Would post a traditional review, but the review boards still aren't working for me. (Is this a Firefox thing, or a Basenotes-wide thing? Anyone?)
All I can say is, "Wow -- what a gourmand experience!" I feel as though I've just been drenched in treacle and rum and golden syrup and cinnamon, then dipped in raisins and anointed with just a smidgen of some exotic Near Eastern musk.
I really wanted to enjoy Arabie, and I DID enjoy the experience (i.e., to the extent that I'm a foodie). Still, though, there are things which I wish to eat and things which I wish to wear on my skin. Sometimes those two mesh (e.g., lemon, a light dusting of cocoa, lime etc.); sometimes they do not. Arabie, while exotic and weird and wonderful, is one of those edibles that I would not care to wear on my skin often if ever.
I can appreciate its artfulness, yes. I can understand its complexity, you bet. I can easily smell the quality of its ingredients, absolutely. But for me to say that I'd go out of my way to pay $92.00 plus shipping for 1.7 oz of bottled Lebanese fruitcake? No -- no, I'll go to my local Arabic bakery and stuff my nostrils full of sultanas, spices and sugar cubes first.
All that said, though, I imagine that this is what C.S. Lewis' Edmund had in mind when he first smelled Turkish Delight. Yes, the White Witch could well have conjured up this olfactory confection to tempt small British children into pledging her their fealty.
Souk-like it was not. There was no sweat filled with cumin, no soft jasmine wafting in the air, no mint tea, no diesel fumes, no lamb sizzling smoke into the air, no turmeric . . . no, this is an idealized, very late Victorian, Orientalist vision of a Near Eastern marketplace, not a real souk.
Exotic? Yes, definitively. What I had reasonably expected, though, given the name and the Lutens website description? No.
I can't give it a thumbs down -- no how, no way. It's too rich and complex and beautiful for that. But wearable? No. Not for me, at least. This one will go down with Iquitos and A*men and a few other scents that I find fascinating as hell but utterly unwearable.
All I can say is, "Wow -- what a gourmand experience!" I feel as though I've just been drenched in treacle and rum and golden syrup and cinnamon, then dipped in raisins and anointed with just a smidgen of some exotic Near Eastern musk.
I really wanted to enjoy Arabie, and I DID enjoy the experience (i.e., to the extent that I'm a foodie). Still, though, there are things which I wish to eat and things which I wish to wear on my skin. Sometimes those two mesh (e.g., lemon, a light dusting of cocoa, lime etc.); sometimes they do not. Arabie, while exotic and weird and wonderful, is one of those edibles that I would not care to wear on my skin often if ever.
I can appreciate its artfulness, yes. I can understand its complexity, you bet. I can easily smell the quality of its ingredients, absolutely. But for me to say that I'd go out of my way to pay $92.00 plus shipping for 1.7 oz of bottled Lebanese fruitcake? No -- no, I'll go to my local Arabic bakery and stuff my nostrils full of sultanas, spices and sugar cubes first.
All that said, though, I imagine that this is what C.S. Lewis' Edmund had in mind when he first smelled Turkish Delight. Yes, the White Witch could well have conjured up this olfactory confection to tempt small British children into pledging her their fealty.
Souk-like it was not. There was no sweat filled with cumin, no soft jasmine wafting in the air, no mint tea, no diesel fumes, no lamb sizzling smoke into the air, no turmeric . . . no, this is an idealized, very late Victorian, Orientalist vision of a Near Eastern marketplace, not a real souk.
Exotic? Yes, definitively. What I had reasonably expected, though, given the name and the Lutens website description? No.
I can't give it a thumbs down -- no how, no way. It's too rich and complex and beautiful for that. But wearable? No. Not for me, at least. This one will go down with Iquitos and A*men and a few other scents that I find fascinating as hell but utterly unwearable.












