Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › MFD Archive › Which Creed fragrance do you like best?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Which Creed fragrance do you like best?

post #1 of 83
2/26/08 at 5:16am
Thread Starter 
Tell us what you like most and why. Here's mine:

1. Green Irish Tweed
2. Silver Mountain Water
3. Millesime Imperial
4. Himalaya
5. Original Vetiver

Sorry I didn't specify the first time, but I was also hoping you list them in order of preference, 1 being your top choice. But I guess those who replied already did it that way.

And yes, I am a fan of Creed, and this thread is just out of my curiosity what other Creed fans prefer, that's all.
Reply
Reply

Features on Basenotes

Petals Falling From The Sky - A Report From The Cote d'Azur's Bataille De Fleurs
Greatest Hits: Annick Menardo
Basenotes Reader Awards 2013 - Finalists Announced.
post #2 of 83
2/26/08 at 5:30am
1. Silver Mountain Water
2. Millésime Imperial
3. Green Irish Tweed
4. Virgin Island Water
5. Erolfa
6. Original Vetiver
7. Original Santal
8. Neroli Sauvage

I don´t know why I never bought Himalaya or Bois du Portugal (I´m not ready for this one...too young)
Reply
Reply
post #3 of 83
2/26/08 at 6:12am
-bois Du Portugal
-original Vetiver
-green Irish Tweed
-silver Mountain Water
-m.imperial
Reply
Reply
post #4 of 83
2/26/08 at 6:51am
Is it just me or BN is becoming more and more some sort of creed-cult group?
meh I will bite.

Erolfa
SMW
Imperial
BdP
Acier A.


IMHO, very over rated:
VIW. Without the creed lable, this scent would have been "average". Tommy Bahama SSSB and Very Cool are similar and actually better.
GIT. Must be a cultural thing. I can't not understand why something so similar to Cool Water would be liked so much.
BdP True there is nothing like it. But it is not the best fragrance ever either.
OV. Mugler cologne was released 3 years before you, you overpriced homage( .~~)
Himalaya. The product of a developed idea. Eternity, XS, D&G PH, Herrera, Chanel PE. almost 10 years later, Himalaya.
Reply
Reply
post #5 of 83
2/26/08 at 7:10am
At this time I lean towards Imperiale and Acier Aluminum.
Reply
Reply
post #6 of 83
2/26/08 at 7:13am
1. Millesime Imperial
2. Green Irish Tweed
3. Silver Mountain Water (the blackcurrant still grosses me out, but the scent turns beautiful in 30-45 min.)
4. Bois du Portugal
5. Selection Verte/Original Vetiver/Feuille Verte

Those are my 5 faves, but all have very similar alternatives: Unforgivable Multi-Platinum, Cool Water/Chez Bond, Hamptons, PdN New York/Heritage, Mugler Cologne. It's pretty easy to go budget on Creed smell-alikes.

I've tried to love AA/AE (too dirty), VIW/SF/FdtRB (too fem), RD (great on paper, not on my skin), RW (too boring), Erolfa (Amouage Arcus won out over this).
Reply
Reply
post #7 of 83
2/26/08 at 7:26am
1.Original Santal
2.Green Irish Tweed
3.BdP
4.Vetiver
5.Hopefully Royal Delight
Reply
Reply
post #8 of 83
2/26/08 at 7:31am
1. Erolfa
2. Bois du Portugal
3. Royal English Leather
4. Silver Mountain Water
5. Green Irish Tweed
6. Tabarome
Reply
Reply
post #9 of 83
2/26/08 at 7:42am
1. Bois Du Portugal
2. Millesime Imperial
3. Green Irish Tweed
Reply
Reply
post #10 of 83
2/26/08 at 9:23am
Acier Aluminium
Reply
Reply
post #11 of 83
2/26/08 at 9:30am
Quote:
Originally Posted by cologneguy View Post

And yes, I am a fan of Creed, and this thread is just out of my curiosity what other Creed fans prefer, that's all.

