Thanks to everyone for your help! This is my first day on this message board and I appreciate all the responses.
Right now I'm leaning towards: Lomani Ignition and Jaipur; however, Sculpture by Nikos, Creed's Original Santal, and Montale's Sweet Oriental Dream (as described) sound very interesting!
I also just bought the Givenchy PI (EDP "parfum") on eBay which I have never tried before (the parfum version).
Rochas, Critobal, Allure, Gaultier2, Obsession Night, and Angel for Men are nice... but not for me.
Armani Code, Polo Double Black, Euphoria, Vera Wang, Happy, and Black were also not for me. LOL
The Coty Raw Vanilla did not even smell like Vanilla to me (or to my mom) LOL
I didn't like PI Fraiche.
I think I wont like Opium EDP because it sounds like it may be very spicy or similar to Egoiste (which I detest).
I never tried Joop or Casran before. I think I might like Casran. Is Casran "vanilla-ish"?
Conquest by Agatha Brown sounds a lot like the new Prada Amber pour Homme as it is described: an ambery, smooth fragrance that has a soapy yet sweetened base. Prada was too mild and smelled sweeter on the paper "test strip" than it did on me.
I tried the "Bond" fragrances at Saks 5th Avenue, but I didnt really care for them.
I bought some Fragonard fragrances at fragonard.com but they were way too sweet and feminine. I think I may have bought the perfume instead of cologne: Fragonard Diamant, Fragonard Vanille EDT, and Fragonard Reve Indien.
The Fragonard cologne samples they sent me I didnt like.
Right now my favorite is Givenchy PI for winter, and "Issey Myake pour Homme" for summer.
Anyways, thanks again to everyone who replied. I wish I would have found this website before "blindly" spending $300 on cologne solely based on the descriptions from fragrancenet.com and ebay
Now I just have to unload the following fragrances: Le Dix, Caron pour Homme, Estee Lauder Metropolis, Cristobal, Coty Raw Vanilla, Zizanie, Diamant, and Fragonard Vanille.
I already unloaded: Animale Animale, Avatar, Egoiste, Fragonard Reve Indien, and Creed Taborome.
When I was a kid all I had to worry about was wearing Brut cologne, and nowadays I'm just too particular :-)