Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › Which scent gets you the most female compliments?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Which scent gets you the most female compliments? - Page 67

post #3961 of 5552
I always had great success with the original Escada (not the junk they put out now). The original Escada EDT has been discontinued from most stores and it's very difficult to find now. Pretty bummed that it's gone now.

Recently: YSL La Nuit De L'Homme, Hanae Mori. Want to try Aventus and the Bond scents. My biggest problem is finding a scent that sticks on me. That's why I veer towards EDP now instead of EDT.
post #3962 of 5552
I come across someone woman wearing Mitsouko, Bandit, or something like that, then it's usually mildly transforming and feels extremely good.

Android Menu
post #3963 of 5552
I've been getting a lot of compliments on Le Male lately but my #1 most complimented of all time is Versace Pour Homme.
post #3964 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by tbp82 View Post

I've been getting a lot of compliments on Le Male lately but my #1 most complimented of all time is Versace Pour Homme.

+1

Versace pour homme is getting a lot of compliments for me lately
post #3965 of 5552
I got a compliment from a co-worker yesterday wearing
Cristobal pour Homme de Balenciaga.
She said she couldn't stop turning her head in my
direction everytime I passed her.
post #3966 of 5552
my bottle of DIOR HOMME INTENSE arrived today! after quickly unwrapping it i sprayed a little on an index card. WOW!!! I CANT STOP SNIFFING IT! im pretty sure im giving myself a headache right not buuuuut its smells great. Cant wait to wear this tomorrow night at the bars
post #3967 of 5552
Terre D'Hermes and Bond No. 9 have been my two most complimented fragrances. I don't think a day has gone by where I have worn either and someone (man or woman) has not complimented me on those smells.
post #3968 of 5552
So far for me, Creeds Original Santal, Chanel Allure, D&G light blue and YVES nuit de l'homme has been even for me. If I was going to pick one I like Creeds Original Santal (perhaps the most underrated of all the Creeds and IMHO the best one they have).
post #3969 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by DrAdotP View Post

Terre D'Hermes and Bond No. 9 have been my two most complimented fragrances. I don't think a day has gone by where I have worn either and someone (man or woman) has not complimented me on those smells.

Which Bond? There are a couple dozen.
post #3970 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by SmellMePlease View Post

I always had great success with the original Escada (not the junk they put out now). The original Escada EDT has been discontinued from most stores and it's very difficult to find now. Pretty bummed that it's gone now.

Recently: YSL La Nuit De L'Homme, Hanae Mori. Want to try Aventus and the Bond scents. My biggest problem is finding a scent that sticks on me. That's why I veer towards EDP now instead of EDT.

i almost never see EDP for men...do you have any idea why?
post #3971 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by RiveGaucheInstead View Post

i almost never see EDP for men...do you have any idea why?

I think EDT sells much better than EDP. Also, maybe I'm wrong here, but EDP is stronger than EDT so perhaps the increased strength is more expensive to produce?
post #3972 of 5552
Givenchy Play Intense,Sung Homme,Pure Coffee/Pure Havane and Givenchy Pi have gotten me compliments . But mostly Play Intense.
post #3973 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by claytonmarionneaux View Post

5. Armani Code by Armani

Armani Code??? Really?? I'm thinking you can get it at Walgreen's these days....lol.

Don't mean to knock you, but the point is to be original. The scents "everyone has" probably won't separate you from the rest.
post #3974 of 5552
Got a "you smell nice" today

Joop Nightflight on its first test run
post #3975 of 5552
Re: Which scent get's most female compliments:

I have to say first, as a general rule, most females like most men's colognes. They are not too picky and love many if not most of the scents. Having said that, I get the absolute most compliments from a select few. These colognes get comments from women I know and women I do not know. Whether in the south of the United States, out west, or in the Northeast, I get the same comments. These colognes are teh following:
1.Abercrombie and Finch-Fierce
2.Paco Rabanne-One Million
3.Yves St Laurent-Lhommelibre
4.Dolce and Gabann-The One

Yes, these are the "trendy" colognes, but, they are popular for a reason. Girls love these scents. Women young and old will compliment you on your scent. By far, Fierce gets the most compliments of any I have used. All 4 of these last a long time and will give you a great scent for 8 to 10 hours. The first three seem to get more intense during a workout at the gym at the end of the day. Beware, ladies at the gym will notice and make flattering comments! You can't go wrong with these! I promise. Some folks like to wear "original" disigner secents, but, why not wear what you like and what gets attention. Since most women like a good smelling guy and are not very picky, buy a winner that will wow them!
post #3976 of 5552
Givenchy Pour Homme and I've worn it for ten years. Keep coming back to it though Creeds BdP might be a close second based on how it smells on me. Doesn't seem to last long in my skin though.

