I love Tabac Original. It is utterly refreshing to me IMHO, and has excellent duration. The closest thing I have to it is Tuscany PH, and I think Tabac Original completely trumps it.
However, I have talked with a couple BN'ers who have said that the scent is too synthetic smelling to them. I can understand where they are coming from; there is a bit of a plastic smell coming from it. However, I love the 1980's cassette tape smell
Tuscany Per Uomo doesn't have as much of the synth smell IMHO, but I think it is still there. I'm thinking it is the carnation.
I have Tabac Man but was not wowed by it like I was Tabac Original.