I got a lot of positive comments over the summer with Nautica Voyage.
I was at a University signing up for my Master's program and one girl handed me a paper and said "can you smell this?"
I just laughed . . .then the girl behind her intervened (noting her friends embarassment) and asked me what scent I was wearing and said that they
had both liked it.
Voyage is not a really outrageously unique or great scent but it does get a lot of compliments.