La Nuit is...meh. The One, while a spicy scent that still happens to be very pleasant all order is extremely weak. Honestly this question gets asked a lot, and I'd suggest you do a search. Unless you can get more specific about what you're looking for, what kind of fragrance you like or want to add to your collection and what's your budget.
Personally, some of my most complimented fragrances are Chergui, Ambre Precieux, Derby, Jubilation XXV, Iris Poudre and Musc Ravageur. My girlfriend also loves Tonka Imperiale. But all of those are a little pricey, and don't seem to be anything like what you usually purchase. In your situation, I'd wear Derby if I want to leave a mature impression, Musc Ravageur or Tonka Imperiale if I want sexy and Chergui if I'm unsure and just want to play it safe and feel like myself.
Allure Homme is alright, personal as with most Chanels I just find it to be more of a....Safe scent. You know, not something to leave an impression, just something that smells pleasant. But hey things that are simply pleasant leave impressions sometimes, just look at GIT. Though as much as I hate the term, if you want to venture into this whole "Panty Dropper" world, Le Male is probably the place to start, or one of it's various cheaper flankers (Cubano Gold, Cuba Gold...etc). Out of your list I like "The One" the most, but it's pathetically light so I'd go for La Nuit.