I wear Givenchy and 10 hours later I'm like "damn I smell good! Anyone else smelling this? Single file ladies, no fighting!"

I have to like it myself if Im wearing it for hours. I get compliments on Tabarome but can't love it; something is off to me though the dry down is nice. I may sell that.

I love bergamot and sandalwood so generally I look for those notes. Might get Sandalwood edt by Art of Shaving because I love the shaving cream. Smells great on me.
post #3977 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by Samarkand View Post

I wear Givenchy and 10 hours later I'm like "damn I smell good! Anyone else smelling this? Single file ladies, no fighting!"

hah. nice.
post #3978 of 5552
Some more for Dior Homme, and one for Versace Pour Homme.

Quote:
Originally Posted by checker View Post

Reformulation or Vintage? Both are great IMO

Reformulated ... I haven't even tried the vintage. Either way, Dior Homme is one of the sexiest scents out there.
post #3979 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by tbp82 View Post

I've been getting a lot of compliments on Le Male lately but my #1 most complimented of all time is Versace Pour Homme.

I am surprised at how good this is. It is very similar to Chanel Allure Sport, but I get wayyy more compliments on this than AHS. And that says a lot.

A very very underrated fragrance in my opinion.

Smell lasts on me for 12+ hours.
post #3980 of 5552
Just curious....anyone have any experience with Annick Goutal? I see it everywhere in the dept. stores, but haven't read much about it.
post #3981 of 5552
Well, I found a combo that is really raking in the compliments. Worn it twice now and everyone seems to love it...best yet my wife who rarely makes a comment LOVES it.

I wish I could take credit for the weird layering idea, but it was inspired by fellow basenoter Thaifighter.

I'm layering 3 sprays of Montale Fougres Marines below one spray of Montale Black Aoud. Thaifighter has in his signature that he likes layering GIT and Black Aoud, which gave me the idea. THe sum of the two together are greater than the parts and I never would have thought of trying such different scents together.
post #3982 of 5552
I get many compliments while wearing Prada Amber Pour Homme Intense (it's not listed on basenotes, why?) Girls say, that it's very elegant, drawing their attention, but not intruding.
post #3983 of 5552
Sup guys. So I was just thinking, most of us have heard the usual "u smell good!" compliment. But what about the unique compliments like "mmmm u smell like a dream!" or "OMG u smell good enough to eat!"?

As you get them, post the unique compliments u get.

I'll start it off with mine:

I wore Bond No 9 New Haarlem last night and my girl said "babe u smell like cinnoman toast crunch! I wanna eat u! Lol"
post #3984 of 5552
I think there was a thread like this before...I remember commenting in it. Let me see if I can find it
post #3985 of 5552
This thread is so gonna get merged with the compliments sticky thread
post #3986 of 5552
I started a thread a while back about people telling you that you smell like something else. I don't rember the exact name of the thread though.
post #3987 of 5552
I'd also suggest merging with the previous thread on a similar theme

But meanwhile, almost instantly, as an unusual compliment, the situation when I got "remotely complimented" on Facebook for wearing Knize Ten by a person living about 200-300 km away from my town of residence and writing this compliment from the PC at her place came to my mind
post #3988 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ken_Russell View Post

I'd also suggest merging with the previous thread on a similar theme

Agree.
post #3989 of 5552
I have received the most compliments on Le Labo Poivre 23. Women literally run up to me asking me what fragerance am I wearing. Of course I tell them something else ( want to remain exclusive) and they go for it.
post #3990 of 5552
I personally believe there is no such thing as a 'compliment getter' when it comes to fragrances.
No matter what you're wearing, it's you as person combined with the fragrance you are wearing which garners the compliments.

Example; if you're a serious person who is authoritative and perhaps even slightly unapproachable, it would make no difference if you were wearing the 'best' fragrance in the world, it's highly likely that you wouldn't gain a single compliment

On the other hand, if you're an outgoing person whom people warm to, you are very likely to receive many compliments, no matter what you have on.