I am a fan of Creed but I have a question. Can you tell us when and how you encountered Creed? I am just curious as to why most newbies here start off with a Creed thread, thats all.
Reply
Reply
post #12 of 83
2/26/08 at 9:39am
My Dad told me about it. When he went to Neiman Marcus. He bought the Taborome (Which I Hate).
Reply
Reply
post #13 of 83
2/26/08 at 9:39am
Green Irish Tweed & BdP.
Reply
Reply
post #14 of 83
2/26/08 at 9:50am
Quote:
Originally Posted by zztopp View Post

I am a fan of Creed but I have a question. Can you tell us when and how you encountered Creed? I am just curious as to why most newbies here start off with a Creed thread, thats all.

We are not all back-water, unintelligent beings, LOL. I knew of Creed long before joining basenotes. When developing my fascination with fragrances, I knew there had to be higher offerings in the world than what could be found at the local mainstream market. I did some research and it seemed that Creed was revered as a top luxury line. Not knowing how it smelled or if it was worth the money, I did another search and aquired some samples. This is probably how most people go about it. I will admit that since joining basenotes, I hear of exciting things that was not previous knowledge.

Now back to you, share with us how you discovered Creed. I was lead by my own cognition. Were you introduced through basenotes as your question would suggest? To answer the original question, I don't have an answer as to which Creed I like the best. I am currently investing interest in other houses although I will make an effort to reconnect with Creed in the future.
Reply
Reply
post #15 of 83
2/26/08 at 9:58am
1) Feuille Verte

All tied for second:
Selection Verte
Green Irish
Green Valley
Orig. Vetiver
Bois du Portugal
Millesime Imperial
Reply
Reply
post #16 of 83
2/26/08 at 10:04am
You know scentronic, you said what I was thinking. There are so many that are a complete tie. I like most of them with an equal amount of enthusiasm. In fact, if I ever get another creed, it most likely will be selection vert but it is hard to tell at this point.
Reply
Reply
post #17 of 83
2/26/08 at 10:09am
Quote:
Originally Posted by Scentologist View Post

We are not all back-water, unintelligent beings, LOL. I knew of Creed long before joining basenotes. When developing my fascination with fragrances, I knew there had to be higher offerings in the world than what could be found at the local mainstream market. I did some research and it seemed that Creed was revered as a top luxury line. Not knowing how it smelled or if it was worth the money, I did another search and aquired some samples. This is probably how most people go about it. I will admit that since joining basenotes, I hear of exciting things that was not previous knowledge.

I have been to pretty much every perfume blog and site on the net and Creed isn't discussed as much as Serge Lutens, Guerlain, and other houses there. Or maybe you discovered Creed at Neimans/Saks or through a friend/relative?

As for me, I learned about Creed through Basenotes and was initially here to find info on some Polo and Bulgaris.

For the original question: its hard to pick one amongst offerings like Vintage Tabarome, Acier Aluminum, Selection Verte, Feuille Verte, REL, BdP, Bois de Santal, Santal Imperial, M. Imperial, SMW, etc..
Reply
Reply
post #18 of 83
2/26/08 at 10:52am
I know only 20 of them, and don't know BdP.
And now: by far Vintage Tabarome and Green Irish Tweed are the favourite ones. That is they are the only ones for which I would give money (GIT I do have now). I see that Original Vetiver is a great scent, but I simply can't wear any vetiver.
For a time I thought Royal English Leather will be a big love too, but the romance is over.
And the others - well, they fell short of my expectations. Simply put, for me they aren't complex, they are rather short-lived, and they aren't intriguing.
But nice to see happy people wearing them
Reply
Reply
post #19 of 83
2/26/08 at 11:02am
BdP, by miles - i dont mind the 'retro' facet, I like it more because of it.

