A couple folks already mentioned Pleasures by Lauder....try that one out, I agree it's in the same vein. Reaction by Kenneth Cole may be a good possibility and I'll even throw in Vetiver by Guerlain. I won't say Eternity and Vetiver are quite close to one another in how they come across, but the vetiver note in Eternity is an essential part of its character. The Guerlain scent takes on a different spin.....hey, you can at least try it, right?
'Ya know, I was thinking of this and almost ruled it out, but I'm gonna suggest it: L'Eau D'Iseey Pour Homme. Yeah.....the original Issey Miyake scent for Men. I dunno if someone mentioned it already and I'm too lazy to look. Check that one out if 'ya can.....I think it's in the same neighborhood.
And remember: Have fun!!!