Originally Posted by ziffy321
I'm guessing it's likely Armani Attitude. I don't think the other two are in any brick & mortars in the US yet.
Also, I have the same opinion of Attitude. I bought it at Lord & Taylors blind the day it was released and regret it now. EXTREMELY short lasting and very bland and boring ... IMHO of course.
I would have to agree with you about Attitude except for one thing....people seem to love it on me, even though I can't smell whatever it is that they're loving!! I've received a bunch of complements and comments about "what are you wearing....you smell so good". It's beyond weird. I can't smell anything about this fragrance after the initial opening, and yet, it seems to be quite a hit with a LOT of girls at the office as well as, believe it or not, the supermarket. I actually had a woman stop me last night at the grocery store and ask what I was wearing. Wow. For the compliments alone, I'm keeping Attitude. Hopefully over time, my nose will be able to figure it out, but at least other people seem to like it on me.
I haven't seen or tried the other two fragrances mentioned in the title of this post. My other two recent impulse buys were Gucci Pour Homme II, and Tommy Bahama Set Sail St. Barts.
I really like the Gucci PH II, as it's almost like a summer version of the first Gucci Pour Homme. Set Sail St. Barts initially seemed like it was going to be a keeper, but I've since grown tired of it. Much like Armani Attitude, it fades far to quickly, and doesn't hold on to it's identity very well. I thought it would be the perfect island fragrance, but after a few lackluster wearings, I've decided to just sell it. You win some, you lose some I guess.