Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › MFD Archive › Need Help searching for Soapy Frags
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Need Help searching for Soapy Frags

post #1 of 38
Thread Starter 
I'm new here and needed some recommendations for an excellent scent that smells "soapy". It's a word I've seen pop up alot in certain reviews and decided that I have to have one or explode.

In the 70s there was a scent by Dana called Cambridge which I would describe as "soapy" but I can't seem to find a bottle and would prefer something more refined anyway.

Comme des Garcons Man had a drydown I would describe as "soapy", but it seemed to be an "afterthought" rather than the main focus, but Man was neither "light" nor "clean" smelling and I'm not fond of Incense scents. The closest I've come so far to a nice, soapy-feeling fragrance is Neiges pour homme by Lise Watier. I like it a lot but was hoping someone could recommend a scent that was smoother with a little less spice than Neiges' nutmeg top-note which lasts into the drydown.

With the vast experience here, I was wondering if anyone could recommend to me their favorite "soapy" scents, one that is uplifting and clean without being sharp or sneeze-inducing. Something I can grab and spray and not wonder about it's appropriateness for whatever happens at the office or later in the day.

Any suggestions?
post #2 of 38
Hi, I'd suggest try Creed Original Vetiver, it's my favourite clean smelling, soapy frag.
post #3 of 38
I would certainly suggest Joop!'s Nightflight to anyone looking for a soapy scent. Yuzu burst mixed with florals that give way to a very soapy clean fragrance.

I don't really have any suggestions for headier or heavier soapy scents.. it seems that the ones that come to mind are all quite fresh...

ie, Mugler Cologne
Veviter Original
Nightflight
(to some extent) Gendarme


hope this helps a little, if not a lot.

a.
post #4 of 38
You can't go wrong with Acqua di Parma Colonia and Colonia Assoluta, great soapy classics!
post #5 of 38
I don't know if you're looking specifically for niche fragrances, but here's my input.

Polo Blue has a kind of characterless, clean smell that to me strongly suggests any random supermarket soap.

Mugler Cologne was evidently inspired by a soap, and I like it, but not because I think it smells soapy.

I found Façonnable soapy in a light, dry, floral sort of way. I'm not sure others would find it soapy.

I think Geir could be called soapy, but it's a bit sweeter. For me Geir also recalls something alcoholic, fermented, like white whine or sake.

If you like pine-scented soap, Versace's Green Jeans or Pino Silvestre might work.

I'm sure there are others. Anyway I believe that in the end, soap smells like it does mainly because fragrances are added to it. (And of course there are scented soaps in many fragrance lines.)
post #6 of 38
Paco Rabanne Pour homme.
post #7 of 38
R de Capucci,
Original Vetiver.
post #8 of 38
I would second Paco Rabanne Pour Homme

Also, Creed Original Vetiver

and Mugler Cologne

All of those are soapy.
post #9 of 38
Pashana Original Eau de Cologne
post #10 of 38
I also recommend Paco Rabanne pour homme original.
Façonnable is indeed quite floral soapy. (an ex BN member was describing it as Downy smelling)
Many scents with a carnation note have a soapy edge: Hermès' Équipage, Galimard's Monsieur Galimard, Jazz.

There's also Gucci Nobile, Tabac Original, Worth PH (quite similar to Rabanne).
post #11 of 38
Tabac Original, Its quite fantastic.
post #12 of 38
Gendarme
Mugler Cologne
Clean Men

Clinique Happy smells very clean to me, but not exactly soapy. You might give it a try, though.
post #13 of 38
Thread Starter 
Thanks all, and I'd like to thank everyone for their suggestions.

So, in summary, if you want to smell "just-outta-the shower" clean, try:

Creed Original Vetiver (4)
Mugler Cologne (4)
Paco Rabanne (3)
Gendarme, Faconnable or Tabac Original (2)
or Joop!Nightflight, Acqua di Parma Colonia, Colonia Assoluta, Polo Blue, Geir, R de Capucci, Pashanna, Hermes Equipage, Monsieur Galimardo, Jazz, Gucci Nobile, Worth PH, Clean Man, and possible Clinique Happy, Versace Green Jeans, or Pino Silvestre (1 recommendation each)

I'll try to sample them all!
post #14 of 38
Gendarme Grabazzi has a very nice soapy note. Of all the Gendarmes, I have found Grabazzi to be the soapiest.