What matters most above all else is your personal enjoyment of a fragrance and the memories or associations attached to it.
post #3991 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by lucasai View Post

I get many compliments while wearing Prada Amber Pour Homme Intense (it's not listed on basenotes, why?) Girls say, that it's very elegant, drawing their attention, but not intruding.

I own Prada Intense too - a great winter scent. Yes, strange that it's not on Basenotes.
post #3992 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by delguy View Post

I have received the most compliments on Le Labo Poivre 23. Women literally run up to me asking me what fragerance am I wearing. Of course I tell them something else ( want to remain exclusive) and they go for it.

But they will go look for it and when they find what ever you said they'll be confused????

Sent from my SK17i using Tapatalk
post #3993 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by Giannino View Post

I personally believe there is no such thing as a 'compliment getter' when it comes to fragrances.
No matter what you're wearing, it's you as person combined with the fragrance you are wearing which garners the compliments.

Example; if you're a serious person who is authoritative and perhaps even slightly unapproachable, it would make no difference if you were wearing the 'best' fragrance in the world, it's highly likely that you wouldn't gain a single compliment

On the other hand, if you're an outgoing person whom people warm to, you are very likely to receive many compliments, no matter what you have on.

What matters most above all else is your personal enjoyment of a fragrance and the memories or associations attached to it.

+1. Personality plays a huge part in garnering positive comments. Sometimes I feel that appearance plays a small part too to be honest.
post #3994 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by Giannino View Post

I personally believe there is no such thing as a 'compliment getter' when it comes to fragrances.
No matter what you're wearing, it's you as person combined with the fragrance you are wearing which garners the compliments.

Example; if you're a serious person who is authoritative and perhaps even slightly unapproachable, it would make no difference if you were wearing the 'best' fragrance in the world, it's highly likely that you wouldn't gain a single compliment

On the other hand, if you're an outgoing person whom people warm to, you are very likely to receive many compliments, no matter what you have on.

What matters most above all else is your personal enjoyment of a fragrance and the memories or associations attached to it.

+1

Being warm and friendly and approachable...and if the chemistry is good with the female company, guaranteed she will like your fragrance.
post #3995 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by Giannino View Post

I personally believe there is no such thing as a 'compliment getter' when it comes to fragrances.
No matter what you're wearing, it's you as person combined with the fragrance you are wearing which garners the compliments.

Example; if you're a serious person who is authoritative and perhaps even slightly unapproachable, it would make no difference if you were wearing the 'best' fragrance in the world, it's highly likely that you wouldn't gain a single compliment

On the other hand, if you're an outgoing person whom people warm to, you are very likely to receive many compliments, no matter what you have on.

What matters most above all else is your personal enjoyment of a fragrance and the memories or associations attached to it.

So, how do you explain the same person getting compliments everyone he/she wears a certain fragrance and not when wearing others.. The personality don't change from one day to the next. If it does, we got some other issues to worry about and not whether he our she gets a compliment. Just saying
post #3996 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by Giannino View Post

I personally believe there is no such thing as a 'compliment getter' when it comes to fragrances.
No matter what you're wearing, it's you as person combined with the fragrance you are wearing which garners the compliments.

Example; if you're a serious person who is authoritative and perhaps even slightly unapproachable, it would make no difference if you were wearing the 'best' fragrance in the world, it's highly likely that you wouldn't gain a single compliment

On the other hand, if you're an outgoing person whom people warm to, you are very likely to receive many compliments, no matter what you have on.

What matters most above all else is your personal enjoyment of a fragrance and the memories or associations attached to it.

Even if you are very sexy, outgoing and all, if you smell like shit you will not have any compliments.
post #3997 of 5552
I agree with Scentdawg and Psycho. I think scents do matter. I do NOT think you're being complimented on your personality when a woman runs up and compliments your cologne. I have sniffed out men I was not even attracted to, wondering what they're wearing.
post #3998 of 5552
Ah, the irony in the whole women approaching men, asking fragrance name, only to purchase it for their boyfriends/husbands...

Because I'm pretty sure if a man said, "Honey! I want you to smell like this woman I met the other day!" He'd get smacked.