But to be honest, ive only tried four Creeds.
GIT - 'sorry' - just dont get it!
Silver Mountain W - utterly foul concoction.
OV - Yes, nice - its OK, but I've encountered others similar that I prefer (much) more.

BdP though .. is a Symphony!
and the music plays on, and on, without repeating and ever changing.
Wonderful, rich, melodic tones.
Reply
Reply
post #20 of 83
2/26/08 at 11:06am
1. Bois du Portugal
2. Acier Aluminium
3. Original Santal
4. Green Irish Tweed
5. Original Vetiver
Reply
Reply
post #21 of 83
2/26/08 at 11:12am
1. Baie de Genievre
2. Bois du Portugal and Green Irish Tweed (tie)
3. Erolfa
4. Tabarome (Millesime)
5. Royal English Leather
6. Imperiale

Thats on me. For women, I love the smell of Fleurissimo.
Reply
Reply
post #22 of 83
2/26/08 at 11:20am
1. Green Irish Tweed
2. Vintage Tabarome
3. Bois Du Portugal
4. Original Vetiver
5. Virgin Island Water

I think it's hard for some to admit what is likely the greatest house.
It's easier to big up for the underdog, and I always cheer for the underdog.
But until the quality is there, I'm just cheering, not buying.
Reply
Reply
post #23 of 83
2/26/08 at 12:16pm
I haven't tried many of 'em but I'd say:

1. Acier Aluminium
2. Original Vetiver
3. Himalaya

Not sure yet how I feel about BdP...
Reply
Reply
post #24 of 83
2/26/08 at 1:07pm
1. BdP
2. Acier Aluminium
3. Orange Spice....This one is new to me and i love it.
4. G.I.T./Erolfa
5. BdG
Reply
Reply
post #25 of 83
2/26/08 at 1:17pm
1. Silver Mountain Water
2. Bois du Portugal
3. Himalaya
4. Green Irish Tweed
5. Millesime Imperial


I was totally indifferent to GIT until lately when I got a decant from Perfumed Court. It's grown on me.
Reply
Reply
post #26 of 83
2/26/08 at 1:33pm
1. Bois De Cedrat
2. Citrus Bigarrade
3. Millesime Imperiale
4. Green Irish Tweed
5. Selection Verte

I own all of the above except for Selection Verte but with summer coming it may soon be mine also.
Reply
Reply
post #27 of 83
2/26/08 at 2:07pm
In no particular order;

Bois du Portugal
Erolfa
Green Irish Tweed (after 20 minutes it smells nothing like Cool Water!)
Neroli Savage
Millesime Tabarome
Reply
Reply
post #28 of 83
2/26/08 at 2:10pm
I just bought a tester of SMW from an Ebay dealer I trust and have used many times. I can already smell the freshness! I've owned it several times.
Reply
Reply
post #29 of 83
2/26/08 at 2:18pm
Windsor
Original Vetiver
Green Irish Tweed
Silver Mountain Water
Reply
Reply
post #30 of 83
2/26/08 at 2:33pm
Selection Verte
Acier Aluminium
Green Irish Tweed
Royal Scottish Lavender
Baie de Genievre
Reply
Reply
post #31 of 83
2/26/08 at 2:48pm
I had as many as 15 different Creed bottles and sold off all but my favorites:

Erolfa
SMW
Baie de Genievre
Green Valley
Vetiver (1948)
Reply
Reply
post #32 of 83
2/26/08 at 3:38pm
I've only tried three.. Neroli Sauvage, GIT and Angelique Encens. The only one I ended up likeing was Angelique Encens.

I have a sample of MI on the way... I'm glad to see most of you have included it in your lists.
Hopefully, this could be another Creed I end up likeing.

