West Indian Lime is as well made, masculine, and gentlemanly as C&E's previous offerings, as you would expect. As mentioned already, the lime is not strong - if you are expecting something similar to Trumpers, Taylors, or T&H, don't look to the C&E, they take a different approach. In the end, the wood and spice notes are more prominent than the citrus. Regardless, very well done. By the way, I don't notice any appreciable difference in longevity/sillage of this EDC compared to the Sienna/Sandalwood/Nomad EDT's. I have used the EDC and shower gel often since purchasing them the week they came out.
Uncharted is a different story...while very pleasant, it is very generic...honestly, the first comparison that came to mind was Very Sexy 2 from Victoria's Secret -vaguely fresh and aquatic and clean but undistinguished. Probably well made considering C&E's generally high level of quality, but certainly not what I am seeking from them. Pass.