Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › MFD Archive › Three Solid Fall/Winter Fragrances?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Three Solid Fall/Winter Fragrances?

post #1 of 48
Thread Starter 
Out of this list, which do you think are the best three fragrances for Fall/Winter? Are these versatile enough to be worn any time of the year besides Black XS? I can certainly end up buying all of them but just want to hear your opinions. Feel free to suggest other fragrances that may compliment the list.

Wishlist:

A*Men (Have yet to test on skin but will do so soon at store).
Black XS (Will buy blind because I don't know where to sample this).
Body Kouros (May buy blind or sample).
Burberry London (Tested and liked but concerned about longevity).
Rive Gauche pour Homme (May buy blind or sample).

Test List:

Bulgari Black (Will test this).
Diesel Zero Plus (Where can I get a sample of this?).
L'Anarchiste (Will test this).
post #2 of 48
Nice choices. I agree with all except Burberry- just not my thing. IMHO, Rive Gauche PH is the most all season wear of the group.

Check out:
Opium PH
Gucci Envy
and definitely
OPUS 1870- this is winter wear all the way to me.
post #3 of 48
Opium most certainly, either EDT or P, M7 comes into its own and Cristobal will see me through the coldest days ahead.
post #4 of 48
Burb London and Rive Gauche. I'd substitute in Lolita Lempicka au Masculin for A*Men, a much easier-to-wear gourmand IMO. Regarding Black XS, give Dolce & Gabanna Light Blue (the ladies version) a try - Black XS is quite similar.
post #5 of 48
Thread Starter 
Opium sounds nice but the list of ingredients is so large that I feel like I will get cancer after a few sprays. I don't know why they plastered that fragrance with all of those unecessary ingredients. Lolita Lempicka au Masculin was on my test list but then I took it off because I don't know where to get a sample of this and I'm not willing to buy blind on that one. It is back on my test list but I don't know where to sample it.
post #6 of 48
My three favs from your list are:

Body Kouros
Rive Gauche pour Homme
L'Anarchiste
post #7 of 48
Opium is a masterful blend. It is many fragrances over the course of its development. There are nuances to it that the Kouros family is missing. If your nose is good, you'll be amazed at the play between subtleties and aggression that Opium goes through. Don't get me wrong, Body Kouros is fantastic, but a different frag than Opium.
post #8 of 48
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ronin View Post

Out of this list, which do you think are the best three fragrances for Fall/Winter? Are these versatile enough to be worn any time of the year besides Black XS? I can certainly end up buying all of them but just want to hear your opinions. Feel free to suggest other fragrances that may compliment the list.

Wishlist:

A*Men (Have yet to test on skin but will do so soon at store).
Black XS (Will buy blind because I don't know where to sample this).
Body Kouros (May buy blind or sample).
Burberry London (Tested and liked but concerned about longevity).
Rive Gauche pour Homme (May buy blind or sample).

Test List:

Bulgari Black (Will test this).
Diesel Zero Plus (Where can I get a sample of this?).
L'Anarchiste (Will test this).

My friend, you do realize that there is no link between cancer and fragrance ingredients, and even the relation between certain ingredients and skin reactions are tenous at best? I would hate for you to miss out on beautiful scents because paranoid watchdog organizations have bombarded you with misinformation. I'm a scientist, if you ever have any questions regarding the potential medical significance of any ingredient in a fragrance, please let me know and I would be more than happy to search the available resources I have at work and home to see if there has been any solid evidence that it has done harm.

I know your asked in another thread but the ingredients in Rive Gauche:
Alcohol
Water
Parfum
Benzyl Salicyclate
Linalool
Limonene
Hydroxycitronellal
Butyl Methoxydibenzolylmethane
Butylphenyl Methylpropiional
Hydroxyishohexyl-3-cyclohexene
Carboxaldehyde
Citronellol
Eugenol
Coumarin
Oakmoss
BHT
Citral
post #9 of 48
1. Alfred Dunhill 1934
2. Richard James
3. Habit Rouge or Egoiste, take your pick.