Based on notes and description, I'm interested in Chèvrefeuille Original, Green Valley, Original Vetiver, Baie de Genièvre and Fleur de Thé Rose Bulgare.
Reply
Reply
post #33 of 83
2/26/08 at 4:22pm
Vintage Tabarome
Royal English Leather
Acier Aluminum
Bois du Portugal
Ambre Cannelle
Orange Spice
Neroli Sauvage
Original Vetiver
Baie de Genievre
Green Irish Tweed
Original Santal
Silver Mountain Water
Tabarome Millesime
Erolfa
Reply
Reply
post #34 of 83
2/26/08 at 5:24pm
Top 5: Bois de Portugal (my all time favorite), Baie de Genièvre, Original Santal (a civilized version of Joop!, IMHO), Acier Aluminium and Green Irish Tweed. Royal Delight comes close to my Top 5, but has a bit too much jasmine for my taste.

I've yet to sample Royal Water. Neroli Sauvage is delightful, but has horrible longevity -- at least on my skin.
Reply
Reply
post #35 of 83
2/26/08 at 5:53pm
for some reason royal water reminds me a bit if fred haymans "hollywood" for men...
just a bit.
Reply
Reply
post #36 of 83
2/26/08 at 6:24pm
The two that I have liked the most:
BdP and Himalaya. I don't know if I like one more than the other - they suite just two different feelings for me.
Reply
Reply
post #37 of 83
2/26/08 at 6:33pm
I have several (very different) favorite Creeds, though I'll break 'em down into "traditionally" M/F/Uni:

Male: Vintage Taberome (only have a sample, and completely LOVE this stuff. I own a FB of Taberome Milleseme, which is good, but much lighter/sharper/ginger-up than the Vintage, which is like diving head first into the 1940s), Tabarome Milliseme.

Female: Fleurissimo, Jasmine Imperatrice Eugenie and Tuberose Indiana

Uni: Baie de Genievre (which some say is "male" and I say, "ha!"), Vanisia
Reply
Reply
post #38 of 83
2/26/08 at 6:39pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by frank06 View Post

Green Irish Tweed & BdP.

Great minds think alike.
Reply
Reply
post #39 of 83
2/26/08 at 6:57pm
I like whichever one I'm wearing at the time best. I don't know any other way to put it, but I'm pretty happy with anything I've bought, and when I wear them, I'm content. REL and BdP are top favorites in the abstract, Vetiver '48, Tabarome Millésime, Selection Verte, and vintage Tabarome are also, but when I wear Cyprès-Musc or Acier Aluminium I'm just as happy with those.
--Chris
Reply
Reply
post #40 of 83
2/26/08 at 6:58pm
Wow, Green Irish Tweed is DEFINITELY the most popular Creed fragrance on Basenotes
Reply
Reply
post #41 of 83
2/26/08 at 7:31pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by tvlampboy View Post

Original Santal (a civilized version of Joop!, IMHO),

Original Santal is a great fragrance on its own - its nowhere the sillage monster that most people make it out to be. BdP, Royal Delight, REL and quite a few others have far more sillage and longevity. Am I the only one who gets a very alluring spicy BO like accord in this?
Reply
Reply
post #42 of 83
2/26/08 at 7:55pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by Scentronic View Post

1) Feuille Verte

Me too. FV is amazing!
Reply
Reply
post #43 of 83
2/26/08 at 8:00pm
1) Imperial
2) Silver Mountain Water
3) BdP
4) Himalaya
5) Santal Imperial
Reply
Reply
post #44 of 83
2/26/08 at 8:22pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by zztopp View Post

Original Santal is a great fragrance on its own - its nowhere the sillage monster that most people make it out to be. BdP, Royal Delight, REL and quite a few others have far more sillage and longevity. Am I the only one who gets a very alluring spicy BO like accord in this?