Santa Maria Novella Muschio Oro (Gold Musk) also has a very attractive soapy note.
post #15 of 38
Tabac Original -- wonderful stuff, and super cheap! Yes, Paco Rabanne is a definite winner in this arena, too, but wear with care. (Over-applying results in absurdly high levels of "pimpitude.") Thierry Mugler ranks right up there, as does the super-strong Grey Flannel ("Soap for DAYS.") Don't forget Boucheron, either -- "soap with high class." (Lovely stuff, Boucheron.) Pino Silvestre never goes out of style, nor does the soapy/powdery Canoe. Finally, I second (or third, or whatever) the Nightflight suggestion -- I never would have thought of that one, but it's definitely soapy.
post #16 of 38
The new Prada Ambre Homme - soap, barber shop, shaving cream..........absolutely fantastic!! My favorite release this year!
post #17 of 38
I find L'Eau D'Issey soapy in the drydown.
post #18 of 38
You could also sample Photo by Karl Lagerfeld.
A (semi)classic fragrance , a citrus scent with a soapy feeling .
post #19 of 38
I like Paco Rabanne but I have to be cautious in spraying it as it has a pretty potent drydown ... the top notes are not strong.

Equipage is one where you can spritz away with not worrying too much about how much your spraying. Pretty soapy, I just wish the carnation was more prominent. English Leather is along similar lines but with the emphasis on the citrus notes... and a hell of a lot less expensive.

Worth PH is soapy but not overly done, and it has the carnation which I love. On the other hand duration is an issue... I'd love to get my hands on the Haute Concentrate of this one, but I haven't splurged to get it... yet.

Gendarme V is fantastic; I'd say this might be one which falls into the "uplifting" category. If Superman had a fragrance, IMHO this would be his. The wife calls it "it smells like soap, but really good french soap." Good duration too. A little Brutish, but that's a good thing for me as I adore Brut.
K
post #20 of 38
So far, a lot of great ideas for what to try. I agree with quite a few including Mugler Cologne, Gendarme (like clean laundry, really), Paco Rabanne PH, Nightflight by JOOP! and L'Eau D'Issey are good ones to try, for sure.

I'll add in:

Drakkar Noir: You may have tried this. It's been around and popular for some time. I tried to avoid this one and wear other scents in high school....not for it being a bad scent, just for the fact that I didn't want to be a "smell-alike!"

Cool Water: This does have a "freshouttatheshower" vibe......but it's way too common 'round me.

Van Cleef and Arpels Pour Homme: Really a cool carnation/rose middle that is reminiscent of a classic soap smell.

Carven Vetiver: A lot like a shaving cream smell. Soft and mellow but doesn't last for nuthin' on my skin.


Good Luck!!

post #21 of 38
L'Artisan - Fou d'Absinthe. first thing my wife noted was its soapiness. i also think it would be a very versatile, office-into-evening scent
post #22 of 38
Merde! I forgot to add Monsieur Musk.

No musk in it, but a veddy nice soapy-spicy frag. I really can't think of a soapy-spicy one that I have (Equipage has clove in it, but I think that might be an accident when Hermes tried to replicate carnation.)
post #23 of 38
Thread Starter 
Thanks again, so here is a more recent summary:

Mugler Cologne (beating out Creed OV (5)
Creed Original Vetiver (down from first place)(4)
Tabac Original, Gendarme, Paco Rabanne (Holding their own)(3)
Faconnable, L'Eau D'Issey(moving up), Joop!Nightflight, (2)
Acqua di Parma Colonia, Colonia Assoluta, L'Artisan - Fou d'Absinthe(new), Polo Blue, G.eir, R de Capucci, Pashanna, Hermes Equipage, Monsieur Galimardo, Jazz, Gucci Nobile, Worth PH, Clean Man, Gendarme Grabazzi(new), Santa Maria Novella Muschio Oro (Gold Musk)(new), Prada Ambre Homme(new), Drakkar Noir(new), Photo by Karl Lagerfeld(new), Gendarme V(new), Cool Water(new), Van Cleef and Arpels(new), Carven Vetiver(new), Monsieur Musk(new), and possibly Clinique Happy, Versace Green Jeans, or Pino Silvestre (1 recommendation each)

Forgive me for being impertinent, but may I ask for any feedback on other's suggestions? In the above list what do you personally feel is absolutely, positively NOT a "SOAPY" fragrance.
post #24 of 38
Quote:
Originally Posted by Spony

Thanks again, so here is a more recent summary:

Mugler Cologne (beating out Creed OV (5)
Creed Original Vetiver (down from first place)(4)
Tabac Original, Gendarme, Paco Rabanne (Holding their own)(3)
Faconnable, L'Eau D'Issey(moving up), Joop!Nightflight, (2)
Acqua di Parma Colonia, Colonia Assoluta, L'Artisan - Fou d'Absinthe(new), Polo Blue, G.eir, R de Capucci, Pashanna, Hermes Equipage, Monsieur Galimardo, Jazz, Gucci Nobile, Worth PH, Clean Man, Gendarme Grabazzi(new), Santa Maria Novella Muschio Oro (Gold Musk)(new), Prada Ambre Homme(new), Drakkar Noir(new), Photo by Karl Lagerfeld(new), Gendarme V(new), Cool Water(new), Van Cleef and Arpels(new), Carven Vetiver(new), Monsieur Musk(new), and possibly Clinique Happy, Versace Green Jeans, or Pino Silvestre (1 recommendation each)

Forgive me for being impertinent, but may I ask for any feedback on other's suggestions? In the above list what do you personally feel is absolutely, positively NOT a "SOAPY" fragrance.