Cheers,

Mario
post #10 of 48
L'Anarchiste is a must have for fall - Burberry London too (I get ridiculous longevity on this one, strangely.)
I find L'Anarchiste is wearable - when adjusting the amount for season - all year long. It really comes alive in summer, and presents a darker, spicier and woodier aspect of itself in the winter.

I found Body Kouros to be amazing at first, bought a bottle, and after a few wears found it's thick and syrupy texture to be rather sickening. For a similar but lighter and more versatile scent to Body Kouros, check out Bulgari Pour Homme Soir (thanks to Jenson for first noticing the link between this and BK - they definitely both share a prominent note!)

A few more designer scents to consider: V&R Antidote (spicy cinnamon nutmeg, sweet amber) and Santana for men (sweet cinnamon and tonka, very much an autumn scent).

I'd also recommend, if you're willing to investigate niche houses, Les Nez Let Me Play the Lion (warm cedar and sweet ambergris, very woody but cozy) , CDG Monocle: Hinoki (straight up wood!), Montale's Original Aoud/Bois De Aoud (another good dry woody scent), a good vetiver such as Route Du Vetiver (dark and earthy!) by MPG or Annick Goutal's Vetiver (starts light and salty like a sea breeze but gets smokey), and if you like rum, Idole de Lubin.
post #11 of 48
Thread Starter 
Shalashaska, thanks for the list of ingredients for Rive Gauche. If you would have ingested some of those things then I bet there would be harm. Your skin should absorb some of those ingredients. Maybe the absorption is insignificant but over time there can be harm. Perhaps I am overreacting considering all of the dangers we experience through the everyday environment. Maybe I am a bit paranoid but I still wonder why companies must toss in a bunch of ingredients that serve no purpose.

The first time I sprayed Burberry London it diminished rather quickly and I could only smell it when up close to the skin. The second time I sprayed on the hair of my forearm and it lasted a while. I'm assuming that if I spray on body hair and then put on my shirt that it will remain there for a long time. L'Anarchiste seems interesting. Anyway, would Opium be a good casual choice for someone in their early 20s? Seems a bit sophisticated from the description. Thanks for the suggestions.
post #12 of 48
DK Fuel

M7

Obsession
post #13 of 48
Quote:
Originally Posted by mrclmind View Post

My three favs from your list are:

Body Kouros
Rive Gauche pour Homme
L'Anarchiste

Agreed, at least among the ones you named. Otherwise there's full of alternative options both designer or niche from Opium PH to Egoiste or Antaeus, from Narciso Rodriguez for him to Heritage....
post #14 of 48
Polo Modern Reserve
Burberry London
TdH

Simple and all three are perfect
post #15 of 48
There's so many great, rich fragrances perfect for winter. I've only got about 3-4 months of cooler weather, and I'll be taking advantage of the cooler weather to wear items more oppressive in the summer, like:

Polo
M7
Fahrenheit
post #16 of 48
Ive read on several smelly sites that Chanel Cuir De Russie is a perfect fragrance for winter but Ive never smelt it .....
post #17 of 48
L'anarchiste would be my choice. Too bad I had serious longevity issues with it. If It lasted on me for more than an hour I would still own it.
post #18 of 48
in this order..:

1.- Bvlgari Black
2.- Burberry London(excellent sillage and longevity at least on me..test it!)
3.- Rive Gauche
post #19 of 48
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ronin View Post

Shalashaska, thanks for the list of ingredients for Rive Gauche. If you would have ingested some of those things then I bet there would be harm. Your skin should absorb some of those ingredients. Maybe the absorption is insignificant but over time there can be harm. Perhaps I am overreacting considering all of the dangers we experience through the everyday environment. Maybe I am a bit paranoid but I still wonder why companies must toss in a bunch of ingredients that serve no purpose.

