Sadly I have to agree with others above that they have really dropped their game. Since the twisty glass bottle gems of For Men, Edition, and to a lesser extent, d, they've churned out a series of generic fresh smelling banalities (can anyone tell the difference between Blue, Fresh, Pure, etc...?).
If anyone's been to the Dunhill boutique in London, they know how many gorgeous pipe tobaccos they have there, in all different flavours and scents. They used to do one called Christmas Blend which was magical.
What do they sell at Dunhill? Tobacco, leather goods, and stuff like platinum cigaretter lighters and cufflinks. Can anyone imagine how great it would be if they did the ultimate tobacco fragrance? Somewhere between the old gentlemen's club of Vintage Tabarome and the sweet plummy porty Burberry London? A bit of dusty leather like Tabac Blond or Knize Ten. A bit of cold steel and flint (a la Terre d'Hermes) and gasoline (a la DKNY Fuel, Bvlgari Black) to represent lighters. That's some of my all time favourite scents!
Hmmm.... if only they'd listen to us.