Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › MFD Archive › SotW August 16th-22nd, 2008
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

SotW August 16th-22nd, 2008

post #1 of 13
Thread Starter 
It’s been a busy two weeks here at the Scentlympic Games in Basenotes City. We’re all gathered here in the main Scentlympic Stadium, nicknamed the Fragrant Forum, for the closing ceremonies. Very shortly ISC Commissioner Grant Osborne will extinguish the flaming atomizer and it will be four long years until the fragrant houses gather again. Before the end let’s review the last seven days here in Basenotes City and see what Week 25 looked like.
There were 1,134 scents posted, our second-highest total.
A total of 682 scents were mentioned which is our highest total, to date.
468 scents were mentioned just once for an individuality index of 41.3%. The first number is our second-highest number and the individuality index is slightly lower than the average.
The last three weeks have been huge weeks overall as we have been above 1,110 posts, 665 individual scents, and 439 single wears. Even with all of that there are some things that just stay the same.
One of those things is the big 5 houses. This week it was a Chanel world as Chanel had 57 wears over 23 scents and placed two scents into the top 10. Chanel nearly doubled the amount of wears from the last three weeks and was just short of hitting an all-time house total. Guerlain is the most worn house this week with 66 wears over 27 scents. Guerlain takes back the House crown from Serge Lutens. Serge Lutens dropped in half the number of wears from last week as it had 35 wears over 20 scents. Hermes also had a precipitous drop down to 31 wears over 13 scents. Creed was right in the middle with another consistent 55 wears over 19 scents. The big 5 represented 21.5% of all wears and 15.0% of all scents worn.
You might wonder why I don’t include Yves St. Laurent in the top houses. If you were to look at this week with 49 wears over 16 scents you might think it should be included. This is the most inconsistent house in the survey as it can have a week like this with two scents in the top 3 and high overall totals and then it can have a week like Week 20 where it posts 25 wears over 10 scents. There are clearly some beloved scents but the community tends to run hot and cold on them and when its cold, it’s really cold. What makes the big 5 stand out is none of them have had a week below 30 wears. As you’ve seen particularly in the last two weeks there can be an almost doubling from one week to the next but these five houses are the most consistent of all of the houses.
Comme des Garcons still is down and Hinoki had its worst week in almost two months which helps drag the CdG total down. L’Artisan is a house which usually sees some pretty diverse wear patterns but over the last month it has been way down and has been at its lowest point since I’ve been keeping track. The houses which had big up weeks were Acqua di Parma, Bond #9, Jo Malone, Versace and Parfumerie Generale. Parfumerie Generale posted its best week ever.
One thing I’ve been watching is, how does posting on the forums affect the wear pattern of a scent or house. This week was a good example of forum postings seeing increased wears from Lalique Encre Noir, Le Labo Rose 31, The Different Company Sel de Vetiver, Possets, Montale, and Neil Morris. All of these saw spikes over previous totals. This hasn’t always been a reliable barometer as there are some weeks where there is a lot of chatter over a number of scents that will only get a wear or two. It is still less likely to see the forums truly boost something but this week there seemed to be more of a correlation than in weeks past and I thought I’d mention it.
On to the top 10. This week looks like a top 10 from before the ladies were included. There was only one scent in the top 10 that was predominantly worn by the ladies. That doesn’t mean they were idle this week as 6 of the scents in the just missed category were predominantly female worn scents. This is a top 10 of scents we’ve mentioned in the past and at the top is Guerlain Vetiver followed by two Yves St. Laurent scents Kouros and Rive Gauche pour Homme. Tied for fourth are two Creeds Green Irish Tweed and after a 13 week absence Bois du Portugal returns to the top 10. Along with the Creeds, Le Labo Rose 31 and Tauer L’Air du Desert Marocain share the 4th spot. Tied with Hermes Terre D’Hermes in the 8th spot is The Different Company Sel de Vetiver. As of Friday morning Terre D’Hermes was in danger of missing its first top 10 but it put on a three wear finishing kick to make it back into the top 10. Sel De Vetiver has been on a slow build throughout the summer and it finally results in a top 10 appearance. DK Black Cashmere is the only scent the ladies put into the top 10 this week. Chanel has Antaeus and Egoiste in the top 10. Guerlain adds Habit Rouge and Heritage to go with Vetiver at the top. The last two members are Acqua di Parma Colonia Assoluta and Montale Black Aoud.
Here now the SotW top 10 for August 16th-22nd, 2008
1.)\tGuerlain Vetiver 14 wears (1.2%)
2.)\tYves St. Laurent Kouros 13 wears (1.1%)
3.)\tYves St. Laurent Rive Gauche pour Homme 12 wears (1.0%)
4.)\tCreed Bois du Portugal 9 wears (0.8%)
4.)\tCreed Green Irish Tweed 9 wears (0.8%)
4.)\tLe Labo Rose 31 9 wears (0.8%)
4.)\tTauer L’Air du Desert Marocain 9 wears (0.8%)
8.)\tHermes Terre D’Hermes 8 wears (0.7%)
8.)\tThe Different Company Sel de Vetiver 8 wears (0.7%)
10.)\tAcqua di Parma Colonia Assoluta 6 wears (0.5%)
10.)\tChanel Antaeus 6 wears (0.5%)
10.)\tChanel Egoiste 6 wears (0.5%)
10.)\tDonna Karan Black Cashmere 6 wears (0.5%)
10.)\tGuerlain Habit Rouge 6 wears (0.5%)
10.)\tGuerlain Heritage 6 wears (0.5%)
10.)\tMontale Black Aoud 6 wears (0.5%)

