Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › MFD Archive › Underrated designers frags for men
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Underrated designers frags for men

post #1 of 80
Thread Starter 
Hi all. I just purchased Issey Miyake's Bleue last week. I think it is one of the most underrated designers frags for men. One can forget about the citrus top notes as it only lasts for 10 seconds on my skin. After that, it turns to a dried flower/leaves/woody scent----- airy yet woody. It reminds me of the smell of dried chrysanthemum flower. On a hot summer days, we always drink chrysanthemum tea. Fragrant yet airy (the tea drink). Lastly it turns to a soft ambery scent. I think that IM Bleue can easily fits for summer days despite the woody characteristic. Longevity is about 5 hours on my skin. I love it to the max.

So it makes me wonder whether could you all list down any underrated designers mens frags for me to try in the future. I do feel that Azzaro Now for men is another underrated scent.
post #2 of 80
Quote:
Originally Posted by archaic View Post

Hi all. I just purchased Issey Miyake's Bleue last week. I think it is one of the most underrated designers frags for men.

Ohh it's my favorite! smells absolutely mesmerising. lovely use of spices and woods. easily one of the best scent out there.

Others, which imho are underrated -

Azzaro Pure Vetiver
Luciano Soprani Uomo & Sulky
Loewe Agua de Loewe & Para Hombre
Adolfo Dominiguez Vetiver Hombre
Burberry Brit
Faconnable Face a Face
Hugo Boss Soul
+
many more...
post #3 of 80
Long time no see archaic. Yeah i totally get the chrysanthemum tea reference. Although i don't have much love for Bleue the last time i tried it months ago because it reminded me of Vicks Vapor Rub. I feel the urge to give it another go. Some of the underrated frags are IMO:
- Solo Loewe (and others in the Loewe Mens range).
- Versace Pour Homme (wait till the drydown)
- YSL L'Homme (needs a few wearing to see its beauty).
- Z Zegna Extreme
- YSL Pour Homme Haute Concentration (I just realised how rare this is in Malaysia).

btw, If u know of any good deals on frags in Msia pls let me know.
post #4 of 80
Totally agree about Issey Blue, as I call it. Very underrated. I brought it home on a sample card ages ago, thinking it was so-so. I put it in a box on the dresser, as I usually do, and rediscovered it a few days later. I couldn't believe it was the same fragrance I'd initially almost dismissed. I immediately went out to buy a 75ml bottle.
Do not go by initial impressions with this one! Unctious and delicious.
post #5 of 80
Givenchy Blue Label.

Knee jerk reactions based on how commonly used or popular it is, exaggerated notions of the "superiority" of the Red Label (Johnny Walkerism in reverse, lol), wearabilty that makes it an easy neutral despite statements of it being "well done" and clear longevity, and of course revenge for the aquatics category itself as the summa cum neutral though yes indeed, it "distinguishes itself."

BTW, I am not the biggest fan of aquatics..someone who frequently wears Aramis and Halston Z-14...
post #6 of 80
Cacharel pour l'Homme - An absolute nutmeg feast

Top Notes
Lavender, Lemon, Bergamot .

Middle Notes
Nutmeg, Geranium, Carnation.

Base Notes

Sandalwood, Cedarwood, Vetiver, Musk .
post #7 of 80
.... QUORUM SILVER ....

its nothing like it big brutal brother , which is as notorious re: love/hate as Kouros
If you like frags in the Envy & Carven Homme type , then give this one a wearing if you can get it .. its sublime !
post #8 of 80
Paul Smith Story
Burberry Touch
and...

Terre d'Hermes,












....j/k on the TdH
post #9 of 80
Eau Fresh - Bogart

When I got this yesterday I was like - oh my where have you been? Soapy, pine, citrus, some spice, really well balanced and put together. Paco Rabanne fans would most likely enjoy this.
post #10 of 80
Ricci Club Haute is one of my all time favs.
post #11 of 80
A great warm-weather designer scent that I think is very underrated is

