I have a review editing problem,too. First, there is no editing option at the moment, correct? [It's not just me, or my status? Hard to tell b/c this editing feature thread goes so many years back]
When I view my review of Mecca (lby searching the Mecca reviews page) my review shows a neutral instead of a positive. But I noticed that when I click on all of my reviews, my review of Mecca shows up as positive (which was my intention).
I'm wondering-- it seems editing rarely works--is the site is going in the direction of phasing out editing or is it just a glitchy feature, still a work in progress?
I wonder, too, if editing ends up not being an option (or only an option for BN +--as someone suggested ) if we could have a chance to at least have one last pass at editing, or at least deleting our reviews.
It's so embarrassing to find typos, or to find a thumbs down mistakenly posted with a glowing review (something I see quite frequently). Not to mention that it would be nice to go back and add info (EDT vs EDP; change of heart; info on year of formulation, since scents change and review soften no longer match what is out there; sillage experiments; season experiments;and so on).
I confess I feel a bit nervous about the "carved in stone" status, as it were.