Originally Posted by yepyep
Do you mean why is it that I'm concerned about the tobacco leaf ingredient, or why am I concerned only slightly about it?
My guess would be that the question relates to the former.
As for DG vs Versace..........
I have both. Both have a "love / hate" following here on Basenotes. Both have also been charged with being "overly synthetic", something I really don't see in either of them. I personally find DG to be a bit more versatile. I have no problems wearing DG in a business setting, or out for a night on the town. Dreamer is a bit more of an enigma.....a great fragrance, but quirky in a way that I won't be able to adequately explain in this post...it's probably been a year or so since I dug it out and wore it.
So in summary:
Avant Garde frag / "Let's be Different" - Versace Dreamer
Versatile / Quality / Safe - DG PH
I'm sure that doesn't help much given the lack of specificity, but as always, in the end, only your nose knows for sure. Give 'em both a try in the form of a sample!