I dont think Van Cleef pour homme is soapy at all. My top 4:

1. Original Vetiver
2. Gendarme Grabazzi
3. Mugler Cologne
4. Gendarme
post #25 of 38
TM Cologne
Creed OV
Montale Aromatic Lime
Gendarme
Jo Malone Grapefruit
post #26 of 38
Santa Maria Novella - Muschio Oro/Golden Musk

read the reviews a very scrubbed with strong soap effect

(and I"m trading it, NIB, as you'll see in swap section)
post #27 of 38
cologne by thierry mugler
eau the vert extreme by bulgari
post #28 of 38
On my skin, the drydown of Burberry's Weekend for Men becomes very very soapy.
post #29 of 38
Thread Starter 
New Summary of Fragrances Perceived as "Soapy":

Mugler Cologne (8)
Creed Original Vetiver (6)
Gendarme (5)
Tabac Original, Paco Rabanne(3)
Faconnable, L'Eau D'Issey, Joop!Nightflight, Santa Maria Novella Muschio Oro (Gold Musk), Gendarme Grabazzi(2)
Acqua di Parma Colonia, Colonia Assoluta, L'Artisan - Fou d'Absinthe, Polo Blue, Geir, R de Capucci, Pashanna, Hermes Equipage, Monsieur Galimardo, Jazz, Gucci Nobile, Worth PH, Clean Man, Prada Ambre Homme, Drakkar Noir, Photo by Karl Lagerfeld, Gendarme V, Cool Water, Carven Vetiver, Monsieur Musk, Montale Aromatic Lime, Jo Malone Grapefruit eau the vert extreme by Bvlgari, Burberry's Weekend for Men and possibly Clinique Happy, Versace Green Jeans, or Pino Silvestre (1 recommendation each)

Van Cleef and Arpels has one "soapy" and one "not soapy".

Mugler Cologne is supposed to have a mysterious "S" ingredient which must mean "soap".

I also checked the ingredients (if available here at basenotes) and noted that: lavendar, "citrus", jasmine, verbena, bergamot, vetiver and a couple of yuzu's pop up frequently in the mix for almost all of them. I think that Yardley's English Lavendar, Coast Soap, and Irish Spring may largely be responsible for that.
post #30 of 38
Quote:
Originally Posted by Spony


I also checked the ingredients (if available here at basenotes) and noted that: lavendar, "citrus", jasmine, verbena, bergamot, vetiver and a couple of yuzu's pop up frequently in the mix for almost all of them. I think that Yardley's English Lavendar, Coast Soap, and Irish Spring may largely be responsible for that.

It has also been suggested that "s" might be "sap." My first smells of Mulger Cologne made me think of fresh green sap.
post #31 of 38
Quote:
Originally Posted by Spony

New Summary of Fragrances Perceived as "Soapy":

Mugler Cologne (8)
Creed Original Vetiver (6)
Gendarme (5)
Tabac Original, Paco Rabanne(3)
Faconnable, L'Eau D'Issey, Joop!Nightflight, Santa Maria Novella Muschio Oro (Gold Musk), Gendarme Grabazzi(2)
Acqua di Parma Colonia, Colonia Assoluta, L'Artisan - Fou d'Absinthe, Polo Blue, Geir, R de Capucci, Pashanna, Hermes Equipage, Monsieur Galimardo, Jazz, Gucci Nobile, Worth PH, Clean Man, Prada Ambre Homme, Drakkar Noir, Photo by Karl Lagerfeld, Gendarme V, Cool Water, Carven Vetiver, Monsieur Musk, Montale Aromatic Lime, Jo Malone Grapefruit eau the vert extreme by Bvlgari, Burberry's Weekend for Men and possibly Clinique Happy, Versace Green Jeans, or Pino Silvestre (1 recommendation each)

Van Cleef and Arpels has one "soapy" and one "not soapy".

Mugler Cologne is supposed to have a mysterious "S" ingredient which must mean "soap".

I also checked the ingredients (if available here at basenotes) and noted that: lavendar, "citrus", jasmine, verbena, bergamot, vetiver and a couple of yuzu's pop up frequently in the mix for almost all of them. I think that Yardley's English Lavendar, Coast Soap, and Irish Spring may largely be responsible for that.

I'm interested to hear which ones you're leaning toward purchasing for yourself!
post #32 of 38
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by CologneJunkie

I'm interested to hear which ones you're leaning toward purchasing for yourself!

