Paul, I am looking for a fall scent to compliment my Eau Des Iles. I tired of Piper Nigrum, sold it, and may have to bring it back. I have been wearing either MI or GIT every day since April. Eau des Iles is better for me when it gets less than 70 degrees, maybe even less than 60, which means starting mid October. Im not into leather scents, patchouli is ok (Gentleman by Givenchy is OK on me) and powder/vanilla is a no no. Obsession was ok, Lagerfeld, the Safari and original Perry Ellis. I like it to last (chergui was good about that, Miller Harris not too good after 4 hours). You seemed to like what I did a few years ago. Oh, and Vetiver (guerlains was the worst) and earthy rose (Voluer de Roses) are no nos.
Im thinking Noir Epices, Piper again, Maybe this L'Air, and Fumerie are gonna be the bets. What's your call.