The first time I sprayed Burberry London it diminished rather quickly and I could only smell it when up close to the skin. The second time I sprayed on the hair of my forearm and it lasted a while. I'm assuming that if I spray on body hair and then put on my shirt that it will remain there for a long time. L'Anarchiste seems interesting. Anyway, would Opium be a good casual choice for someone in their early 20s? Seems a bit sophisticated from the description. Thanks for the suggestions.

I love L'Anarchiste *now*, but in the beginning I didn't get it and gave away my original bottle. Get a decent sized decant of it before you buy a full bottle, you may love it at first sniff or it may take some time to grow, but please don't make a full choice after one or two wearings.

Regarding Opium, try and find the Eau D'Orient EDT version from 2006,2007, or 2008. They are all lighter, fresher takes on the original that are meant for summer wear but work beautifully in the winter too. They also strike me as more 'casual' than the original Opium, more crisp, and less cloying. Definetely easier to pull off for a younger man.

If London doesn't last long for you but you still like the 'boozy' vibe, try John Varvatos Vintage. A scent in the same vein but a little drier, still perfect for winter. While you're at it, sniff out the original Varvatos too.


And as far as chemical exposure guys, many of the chemicals listed were preservants and enhancers that I believe help the scent go into aeorsol form easer. I think, I'd have to look them up though. The main thing is that the skin is actually tougher and more resistant that you give it credit for, and only minute amounts of any chemical there would actually be absorbed. You basically ingest far, far worse from food and inhale worse from walking outside in a city. Is there a risk from a fragrance? Sure, but it is so minimal compared to everything else or even by itself that I wouldn't worry about it. Also, don't think that the ingredient list on any fragrance is complete. They list 'parfum' as an ingredient, what does that tell us? Nothing at all, doesn't tell you which oils they used or even if they were synthetic or natural.
post #20 of 48
Opium and age? Hmmm. Ya know, that's a good question. My gut reaction is that it is sophisticated and therefore maybe not "for" a 20 year old. But that precludes that 20 year olds aren't sophisticated. I think the debate is more about trendiness vs. classic potential. I was wearing Eau Sauvage and Blenheim Bouquet when I was 20 and those certainly aren't trendy. Then again, being the stereotypical rebellious youth was never my thing. I never paid much attention to what was age appropriate. Are John Varvatos and Magnetism typically worn by 38 year olds? I don't know for sure, but I like them, so I wear them. I can see how the classic citruses like Eau Sauvage, Cravache, Blenheim Bouquet, Boucheron,etc... ad nauseum could be perceived as old manish as everyday wear, but Opium's spicy, oriental is more versatile in my book. I might even say it's the bridge between trendy and classic.
post #21 of 48
The 3 I would pick from your list are:

> Black XS
> Rive Gauche pour Homme
> Diesel Zero Plus

I would also suggest you test Fahrenheit by Christian Dior, its not for everybody but one of my favorites....I use it in the cooler months. Its a spicy scent.

Good Luck
post #22 of 48
Body Kouros
Kouros
M7

Stick with the YSL's you won't be disappointed
post #23 of 48
Burberry London
Gucci PH
post #24 of 48
Carolina Herrera for men

Body Kouros or M7

Nemo Cacharel
post #25 of 48
My three favs from your list are:

Body Kouros
Rive Gauche pour Homme
L'Anarchiste


My favs from my collection are

Jaipur
rochas lui
M7
Gucci Envy
Visit
Nemo
post #26 of 48
Quote:
Originally Posted by argogos View Post

Opium and age? Hmmm. Ya know, that's a good question. My gut reaction is that it is sophisticated and therefore maybe not "for" a 20 year old. But that precludes that 20 year olds aren't sophisticated. I think the debate is more about trendiness vs. classic potential. I was wearing Eau Sauvage and Blenheim Bouquet when I was 20 and those certainly aren't trendy. Then again, being the stereotypical rebellious youth was never my thing. I never paid much attention to what was age appropriate. Are John Varvatos and Magnetism typically worn by 38 year olds? I don't know for sure, but I like them, so I wear them. I can see how the classic citruses like Eau Sauvage, Cravache, Blenheim Bouquet, Boucheron,etc... ad nauseum could be perceived as old manish as everyday wear, but Opium's spicy, oriental is more versatile in my book. I might even say it's the bridge between trendy and classic.


