. thesis, so I don't 'think it would be difficult nor expensive.
  69. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    If opinions could be quantified then sociology would be a "hard" science. In this case, my memory was that BdC and Roadster were treated similarly at BN early on. That is, the early "take" on both...
  70. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    I had a bit of a "blog war" not that long ago and I think I can lay claim to being "Mr. Subjectivity," so I'm with you there. However, what I have seen recently on BN especially is a major surge in...
  71. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    Exactly, he'd have to be more specific, but it does come across as a subtle undermining of less expensive, "drug store" scents, regardless of the supposed formulation. I've got more than a few old...
  72. Replies
    7
    Views
    407

    Re: Tell me about Lattafa's Ameer Al-Oudh edp

    A bit on the sweet side but not gourmand. Oud note a bit medicinal but not barnyard. Spice notes not too strong. A few hours or so after application a "synthetic" woody quality is a little too...
  73. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    I wish I could remember what Barbasol smelled like !
  74. Replies
    29
    Views
    880

    Re: What is the first oud that I should try?

    From what I understand, what you should ask is, which oud reconstruction scent should I try first? Either that, or go for true oud, which some claim should not be a note. If you want to start at a...
  75. Replies
    11
    Views
    598

    Re: New Kerosene - 'Dirty Flower Factory'

    I think pepper notes are now required in all "masculine" scents. LOL.
  76. Replies
    4
    Views
    295

    Re: a tale of two egoïstes...

    If they smell the same then isn't it a tale of two lettering placements?
  77. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    But then we are back to concepts of "good" (or even "great"). Why is BdC "better" than something like Roadster, which I'd much rather wear (in fact, at this point, I think I would only wear BdC if...
  78. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    Right, and just to be clear, it doesn't bother me if Chanel wants to create a "crowd pleaser" scent. In fact, I would like to trim down the number of bottles I have so that I breathe a sigh of...
  79. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    I'm not really one to make claims about "greatness" or "masterpieces," at least not in recent years. I just published a blog post criticizing another blogger who wrote up a review of a scent that...
  80. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    I"m not non-calm! LOL. I went through some pretty heated debates years ago in grad school so this is "a walk in the park" by comparison. Now as to your point, my claim here, to state it as...
  81. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    Please don't try to read my mind! If you like the notes or composition, or even the aroma chemicals used,that's fine with me. What I am confused by is the claims about "greatness." This is not a...
  82. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    Now I am not sure what your point is, so let's begin with this question: do you think that some percentage of the praise is due to the Chanel name, as opposed to if it was made by Lomani, Gres,...
  83. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    I totally disagree with this and I'm really surprised that you would say such a thing. However, if you want to think that Chanel's name recognition is even somewhat similar to Yacht Man, Parlux,...
  84. Re: New (no vintage) Modern Masculine scents - Anything out there to talk about ?

    Well then, let's take a look at Cereus #4 !

    And Yardley's Citrus and Wood should work as well.
  85. Re: New (no vintage) Modern Masculine scents - Anything out there to talk about ?

    please delete this post
  86. Re: New (no vintage) Modern Masculine scents - Anything out there to talk about ?

    But another person's gem might be your fool's gold, right? There are plenty of scents with strong wood notes that most women would consider masculine if not hyper-masculine among recent offerings,...
  87. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    Well if this is true then it begs the question, "what is it about a scent that has great mass appeal?" What could they have put in BdC to make it so special in this context? I have never read any...
  88. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    Without having a sample now, I can only go from memory but I did try it a few times spaced out over months. Undeniably, Cool Water was incredibly popular for a long time, yet to me the composition...
  89. Re: Why do so many men not like Chanel's Blue de Chanel?

    I was just reading through the Fragrantica reviews of BdC because the last time I tried it was at least around 18 months ago and I wanted to compare it to Lomani's Body and Soul, which to me is...
  90. Replies
    10
    Views
    543

    Re: A little help from the Gurus.

    Are you responding to my recent blog post which featured a picture of a false guru? LOL. Anyway, what I would try, assuming you care about what she thinks in this context, is to spray what she...
  91. Replies
    7
    Views
    452

    Re: Body and Soul equals Bleu de Chanel ?

    I received the BaS bottle today and here is my review:

    This seems to be Lomani's attempt at a Bleu de Chanel sort of scent. It's certainly not identical, though I don't remember BdC that well....
  92. Replies
    26
    Views
    865

    Re: why the hate on Calvin Klein Euphoria

    IMO, anyone who makes the "hate" claim should have to provide at least three examples of clearly hateful remarks about the scent in question, and those should be from long-standing members (not...
  93. Re: Speclative Futures Discussion - Rive Gauche

    There are a few factors here, not just one, it seems to me:

    1. Prices are rising on retail scents, which pulls up discontinued ones to some degree.
    2. Limited supply and a demand that may grow...
  94. Replies
    30
    Views
    1,020

    Re: similar to terre d' Hermes?

    Yardley's Citrus & Wood.
  95. Replies
    7
    Views
    452

    Re: Body and Soul equals Bleu de Chanel ?

    Actually, I hope you are right on this one! I'd rather have a decent tobacco and myrrh scent than a BdC clone, that's for sure.
  96. Replies
    7
    Views
    452

    Re: Body and Soul equals Bleu de Chanel ?

    I have a feeling that the note pyramid for BaS was deliberately made to look a bit different, for example, myrrh rather than incense, but I'll write up a review for it after I try it. I seem to like...
  97. Replies
    7
    Views
    452

    Body and Soul equals Bleu de Chanel ?

    Given what we've seen with Lomani's recent offerings, as well as how similar their original release is to Drakkar Noir type scents, I am wondering if their Body and Soul is an attempt to cash in on...
  98. Replies
    86
    Views
    2,364

    Re: Bleu de Chanel: Why so many negative reviews?

    I think my posts here on BN are regarded by just about everyone as "clear as day." That's one thing I strive for, and, moreover, there isn't any one point I've tried to make on this thread. For...
  99. Replies
    31
    Views
    845

    Re: What's WRONG with me?

    I think the composition has an unpleasant note clash and I don't understand the idea behind it. Though I don't like at least one of the aroma chemicals used in Brit for Men, I think that is a better...
  100. Re: Pathétique, performance perfume_________Pathétique contest.

    Alcohol, Propylene Glycol, Water, Benzophenone-3, Benzyl Benzoate, Benzyl Salicylate, Butylphenyl Methylpropional, Carvacrol, Cineole, Citral, Citronnellol, Courmarin, Evernia Prunastri, Hexyl...
Results 1 to 100 of 489
Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4