I'll take a bottle of Himalaya over both.
However, I've noticed that Individuel gets a bit of a bad rap on the reviews, with many commenting that it's a Joop! rip-off.
I don't think they're THAT similar--but if they are, then let's hear it for one the most improved rip-offs in perfumery!
Joop! is cloying synthetic crap.
( Does that sound somewhat negative? )
MB Individuel is what a well paid GQ looking 20 something would use for officewear.
SMW is a refined, intriguing acqua scent anyone with good taste can enjoy but it's Creed and therefore, evil
Say, did I mention that I like Himalaya better?