In a cheaper vein of course, kinda reminds me of the spicy BO in the Carlos Santana fragrance, or Dunhill Desire, or Romance Silver. Maybe all these don't have a BO note but they share a kind of warmth that reminds me of the color red that is spiced up with ethnic remnants of mexican culture.
Reply
Reply
post #45 of 83
2/26/08 at 8:25pm
Thread Starter 
I am quite new to this forum, and WOW I am impressed... in less than 24 hours, I got 40+ replies from you guys. I appreciate it.
Reply
Reply
post #46 of 83
2/26/08 at 9:09pm
1. MI
2. GIT
3. SMW
4. BdP
5. Erolfa

Testing Selection Verte right now....I need to give it a few days and I'm sure it will move into my top five...just bought a flacon and it is fantastic!
Reply
Reply
post #47 of 83
2/26/08 at 9:21pm
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by zztopp View Post

I am a fan of Creed but I have a question. Can you tell us when and how you encountered Creed? I am just curious as to why most newbies here start off with a Creed thread, thats all.

Ok, good question. I've been around browsing the huge reviews database of Basenotes for years now, but have not become a member of the forum. I've noticed that Creed has consistently been in the Annual Awards, so I got real curious and then googled if this brand is available locally.

I first encountered Creed at their local outlet in a high-end department store. I was instantly hooked when I smelled SMW and MI, the first 2 that I smelled. Didn't care for GIT the first time as it smelled like Clear Water, but it eventually became my first Creed, when I immediately liked its smell upon settling down on my skin with its nice drydown.

Hope this satisfies your curiosity.
Reply
Reply
post #48 of 83
2/26/08 at 9:38pm
I first encountered Creed while in the Military. I was stationed (for 6 years) near Palmdale Ca.
Which is VERY CLOSE to Los Angeles.. Somehow i got to try it and viola..I fell in love with it.
Been using it exclusively (except for AdP now and then) ever since.
To this day, BdP reminds me of L.A. (i now live in Ohio)
Reply
Reply
post #49 of 83
2/26/08 at 9:38pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by ChuckW View Post

I just bought a tester of SMW from an Ebay dealer I trust and have used many times. I can already smell the freshness! I've owned it several times.

ChuckW, which ebay dealer are you talking about?
Reply
Reply
post #50 of 83
2/26/08 at 9:42pm
Mi
Viw
Reply
Reply
post #51 of 83
2/26/08 at 10:24pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by zztopp View Post

I am a fan of Creed but I have a question. Can you tell us when and how you encountered Creed? I am just curious as to why most newbies here start off with a Creed thread, thats all.

To take a non-newbie stab at answering this...

1) I think Creed is not sold with the major designer fragrances, and so is niche, but is also easy enough to find that it is accessible. It's also expensive, but not totally outrageous. It's accessible niche, if you will.

2) I think that Creed's website, which distinguishes between masculine and feminine fragrances is in line with most Basenoter's proclivities in that regard.

3) I think it's a self-sustaining cycle: Creed is ranked highly on this site in terms of most viewed scents, which makes people check it out, which leads to it being hyped, which leads to it being ranked highly in terms of views, which leads to newbies checking it out, etc.

4) They make many relatively pleasant and easy-to-wear fragrances that have a broad appeal.

5) Their marketing creates an image of exclusivity that many folks enjoy.

Anyway, as to original topic, I like many Creeds, not so much some others. I consider it somewhat overrated on Basenotes, but mainly because the house gets SO MUCH discussion here, often to the exclusion of other equally worthy houses. I am also somewhat put off by some overly zealous adherents of the house. (Though I'd also say I have a soft spot for Creed itself since it was what attracted me to this site as a newbie.)

My current personal favorites:
- Acier Aluminium
- Vintage Tabarome
Reply
Reply
post #52 of 83
2/26/08 at 10:31pm
Very well stated. I see many new folks start with Creed before they branch out into more challenging, interesting fragrances. Sort of like how every beginning Jazz fan buys a copy of Miles Davis' Kind of Blue. Its a good record, and its popular for a reason, but it is a starting point rather than an end.

