I hate to say it but Aqua di Gio has received the most compliments from women. Unfortunately I don't like this fragrance.
Burberry London has received a lot of compliments, but only amongst my gf and family, who get close enough to me to smell it.
I'm such a gentleman that they look past this "flaw". My "flaw" being that I don't generally wear aquatics.
Is that the sound of panties hitting the floor? Nope, it's the sound of forum members droping posts here recommending you explore the world of perfume keep it classy! Cheers.