I can not be more agreed! I`m 34 and use Opium. I think it`s not a matter of age, but how you dress! You can`t wear a t-shirt, jogging pants, sneakers and caps together with Opium... But with a good looking clean white/blue shirt, leather-shoe, elegant jacket etc, it`s a winner! If you are a bit concervative, with a modern- classic style, Opium is a goood choice!
It`s definitively a formal scent, but i love it so much that i use it every day!
As time goes by and i`m getting older, my taste of scents has developed, and my intersest for todays new realeses is getting minor and minor.. Real quality never goes out of style!!
post #27 of 48
Of that list, the only one I've tried and liked is L'Anarchiste, but I find it more a summer fragrance ( though it's good any time ).

My top three fall and winter fragrances would be:

Winter Star
Cuir Ottoman
Iris Silver Mist
post #28 of 48
Musc Ravegeur
Lolita Lempicka
Terre de Hermes
post #29 of 48
John Varvatos (original)
Michael Kors
Aigner Black
post #30 of 48
I rock Opium to work, Court, t-shirt jeans, night out with my girlfriend, romantic dinner with my lady, dinner with family, to a business meeting, etc... It is all good. I am 28 years old and see no connection between Opium and age; it is only a problem if you make it one.
post #31 of 48
Habit Rouge
H.O.T. Always
Jaipur Homme
post #32 of 48
I am surprised no one mentioned Grey Flannel.
post #33 of 48
Thread Starter 
Thanks for the suggestions. My interest is rising for Opium pH. If I like Opium pH then I may look for Eau d'Orient. The problem is that I don't just want to end up buying a bunch of fragrances all at once.

Any ideas where I can buy samples of the following?:

Opium pour Homme
Black XS
Diesel Zero Plus
Lolita Lempicka Au Masculin

Ok, new challenge. Don't include Burberry London because I'm sold on it since I have already tested it. Also, don't include A*Men since I can test it out at the store. Which five fragrances should I look into the most out of the following?:

Body Kouros
L'Anarchiste
Rive Gauche pour Homme
Opium pour Homme
Opium pour Homme Eau d'Orient
Black XS
Diesel Zero Plus
Lolita Lempicka Au Masculin
post #34 of 48
Au Masculin-
Body Kouros-
L'Anarchiste-
Rive Gauche PH- Potent stuff but not as necessarily wintery, IMHO
Opium PH- The Eau D'Orient is designed for warmer weather, stick with original for now.

Opium PH has been spotted all over the country in TJMAXX and Marshall's lately. For 9.99-14.99, it's not a bad blind buy. My guess is that these are older bottles and you may sacrifice some strength. That's just a guess though.

Also, Perfumania stores carry Au Masculin, Rive Gauche, and Opium.

Body Kouros and L'Anarchiste might be more difficult but I'm sure you'll find them on the internet eventually.
post #35 of 48
CdG Sequoia
Rive Gauche
Michael Kors
L'Anarchiste
Tom Ford Amber Absolute
Serge Lutens Fumerie Turque
Serge Lutens Amber Sultan
Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille
Acier Aluminum
Bois du Portugal
M7


TNMA
post #36 of 48
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheAttorney View Post

I rock Opium to work, Court, t-shirt jeans, night out with my girlfriend, romantic dinner with my lady, dinner with family, to a business meeting, etc... It is all good. I am 28 years old and see no connection between Opium and age; it is only a problem if you make it one.

-Here is Rupert Everett in the commercial for Opium pour Homme, http://www.youtube.com/results?searc...ium+pour+homme How old was he back in 95? The women is Linda Evangelista.
post #37 of 48
Sables by A. Goutal
Heritage by Guerlain
Lui by Mazzolari
post #38 of 48
Paco Rabanne Homme
Vetiver Guerlain
post #39 of 48
add B*Men to your list. It is perfect for fall!
post #40 of 48
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by nthny View Post

add B*Men to your list. It is perfect for fall!