=)
post #3999 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by Scentdawg View Post

So, how do you explain the same person getting compliments everyone he/she wears a certain fragrance and not when wearing others.. The personality don't change from one day to the next. If it does, we got some other issues to worry about and not whether he our she gets a compliment. Just saying

I see your point, but my view is that if you were more introverted, serious and less approachable, it's likely you wouldn't have received the compliment to begin with. Just my opinion...
post #4000 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by RiveGaucheInstead View Post

I agree with Scentdawg and Psycho. I think scents do matter. I do NOT think you're being complimented on your personality when a woman runs up and compliments your cologne. I have sniffed out men I was not even attracted to, wondering what they're wearing.

My point was in relation to compliments from people who know you, or work with you.
Of course we all get stopped/stop others on the street to ask what someone is wearing purely in relation to that specific fragrance and nothing whatsoever to with their persona, since they're a total stranger.
I believe if you don't take a liking to someone you know, for whatever reason, it's highly unlikely you would compliment their fragrance no matter how much you liked it.
post #4001 of 5552
...
post #4002 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by PsYcHo View Post

Even if you are very sexy, outgoing and all, if you smell like shit you will not have any compliments.

Well, I don't know of any fragrances that smell like "sh*t", but you know what - even if there were such a fragrance, consider it from another angle.
If you knew someone who was "sexy, outgoing and all" and you found them attractive, I believe you would think up a compliment of any kind, perhaps even in relation to the "sh*t" fragrance they had on.

Just a thought...
post #4003 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by PsYcHo View Post

Even if you are very sexy, outgoing and all, if you smell like shit you will not have any compliments.

Well, I don't know of any fragrances that smell like "sh*t", but you know what - even if there were such a fragrance, consider it from another angle.
If you knew someone who was "sexy, outgoing and all" and you found them attractive, I believe you would think up a compliment of any kind, perhaps even in relation to the "sh*t" fragrance they had on.

Just a thought...
post #4004 of 5552
Got several compliments last night wearing Bvlgari Soir. I been wearing it for a couple of years and it never fails...
post #4005 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by checker View Post

Got several compliments last night wearing Bvlgari Soir. I been wearing it for a couple of years and it never fails...

I remember receiving a compliment from an African American lady. It was pretty funny. I was in the hood when it happened, so when she shouted at me "Aye! Excuse me!.." I was relieved when she simply said I smelt "damn good." hahaha
post #4006 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by G Man View Post

I remember receiving a compliment from an African American lady. It was pretty funny. I was in the hood when it happened, so when she shouted at me "Aye! Excuse me!.." I was relieved when she simply said I smelt "damn good." hahaha

haha thats funny! It really is a great scent indeed with good sillage and longevity..
post #4007 of 5552
I have been testing LOADS of samples recently as i'm quite new to this fragrance hobby, and I always ask my girlfriend her opinion. She's kind of getting fed up of me asking "how do you like this one?" and sticking my wrist in her face.

Today I tried my sample of L'instant de Guerlain Extreme, and without prompting she told me I smell fantastic, despite her weariness of my constant requests for feedback. I think i'll be getting a bottle.
post #4008 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by corbain View Post

I have been testing LOADS of samples recently as i'm quite new to this fragrance hobby, and I always ask my girlfriend her opinion. She's kind of getting fed up of me asking "how do you like this one?" and sticking my wrist in her face.

Today I tried my sample of L'instant de Guerlain Extreme, and without prompting she told me I smell fantastic, despite her weariness of my constant requests for feedback. I think i'll be getting a bottle.

Now that's what I call feedback.
post #4009 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by SmellMePlease View Post

Armani Code??? Really?? I'm thinking you can get it at Walgreen's these days....lol.

Don't mean to knock you, but the point is to be original. The scents "everyone has" probably won't separate you from the rest.

Yes, I was in Walgreen's recently and noticed Armani Code on sale. They actually had a large, department-store-like fragrance section with its own cash register and sales person.
post #4010 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by Giannino View Post

I personally believe there is no such thing as a 'compliment getter' when it comes to fragrances.
No matter what you're wearing, it's you as person combined with the fragrance you are wearing which garners the compliments.

Example; if you're a serious person who is authoritative and perhaps even slightly unapproachable, it would make no difference if you were wearing the 'best' fragrance in the world, it's highly likely that you wouldn't gain a single compliment

On the other hand, if you're an outgoing person whom people warm to, you are very likely to receive many compliments, no matter what you have on.

