Have you jumped the fence and visited makeupalley.com? Lots of opinions there about L'Occitane frags. The Eau Des 4 Reines seems popular for its simplicity of rose scent. I've tried only the Recolte Bleue, and now figure I'm just not a lavender person. They do have some of the best-looking packaging.
Eau des 4 Reines is a pure rose scent. It's pleasant in the mornings sometimes because it's the only soapy rose I own.
I've been looking something similar to Tea Rose, but not as cheap and as "killer".
Disclaimer: every time I call a fragrance "cheap" or some other icky word, I mean the way it smells on me; obviously, if there are lovers of said fragrances, they don't smell cheap on everyone.
I think you'd like Eau de 4 Reines if what you want is apure rose scent. It's composed of 4 different rose types: Grasse Rose, Turkish, Moroccan and Bulgarian, with "hints" of blackcurrant and violet.
It's very refreshing, I've been using it a lot in summer, when the full rose scents like Paris are sort of too sticky :P It reminds me of Aqua Allegoria line, with its simplicity and elegance for evey day.
Hope you'll enjoy it!!!