Here's the history of multiple nominations and wins between Best Fragrance and Best New Fragrance.
Interesting to note that no winner of the Best New Fragrance Award has won the Best Fragrance Award, although two have been nominated, one in the same year as winning the Best New.
The Peter O'Tooles (multiple noms, no wins) are: Eau Savage and Green Irish Tweed with respectively 5 and 4 nominations in the Best category and no wins.
BASENOTES AWARDS FOR MEN’S FRAGRANCES:
2000
BEST FRAGRANCE: VETIVER (Guerlain)
BEST NEW FRAGRANCE: YOHJI HOMME (Yohji Yamamoto)
2001
BEST FRAGRANCE: COOL WATER (Davidoff)
BEST NEW FRAGRANCE: MAMBO FOR MEN (Liz Claiborne)
2002
BEST FRAGRANCE: VETIVER (Guerlain) [2nd Award]
BEST NEW FRAGRANCE: GIVENCHY POUR HOMME (Givenchy)
2004
BEST FRAGRANCE: A*MEN/ANGEL MEN (Thierry Mugler)
BEST NEW FRAGRANCE: GUCCI POUR HOMME (Gucci)
2005
BEST FRAGRANCE: A*MEN/ANGEL MEN (Thierry Mugler) [2nd Award]
BEST NEW FRAGRANCE: B*MEN (Thierry Mugler)
2006
BEST FRAGRANCE: A*MEN/ANGEL MEN (Thierry Mugler) [3rd Award]
BEST NEW FRAGRANCE: DIOR HOMME (Christian Dior)
2007
BEST FRAGRANCE: EGOISTE/L’EGOISTE (Chanel)
BEST NEW FRAGRANCE: TERRE D’HERMES (Hermes)
MOST NOMINATIONS FOR BEST FRAGRANCE:
EAU SAVAGE (Christian Dior) – Five Nominations, 0 Wins
VETIVER (Guerlain) – Five Nominations, Two Wins
A* MEN/ANGEL MEN (Thierry Mugler) - 4 Nominations, 3 wins
GREEN IRISH TWEED (Creed) – 4 Nominations, 0 Wins
LE MALE (Jean Paul Gaultier) - 3 Nominations, 0 Wins
PLATINUM EGOISTE (Chanel) – 3 Nominations, 0 Wins
COOL WATER (Davidoff) – 2 Nominations, 1 Win
ANTAEUS (Chanel) – 2 Nominations, 0 Wins
M7 (Yves Saint Laurent) – 2 nominations, 0 Wins
EGOISTE/L'EGOISTE (Chanel) - 2 nominations, 1 Win
MULTIPLE NOMINATIONS FOR BEST NEW FRAGRANCE:
BODY KOUROS (Yves Saint Laurent) – 2 Nominations, 0 Wins
KENZOAIR (Kenzo) – 2 Nominations, 0 Wins
NOMINEES FOR BEST NEW ALSO NOMINATED FOR BEST:
M7 – 1 BEST NEW NOM/2 BEST NOMS: total 3
TERRE D’HERMES (Hermes) – 1 BEST NEW – Won
1 BEST: total 2 same year
Most Nominated for Best With No Wins:
EAU SAVAGE (Christian Dior) – 5 Nominations, 0 Wins
GREEN IRISH TWEED (Creed) – 4 Nominations, 0 Wins
No Winner of Best New Fragrance Award has gone on to win Best Fragrance, although two have been nominated (M7 and TERRE D’HERMES).
Interesting to note that no winner of the Best New Fragrance Award has won the Best Fragrance Award, although two have been nominated, one in the same year as winning the Best New.
The Peter O'Tooles (multiple noms, no wins) are: Eau Savage and Green Irish Tweed with respectively 5 and 4 nominations in the Best category and no wins.
BASENOTES AWARDS FOR MEN’S FRAGRANCES:
2000
BEST FRAGRANCE: VETIVER (Guerlain)
BEST NEW FRAGRANCE: YOHJI HOMME (Yohji Yamamoto)
2001
BEST FRAGRANCE: COOL WATER (Davidoff)
BEST NEW FRAGRANCE: MAMBO FOR MEN (Liz Claiborne)
2002
BEST FRAGRANCE: VETIVER (Guerlain) [2nd Award]
BEST NEW FRAGRANCE: GIVENCHY POUR HOMME (Givenchy)
2004
BEST FRAGRANCE: A*MEN/ANGEL MEN (Thierry Mugler)
BEST NEW FRAGRANCE: GUCCI POUR HOMME (Gucci)
2005
BEST FRAGRANCE: A*MEN/ANGEL MEN (Thierry Mugler) [2nd Award]
BEST NEW FRAGRANCE: B*MEN (Thierry Mugler)
2006
BEST FRAGRANCE: A*MEN/ANGEL MEN (Thierry Mugler) [3rd Award]
BEST NEW FRAGRANCE: DIOR HOMME (Christian Dior)
2007
BEST FRAGRANCE: EGOISTE/L’EGOISTE (Chanel)
BEST NEW FRAGRANCE: TERRE D’HERMES (Hermes)
MOST NOMINATIONS FOR BEST FRAGRANCE:
EAU SAVAGE (Christian Dior) – Five Nominations, 0 Wins
VETIVER (Guerlain) – Five Nominations, Two Wins
A* MEN/ANGEL MEN (Thierry Mugler) - 4 Nominations, 3 wins
GREEN IRISH TWEED (Creed) – 4 Nominations, 0 Wins
LE MALE (Jean Paul Gaultier) - 3 Nominations, 0 Wins
PLATINUM EGOISTE (Chanel) – 3 Nominations, 0 Wins
COOL WATER (Davidoff) – 2 Nominations, 1 Win
ANTAEUS (Chanel) – 2 Nominations, 0 Wins
M7 (Yves Saint Laurent) – 2 nominations, 0 Wins
EGOISTE/L'EGOISTE (Chanel) - 2 nominations, 1 Win
MULTIPLE NOMINATIONS FOR BEST NEW FRAGRANCE:
BODY KOUROS (Yves Saint Laurent) – 2 Nominations, 0 Wins
KENZOAIR (Kenzo) – 2 Nominations, 0 Wins
NOMINEES FOR BEST NEW ALSO NOMINATED FOR BEST:
M7 – 1 BEST NEW NOM/2 BEST NOMS: total 3
TERRE D’HERMES (Hermes) – 1 BEST NEW – Won
1 BEST: total 2 same year
Most Nominated for Best With No Wins:
EAU SAVAGE (Christian Dior) – 5 Nominations, 0 Wins
GREEN IRISH TWEED (Creed) – 4 Nominations, 0 Wins
No Winner of Best New Fragrance Award has gone on to win Best Fragrance, although two have been nominated (M7 and TERRE D’HERMES).