What matters most above all else is your personal enjoyment of a fragrance and the memories or associations attached to it.

I think environment must have something to do with it, though. For example, thinking about it I can't recall ever hearing a remark about someone's fragrance, man or woman, at work, in all the years I have been employed (I do get complements on my clothes at work, however, especially lately). I have usually worked in places where most people had private offices, which meant you usually couldn't smell someone unless you were in a meeting, in which case it would be less appropriate to make a comment. Also, people in my work environments generally have used fragrances very discretely, if at all.

I would also guess people would be more likely to complement your fragrance in the south than in the north and in environments where conspicuous fragrance-wearing was more common (e.g., bars and nightclubs). I would guess that places where people come and go a lot or work in an open space would produce more comments than a more sedate environment and also places where people came in close contact with each other, like a restaurant or hair salon.
post #4011 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by corbain View Post

I have been testing LOADS of samples recently as i'm quite new to this fragrance hobby, and I always ask my girlfriend her opinion. She's kind of getting fed up of me asking "how do you like this one?" and sticking my wrist in her face.

Today I tried my sample of L'instant de Guerlain Extreme, and without prompting she told me I smell fantastic, despite her weariness of my constant requests for feedback. I think i'll be getting a bottle.

My wife gave me the exact same response with LIDGE. And she is also annoyed by me always asking "and what about this one?". My enthusiasm was tempered by the fact that about a week later I asked her to sniff LIDGE (didn't tell her it's the same scent as before) and she gave it a so-so response. LOL.

The other ones she complimented independently was Absolue Pour Le Soir.
post #4012 of 5552
LIDGE sounds considerably less 'colourful' than L'instant de Guerlain Extreme
post #4013 of 5552
Yeah, LIDGE does sound like a bathroom or furniture cleaning product.
post #4014 of 5552
I will say that all this is highly dependent on each person, how your skin reacts to the cologne, your personality, etc. For example, many people rave about Bond No. 9 New Haarlem. I tried it on over the weekend @ Saks and it smelled disgusting to me. Even the woman at the fragrance counter shook her head when I put it on....and suggested I try another scent.

There is no 'magic formula' scent. There are many great scents out there, but it's all trial and error.

What may work for one guy won't necessarily work at all for you.
post #4015 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by BurgundyMarsh View Post

Yes, I was in Walgreen's recently and noticed Armani Code on sale. They actually had a large, department-store-like fragrance section with its own cash register and sales person.

I've browsed the Walgreen's fragrance counters at a couple local stores to see if I could find anything interesting at a good price. Unfortunately I found that several fragrances were not really that much cheaper than a regular department store. They did have some cheaper ones but those were things like Grey Flannel and other EA frags. Fahrenheit was $52 for a 1.7 oz. Heck, Wal-Mart has it for $43. I'm sure they have some really good deals for the holiday season.
post #4016 of 5552
Another one for Aventus
post #4017 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by alexandermller82 View Post

I've noticed how many people here talk about the compliments they receive for wearing fragrances.

And your point is???
post #4018 of 5552
Again this morning... This beautiful / gorgeous legal assistant passed by my office and said :

"It does always smell good around here !"

And she smiled at me...

Creed Aventus

post #4019 of 5552
I got a compliment from a woman behind the counter while on a cruise to the Bahamas this past weekend while wearing Aventus (the batch I have is fruity, not smoky). And yesterday got another while wearing Minotaure.
post #4020 of 5552
Quote:
Originally Posted by Profumo Saggio View Post

I've browsed the Walgreen's fragrance counters at a couple local stores to see if I could find anything interesting at a good price. Unfortunately I found that several fragrances were not really that much cheaper than a regular department store. They did have some cheaper ones but those were things like Grey Flannel and other EA frags. Fahrenheit was $52 for a 1.7 oz. Heck, Wal-Mart has it for $43. I'm sure they have some really good deals for the holiday season.

The Walgreen selection I saw was slightly better than CVS and the prices were not anything special. Among retail outlets I have checked, Target seems to have the best prices though the selection is only the regular standards. Those places all have sales, though. I've only found a really good selection retail at the very high end department stores, though the Sephora I visit from time to time (fairly sedate, not mobbed with kids) is getting better, at least in the men's dept.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Male Fragrance Discussion
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › Which scent gets you the most female compliments?