Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › MFD Archive › Black Tie vs. LV Musk
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Black Tie vs. LV Musk

post #1 of 18
2/16/08 at 7:44pm
Thread Starter 
I've been wanting a rose frag. for a long time, but now I'm narrowing it down to just these two. So, what are your thoughts about Washington Tremlett's Black Tie vs. Lorenzo Villoresi's Musk?
Reply
Reply

Features on Basenotes

Basenotes Reader Awards 2013 - Finalists Announced.
Greatest Hits: Annick Menardo
Petals Falling From The Sky - A Report From The Cote d'Azur's Bataille De Fleurs
post #2 of 18
2/17/08 at 9:46am
i owned LV musk and Santa Maria Novella musk which are cousins. LV is one of the best crafted frags i have ever encounered. A bottle will last you a lifetime because you only need one spray on the chest and the sillage will do the rest. The scent itself is beautiful...its rose...deep rose which creates warmth on the skin which is where i suppose the musk comes in. I have had so many compliments on this from many lovely ladies who never ever commented on anything i wore before....get it...i have never heard of the other frag that you mentioned.
Reply
Reply
post #3 of 18
2/17/08 at 10:21am
For me LV Musk was a bit too feminine. Really nice, though.
Reply
Reply
post #4 of 18
2/17/08 at 11:16am
I ADORE WT Black Tie... its my favourite rose scent for men by a mile! Its worn close to the skin, but thats also a good thing.
Definitely the superior scent of the two IMHO.
Reply
Reply
post #5 of 18
2/17/08 at 11:43am
Thread Starter 
Well, they seem to be neck-to-neck at the moment. They are both very nice scents, which is why I've narrowed it down to these two. (Floris #89 was in that company too, but now it's too hard to get in the US.) I've previously tested LV Musk and liked it, but thought it might be too feminine for me, but that was before I was seriously considering a rose scent. My only concern about Black Tie is that the rose is really strong and I'm afraid here in the US people will think I smell like their grandmother or something.
Reply
Reply
post #6 of 18
2/17/08 at 1:05pm
Have you tried Domenico Caraceni - this is a rose that will not get you mistaken for Grandma? Qualitywise it plays in the same league and I can't think of a better scent to wear with a fine suit.
Reply
Reply
post #7 of 18
2/17/08 at 2:43pm
Thread Starter 
I have tried Domenico Caraceni, but I just kept thinking that it smelled like a funeral home. I think the combination of smells in it must trigger some memory I have. I think it smells great, but that funeral home association is definitely there for me.
Reply
Reply
post #8 of 18
2/17/08 at 3:08pm
I haven't tried BT, but if Dimitri likes it, I'm sure it's good.

I have BA, R31 and LV Musk, love them all. DID NOT love dom. caraceni, at all.
Reply
Reply
post #9 of 18
2/17/08 at 4:20pm
Well, I'm wearing LV Musk on my left arm and Black tie on the right. LV is very sweet, floral and powdery, the rose is on the backburner. It smells very nice, that heliotrope-kind of sweetness does strike a feminine chord, especially in the topn notes, though I find it entirely wearable - more of a comfort than an office scent to me, though.
Black tie is much more focused on rose, gentler and somewhat sweeter than No. 88. I get green, "flowershop" notes too. The rose actually reminds me of Aoud Damascus, which I wore today.
Both are great and both might get frowns, on a man, from not-so-perfume-crazy people. Then again, if you wear them with confidence, even olfactory conservatives might just wonder what makes you smell so good, rather than accusing you of gender-bending . It's a hard call, sick puppy that I am I'd mortgage the house and get them both.
Reply
Reply
post #10 of 18
2/18/08 at 6:18am
Great insights Good_life! Your description of Black Tie is right on the nose
There is something green lying beneath the surface. The soft rose takes center stage though, but in an understated way.
Where C&S 88 is a little bit harsher and drier, Black Tie is clean and lush. It is exactly what I would like to be wearing under a crisp hand-tailored shirt.
Reply
Reply
post #11 of 18
2/18/08 at 6:26am
Hi Tom,
Where did you bought Black Tie,from first-in-fragrance?
I think is quite expensive,140 euros...[
Is there any other source?

Giannisquote=the_good_life;1161039]Well, I'm wearing LV Musk on my left arm and Black tie on the right. LV is very sweet, floral and powdery, the rose is on the backburner. It smells very nice, that heliotrope-kind of sweetness does strike a feminine chord, especially in the topn notes, though I find it entirely wearable - more of a comfort than an office scent to me, though.
Black tie is much more focused on rose, gentler and somewhat sweeter than No. 88. I get green, "flowershop" notes too. The rose actually reminds me of Aoud Damascus, which I wore today.
Both are great and both might get frowns, on a man, from not-so-perfume-crazy people. Then again, if you wear them with confidence, even olfactory conservatives might just wonder what makes you smell so good, rather than accusing you of gender-bending . It's a hard call, sick puppy that I am I'd mortgage the house and get them both.[/quote]
Reply
Reply
post #12 of 18
2/18/08 at 6:45am
There's a few sources, but the price is always the same. I only have a FIF sample and personally I would rather spend 140 Euros on 200ml of No.88 rather than Tremlett, since I have Crown Marechale, which IMHO is easily as good as Tremlett in terms of green rose and way better on me than even Creed's FdTRB. Plus I haven't even opened my new bottle of Aoud Damascus yet. So, I'm covered .

Quote:
Originally Posted by giannis View Post

Hi Tom,
Where did you bought Black Tie,from first-in-fragrance?
I think is quite expensive,140 euros...[
Is there any other source?
Reply
Reply
post #13 of 18
2/18/08 at 9:28am
Gianni, Luckyscent has Black Tie for around €110 for 100mls which is the cheapest Ive found so far, but then obviously one must consider shipping to Greece.
Heres a link:
http://www.luckyscent.com/shop/detai...1603&section=1

I will be waiting to return to Vienna next month to grab my full-price bottle. Money well spent IMO.
Reply
Reply
post #14 of 18
2/18/08 at 9:33am
Thank you Tom and Dimitri

Dimitri you are right,Luckyscent total for Greece is 125 euros while first-in-fragrance 148...
I think that must try it before,,
Reply
Reply
post #15 of 18
2/18/08 at 9:35am
Gianni, if you can hang on until around easter when I get my bottle, I will gladly send you a sample from it.
Dimitri
Reply
Reply
post #16 of 18
2/18/08 at 9:43am
Thank you patrida,you are very kind as all the Greeks
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dimitri View Post

Gianni, if you can hang on until around easter when I get my bottle, I will gladly send you a sample from it.
Dimitri
Reply
Reply
post #17 of 18
2/18/08 at 9:45am
Na'sai kala file Anything for a fellow Hellene!
Reply
Reply
post #18 of 18
2/18/08 at 9:49am
You are right,we are HELLENES!!!!!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dimitri View Post

Na'sai kala file Anything for a fellow Hellene!
Reply
Reply
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: MFD Archive
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › MFD Archive › Black Tie vs. LV Musk