I'm interested too! First I have to smell what's out there. I think a trip to Perfumania this weekend should help me to sample a few. I only owned or sampled Joop!Nightflight, Cool Water, Paco Rabanne before and I don't remember thinking of them as "soapy" but definitely clean and likeable. Cambridge by Dana was one I remember as being soapy because the reason I didn't buy it back in the 70s was because it smelled like soap and very ordinary soap at that. Times have changed and a bit of ordinary/comfortable would be welcome in my life.

I think the world is/was overdone with Cool Water with its many clones even in Old Spice body shampoos and Arm & Hammer deodorants.

The one I am definitely interested in sampling/buying is Tabac Original. Mainly because of the reviews, also because of the price. If it's something I'm going to wear everyday a large size and decent price is important. Also, it's not worn in the midwest much at all (I'm in the Chicago area). I don't even see it in Walgreens, so it's not much of a "common" fragrance as are Paco Rabanne or even Cool Water.

Thierry Mugler sounds like it would be worth sampling because I'd want to check the longevity of that one. Creed Original Vetiver may be too expensive for an "everyday" scent.

All of these tips help narrow down the nostrils and should save me time at the store this weekend. The word "soapy" used to describe certain fragrances in Basenotes Reviews caught my attention (Eau Sauvage I believe, not mentioned here once) and I remembered the Cambridge. There is no formal "soapy" category of fragrance so I thought I'd pick some brains. And, like another poster mentioned, soaps themselves are "scented". Perception and experience figure into the equation followed by peoples likes or dislikes of that type of fragrance. For instance, if everyone told me that Mugler was "soapy" then all of them offered their bottle for sale I may have thought twice about going "soapy".

I recently sampled "London" at Lord & Taylor and said to the sales-thing the word "grassy" immediately after spritzing the card. She told me in no uncertain terms that there were NO grass or herbal notes and read off the ingredients to impress me but basically all I heard was her saying that there was something wrong with me for not proclaimin it God's Gift upon first spray, all the time glaring at me disapprovingly and looking around to make sure no other customers heard the neutral comment I had made. There really isn't much of a difference between the words "fashion" and "fascist", is there? It was an initial impression! I know that fragrances change from top to drydown and from card to skin, and the London did in fact change instantly on the card even as she told me how wrong I was. I guess "grassy" is how fragrances SHOULDN'T smell. Anyway, the freakin' hag confused me and ruined my experience of London to such an extent that I would rather ram a bottle up her nostrils along with a list of its ingredients than buy it from her or anyone else at any price.

Now, what would happen to me if I went to Lord & Taylor or Sephora and said: "I'm looking for a "soapy" fragrance?".

I think there's more honesty here amongst the posters as they've all demonstrated in their answers to this minor post/poster. So now, after checking them out at Perfumania or wherever I can find them where I won't get any so-called help, I'll buy online, probably at one of the retailers recommended here at Basenotes, and have it/them shipped to me.

Furthermore, if eight people find Mugler Cologne and Creed OV 'soapy', guess what, whether we like it or not, those fragrances probably will set the new standard for me of what defines a "soapy" scent rather than the discontinued Cambridge.

I've gotten alot of advice here and thanks all. I may post my impressions here, but I'm really more interested in modern perceptions of afficinados that my own little world of "soap".

By the way, does anyone think I'll get bounced out of the Basenotes Community if I start a discussion asking: "What Fragrance fits the age-old question: Where Has That Finger Been Young Man!"?
post #33 of 38
Gendarme, Gendarme, Gendarme.
post #34 of 38
Thread Starter 
okay okay okay...I'll definitely check the Gendarme (if it's there). I think I got a sample once in an order from International Male. I don't remember it at all. Thanks.
post #35 of 38
Prada Man
post #36 of 38
tabac original: pure soapy

creed original vetiver isn't soap exactly, what it is exactly is "clairol herbal essence" only a little purer or something, a little nicer, a little lighter, actually.

and as I said before SMW gold musk for soap that projects
post #37 of 38
I'm a soapy fanatic, and have most of the ones mentioned in this thread. Allow me to suggest Grey Flannel, its the absolute soapiest in my book. Now by soapy, I mean that "fresh" smell after say using Ivory soap and Johnsons baby shampoo in the shower. It may not smell that way when you first spray it on and analyze the scent, but a chick walking by will definitely think you just jumped out of the shower -- its the king of getting the "you smell great" compliment, and NEVER "what cologne are you wearing" question. Check it out, and ignore the critics.
post #38 of 38
How could I have forgotten Jockey Club by Caswell Massey? The ultimate soapy/powdery/barbershop smell -- pure masculinity in a bottle. Also, there's always Piguet's Fracas for Men -- not a personal favorite, no, but very, VERY soapy.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: MFD Archive
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › MFD Archive › Need Help searching for Soapy Frags