I would if I didn't already have it in my collection!

I want to have a solid wardrobe of fragrances that I will wear often and have no problem wearing. Fragrances don't usually grow on me so that means if I don't like them right away then they won't grow on me. Here's my edited list of fragrances I am thinking about buying. Solid list?

A*Men (Will test)
Burberry London (Will buy)
Body Kouros (May test or buy blind)
Brit for Men (Will test)
post #41 of 48
Thread Starter 
Just thought I'd bump this to ask another question. Is it worth owning both A*Men and Body Kouros? I want a sweet fragrance and both seem like they have sweet edible notes. Some say they smell cotton candy from Body Kouros? Which would you prefer out of the two?
post #42 of 48
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ronin View Post

Just thought I'd bump this to ask another question. Is it worth owning both A*Men and Body Kouros? I want a sweet fragrance and both seem like they have sweet edible notes. Some say they smell cotton candy from Body Kouros? Which would you prefer out of the two?

Hmm.. A*Men smells like a box confectionary candy. I Like it! -But i wouldn`t dare wearing it.. If you want a sweet scent, go for Bouchereon Jaipur! Very delicious composition. Classic elegance, that radiate style and good taste.. Smells very expensive. Beautiful dry-down. A couple of weeks ago, i had trouble choose from Opium and Jaipur. Both of them are great, and i picked Opium that is something i don`t regret..
But i could not get Jaipur out of my mind, so today i went back and bought it. So now i can alternate between these two materpices!
It`s not a scent for the masses, so it feels like i`m wearing something uniqe and spesial!

Good Luck with your hunt for a new perfume!
post #43 of 48
What do people think of xeryus rouge as a winter frag?
post #44 of 48
If you like sweet frags and you like the smell of strawberries, give Black XS a try.

Edit: Oh whoops, I forgot this was already on your list.
post #45 of 48
Rive Gauche pour Homme
Body Kouros
Burberry London
Bulgari Black
post #46 of 48
Thread Starter 
I may give Black XS a try sometime but not right now. The problem is that it's a bit too pricey for me to buy blind and I don't know where to sample it. I will try A*Men and Brit on Monday to determine if these are ones I want to buy. Burberry London is a keeper for me and Body Kouros will be a blind buy. I want to have a small but varied collection of fragrances that I will use often. I wonder which I will like more: Brit or A*Men? Or both? I shall see this Monday and report my thoughts.

I'm still not sure whether I should blind buy Body Kouros because reading past topics shows that it's a fragrance that you can easily be bored with and many people have. Some even compared it to one of the Valentino fragrances that my friend has but I don't care for it. Are there people out there that continue to like Body Kouros after multiple wearings?
post #47 of 48
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ronin View Post

I may give Black XS a try sometime but not right now. The problem is that it's a bit too pricey for me to buy blind and I don't know where to sample it. I will try A*Men and Brit on Monday to determine if these are ones I want to buy. Burberry London is a keeper for me and Body Kouros will be a blind buy. I want to have a small but varied collection of fragrances that I will use often. I wonder which I will like more: Brit or A*Men? Or both? I shall see this Monday and report my thoughts.

I'm still not sure whether I should blind buy Body Kouros because reading past topics shows that it's a fragrance that you can easily be bored with and many people have. Some even compared it to one of the Valentino fragrances that my friend has but I don't care for it. Are there people out there that continue to like Body Kouros after multiple wearings?


If you are going to try out A*Men, you must give Jaipur a chance also! There are some simularities between them.. Bouth are sweet, but Jaipur is more luxurius! It`s More cocoa-smell in A*Men...
post #48 of 48
L'Anarchiste
Chergui
Knize ten
Musc Ravageur
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: MFD Archive
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › MFD Archive › Three Solid Fall/Winter Fragrances?