16 scents were one wear away from making the top 10. Most notable from that group were Amouage Jubilation XXV which has seen an increased wear pattern and this was the second time it’s been close. There have been a lot of new male scents out there and I’ve seen that reflected in the sampling going on this week. Prada Infusion D’Homme got a decent sampling and just missed making the top 10 by one wear. Hinoki and Sensuous are the front runners for most worn new scent but the new fall releases might change that.
It has been a lovely Scentlympic Games and Commissioner Osborne should be proud of the way his hometown of Basenotes City has hosted the Scented Cognoscenti. He is now standing next to the flaming crystal atomizer which has been the symbol of these games and with one last geyser of flame he brings these games to a close.
As always, you keep wearing ‘em and I’ll keep counting ‘em
Have a well-fragranced week.
post #2 of 13
entertaining and informative as usual......great job!
post #3 of 13
Note to self:
Remember to try Sel de Vetiver.

Thanks my friend, we benefit from all the work you do!
post #4 of 13
Great jobs as usual! I've helped four frags get into the top 10 this week
post #5 of 13
Metro Man, thank you for this interesting contribution!
You add a new perspective to the SOTD threads, and I shall be looking forward to future editions.
Have you thought of working on even longer intervals yet?
post #6 of 13
To my knowledge there have already been a couple of SotM(onth) threads by his hand, Narcus.
post #7 of 13
Quote:
Originally Posted by TwoRoads View Post

Thanks my friend, we benefit from all the work you do!

Absolutely, and from my home town of Miramar, Florida too!
post #8 of 13
Quote:
Originally Posted by Merlino View Post

To my knowledge there have already been a couple of SotM(onth) threads by his hand, Narcus.

Yes, and one SotQ(uarter) so far as well!
post #9 of 13
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by narcus View Post

Have you thought of working on even longer intervals yet?

As the others have already posted I've done SotM for every month since I started in March. also SotQ which I see you found.
My purpose for doing this is to observe the Basenotes community for an entire year and see what I see.
My intention at the end of the year's worth of data gathering is to pull subsets of stats up like for instance focusing on Serge Lutens and talk about how the wear patterns changed over the course of the year. I'll probably take the yearly top 10 and comment on each of those and how they developed. I would like to take one new fragrance and show it from testing through acceptance, Hinoki looks like the likely candidate for that treatment. I'll try and look for warm-weather vs. cold-weather patterns.
In almost six months of doing this it has been an incredibly educational experience.
I've really enjoyed watching the ebb and flow of what we wear as a community.
Next weekend will be a big stats weekend with SotW Week 26, SotM August, SotQ June-August and SotHY March-August.
It will be the half-way mark of the experiment and I'm betting all four sets of stats will look somewhat different except for one constant.
Thank to all of you for your support I'm glad you are all enjoying this as much as me.
post #10 of 13
SMM, is it too soon to start lobbying you to continue this fascinating study after the first year concludes? The final frontier is seemingly an endless quest!
post #11 of 13
Quote:
Originally Posted by Somerville Metro Man View Post

As the others have already posted I've done SotM for every month since I started in March. also SotQ which I see you found.
My purpose for doing this is to observe the Basenotes community for an entire year and see what I see.
.....
Thank to all of you for your support I'm glad you are all enjoying this as much as me.

It's a wonderful, new discovery for me, and I'll try to grow into this fast. It's amazing how I missed all of this in the past six months! My only excuse: from day one onwards I left 95% of all SOTD threads unopned, because I failed to see a point in them.
Thank you Merlino and TwoRoads helping me to find the quartely / monthly threads immediately.
post #12 of 13
Quote:
Originally Posted by narcus View Post

It's a wonderful, new discovery for me, and I'll try to grow into this fast. It's amazing how I missed all of this in the past six months! My only excuse: from day one onwards I left 95% of all SOTD threads unopned, because I failed to see a point in them.
Thank you Merlino and TwoRoads helping me to find the quartely / monthly threads immediately.

I think that's one of the real beauties of SotD - the data actually has real meaning and information for us. It's some really fascinating stuff, too, but it takes some serious effort and thought to summon the genie out of the bottle.

Quote:
I'm betting all four sets of stats will look somewhat different except for one constant.

He-he-he! And the constant had a rough week, too!
post #13 of 13
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by TwoRoads View Post

SMM, is it too soon to start lobbying you to continue this fascinating study after the first year concludes? The final frontier is seemingly an endless quest!

Yes it is too early.

Let's see where we stand five months from now.
Then you can really start to work on me.
Or you may be tired of my nonsense by then and be happy its near an end.
Who knows?

No matter what thanks for all of your kind words and support.
The idea that you want more makes it easier to keep doing it.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: MFD Archive
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › MFD Archive › SotW August 16th-22nd, 2008