Juicy Couture Dirty English

If you were to look at the note list of; peppered mandarin, blue cypress, Calabrian bergamot, caraway, cardamom pods, marjoram, black leather, “Santal Fatal” accord (a mix of sandalwood, Atlas cedar and vetiver), agarwood, ebony wood, black moss absolute, and amber musk; you might think this would be a too heavy scent to wear in the summer.
I find the spicy citrus and the woody accord in the heart lend a different fresh and clean experience than many of the scents out there. I love it on a hot summer day.
post #12 of 80
Quote:
Originally Posted by mcjra View Post

Paul Smith Story
Burberry Touch

Definitely agree on those two. Especially Story, which I find to be far more natural smelling and interesting than Mugler cologne despite them having a number of similarities.
post #13 of 80
Quote:
Originally Posted by SculptureOfSoul View Post

Definitely agree on those two. Especially Story, which I find to be far more natural smelling and interesting than Mugler cologne despite them having a number of similarities.

I couldn't agree more. Story is much better than mugler cologne.
post #14 of 80
Lanvin Arpege pour Homme - I highly recommend picking this up at Marshalls/TJ Maxx if you see it (~ $12.99).
post #15 of 80
I will second and third;

Givenchy Blue Label
Paul Smith Story (my SOTD)
Cacheral pour l'Homme (my SOTD yesterday!)

Got to add;

Hugh Parsons Blue
Herrera Sensual Vetiver
post #16 of 80
Mario Valentino's Ocean Rain is highly underrated and undermentioned. Love it.
post #17 of 80

Guerlain Aqua Allegoria Lavande Velours
Lanvin Vetyver
Lacoste Booster

post #18 of 80
RL Safari for me
post #19 of 80
Carven Homme. Never fails to get alot of compliments. Not so easy to find.
post #20 of 80
Vuarnet Duo Homme
post #21 of 80
Kouros Cologne Sport, the perfect update of a very dated fragrance. Sexy, animalic and tenacious.
post #22 of 80
Nicole Farhi Pour Homme
Bulgari Pour Homme Soir
Lanvin L'Homme
post #23 of 80
Quote:
A great warm-weather designer scent that I think is very underrated is

Juicy Couture Dirty English

If you were to look at the note list of; peppered mandarin, blue cypress, Calabrian bergamot, caraway, cardamom pods, marjoram, black leather, “Santal Fatal” accord (a mix of sandalwood, Atlas cedar and vetiver), agarwood, ebony wood, black moss absolute, and amber musk; you might think this would be a too heavy scent to wear in the summer.
I find the spicy citrus and the woody accord in the heart lend a different fresh and clean experience than many of the scents out there. I love it on a hot summer day.

Dirty English is one of my favorite cooler-weather scents, but I havent dared to try it in the heat yet. Maybe I will try next week.

And I second DE being underrated, as well as Hugo XY (best mint I've tried as of yet), and Ed Hardy Love and Luck. If people can forget the notion that EH is a trendy brand and that Christian Audigier is a sub-par designer, the scent is probably my favorite fresh/fruity scents in my wardrobe.
post #24 of 80
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dimitrios View Post

.... QUORUM SILVER ....

its nothing like it big brutal brother , which is as notorious re: love/hate as Kouros
If you like frags in the Envy & Carven Homme type , then give this one a wearing if you can get it .. its sublime !

I second that...big time!
post #25 of 80
YSL Live Jazz

John Varvatos Artisan

L'eau D'issey Bleue
post #26 of 80
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by JoNnY 4 View Post

Long time no see archaic. Yeah i totally get the chrysanthemum tea reference. Although i don't have much love for Bleue the last time i tried it months ago because it reminded me of Vicks Vapor Rub. I feel the urge to give it another go. Some of the underrated frags are IMO:
- Solo Loewe (and others in the Loewe Mens range).
- Versace Pour Homme (wait till the drydown)
- YSL L'Homme (needs a few wearing to see its beauty).
- Z Zegna Extreme
- YSL Pour Homme Haute Concentration (I just realised how rare this is in Malaysia).

btw, If u know of any good deals on frags in Msia pls let me know.

ahhh for the Loewe range...you can find it @Plaza Low Yat, near the main escalator somewhere at level 1 or 2. This little shop also sells Byblos products.