-Slim


Quote:
Originally Posted by robyogi View Post

To take a non-newbie stab at answering this...

1) I think Creed is not sold with the major designer fragrances, and so is niche, but is also easy enough to find that it is accessible. It's also expensive, but not totally outrageous. It's accessible niche, if you will.

2) I think that Creed's website, which distinguishes between masculine and feminine fragrances is in line with most Basenoter's proclivities in that regard.

3) I think it's a self-sustaining cycle: Creed is ranked highly on this site in terms of most viewed scents, which makes people check it out, which leads to it being hyped, which leads to it being ranked highly in terms of views, which leads to newbies checking it out, etc.

4) They make many relatively pleasant and easy-to-wear fragrances that have a broad appeal.

5) Their marketing creates an image of exclusivity that many folks enjoy.

Anyway, as to original topic, I like many Creeds, not so much some others. I consider it somewhat overrated on Basenotes, but mainly because the house gets SO MUCH discussion here, often to the exclusion of other equally worthy houses. I am also somewhat put off by some overly zealous adherents of the house. (Though I'd also say I have a soft spot for Creed itself since it was what attracted me to this site as a newbie.)

My current personal favorites:
- Acier Aluminium
- Vintage Tabarome
Reply
Reply
post #53 of 83
2/26/08 at 10:32pm
Well said, Robyogi.

MI, OV, GIT


TNMA
Reply
Reply
post #54 of 83
2/26/08 at 10:43pm
Imperial
Erolfa
SMW
VIW
GIT
Royal Water
Himalaya

It is hard to pick one as "the best," because they are all so wonderful and unique. If I had to choose, it would be Imperial.
Reply
Reply
post #55 of 83
2/27/08 at 2:38am
I've only had the opportunity to try about 10 Creeds, but of those, Original Vetiver and Original Santal are my favorites. I own GIT, and like it, but it just doesn't wow me like the other two.
Reply
Reply
post #56 of 83
2/27/08 at 3:28am
I had passed by the large Creed selection at NM for years, but figured that the English style bottles were aimed specifically at the yacht and polo set. I had also frequented the Perfume of Life board years before discovering Basenotes, and over at PoL, by and large, they worship Lutens and dismiss Creed as mens aftershave, boring scents for boring people, drugstore quality etc. I actually believed these comments for awhile, until I couldn't help but admire the red and gold Original Santal bottle at NM. After testing it, I soon discovered that the line wasn't anything I imagined it to be, and a great majority of the Creed scents aren't particularly gender-specific either.

Favorites:
Feuille Verte, in a class by itself - Olivier's lush green paradise.

Silver Mountain Water
Royal English Leather
Acier Aluminium
Original Santal

These are just top favorites. There are plenty of others I like a lot, own or are thinking of owning.
Reply
Reply
post #57 of 83
2/27/08 at 5:44am
it seems Bdp, GIT, SMW, Acier, tabarome are clear winners...
Reply
Reply
post #58 of 83
2/27/08 at 6:27am
"Perfume To Go All She Wants" is my one of my favorite eBay sellers. That's where I have purchased probably at least 50 bottles over the years.
Reply
Reply
post #59 of 83
2/27/08 at 6:53am
Since it isn't clear yet I'll point out that many of the recent Creed threads are apparently no more than bait for gullible Basenoters.

But keep replying if you wish. I would simply tell the person to search the archives.
Reply
Reply
post #60 of 83
2/27/08 at 9:12am
If I could only own five Creeds, I would go with Vetiver '48, Selection Verte, and Royal English Leather for daily wear; Vintage Tabarome and Acier Aluminium for evenings.
Reply
Reply
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: MFD Archive

Features on Basenotes

Petals Falling From The Sky - A Report From The Cote d'Azur's Bataille De Fleurs
Greatest Hits: Annick Menardo
Basenotes Reader Awards 2013 - Finalists Announced.
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › MFD Archive › Which Creed fragrance do you like best?