New York is officially in "rot mode". It's when all the garbage trucks have fermented and fill the NY streets with their odor. It's like a fish market that had its refrigeration system fail. NY has gotten wetter and wetter over the past decade and the "rot mode" came early this year.
That said, in NYC, nothing says "tourist" or "bridge and tunnel" more than a heavy hand with a fragrance.
Out of your list I would stick with the Creed Vetiver for day and perhaps Tea for Two for evening. NY'ers aren't so big on sillage from others. Antaeus, like smoking, has actually been baned from all NY restaurants. Just kidding.
Enjoy all the great things that NYC has to offer.