I do love z zegna extreme's rose definition. i find it more masculine than burberry brit (powdery velvety rose) tho. z zegna extreme's rose feels woody and herbacious with a hint of spice. very Arabesque.
post #27 of 80
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by mcjra View Post

Paul Smith Story

yesss PS Story is wayyy underrated. i love PS Story more than my Mugler Cologne LOL
post #28 of 80
Too many to mention, but one that doesn't get much attention here is Green Jeans. I wore it several days ago and was very impressed by the rich yet subtle pine drydown.
post #29 of 80
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by MassMenace View Post

YSL Live Jazz

John Varvatos Artisan

L'eau D'issey Bleue

i love all 3. hahaha. so what if it is heavily synthetic... (as quoted in some of the reviews). as long as it makes me feel happy and dandy all day long, i'm ok with it. LOL
post #30 of 80
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bigsly View Post

Too many to mention, but one that doesn't get much attention here is Green Jeans. I wore it several days ago and was very impressed by the rich yet subtle pine drydown.

hehe i thought Versace Green Jeans was discontinued. and yessss green jeans feels like a walk in pine forest.
post #31 of 80
The one that comes to my mind immediately and it's because it gets absolutely no love here:
Roberto Cavalli Man

-Bergamot, ginger, lemon
-Cedarwood, leather, lavender
-Sandalwood, myrrh, musk

I love how fresh and fizzy it is in the opening and how soft and creamy in the base.
RM
post #32 of 80
Versace Black Jeans and the aforementioned Green Jeans. My interest in them diminished after wearing them constantly for years.

Black Jeans can go head-to-head with many niche fragrances out there and win, in my opinion.. it's bold, masculine and has excellent longevity and sillage.
post #33 of 80
I have to disagree with Versace Green Jeans, that stuff is pretty vile!
What about Metal Jeans??
post #34 of 80
not just underrated but never mentioned !!
Derrick Black by Orlane
post #35 of 80
It's funny that I've been accused of being too sensitive, yet Green Jeans is rather mild for me, even with two sprays. Then, once the drydown fully sets in, it's quite sedate, but there is a rich pine accord that is great. However, it's sometimes so faint that I have to wave my hand to waft it up to my nose. I wonder if this has to do with certain notes bothering people. I have problems with lavender and geranium, unless they are quite subdued, and the anise bombs are unbearable to me (like Body Kouros), but others don't even seem to smell the lavender. As a newbie, the lavender just came across as a kind of "background noise," from what I remember.
post #36 of 80
Hi archaic, Just got into this hobby and finding it devilish hard to find anything other then the latest designer frags in KL. Any suggestions where to look for fragrances in malaysia?
post #37 of 80
Quote:
Originally Posted by petruccijc View Post

Lanvin Arpege pour Homme - I highly recommend picking this up at Marshalls/TJ Maxx if you see it (~ $12.99).


I strongly second L'Arpege Homme, with a megaphone.

It's not particularly unique, but it is, quite simply, an exceelent fragrance if you like iris and anise in your fragrances. Like petruccijc said, look for it at TJMaxx - I got a 3.4 oz. bottle on clearance for $10. The scent has excellent longevity too (8 - 12 hrs. on my dry skin).
post #38 of 80
Gucci PH II is very underrated. I feel people dismiss it because it's very easy to wear and a designer frag. It would be one of the more popular niche frags if it weren't designer. It shares a lot with L'Artisan's Tea for Two.

Personally, I don't understand Versace's Black Jeans.
post #39 of 80
Quote:
Originally Posted by teohha View Post

Hi archaic, Just got into this hobby and finding it devilish hard to find anything other then the latest designer frags in KL. Any suggestions where to look for fragrances in malaysia?

Hi there. Nice to see another Malaysian on Basenotes. Pls PM me if u interested on anything about frags in Malaysia. We could help each other
post #40 of 80
I struggle to see what turns people off about Black Jeans, quite frankly. Not that you aren't entitled to your opinion! I can somewhat understand Green Jeans, as the opening reminds me a bit of "Pine Sol"..

Quote:
Originally Posted by Stereotomy View Post

Gucci PH II is very underrated. I feel people dismiss it because it's very easy to wear and a designer frag. It would be one of the more popular niche frags if it weren't designer. It shares a lot with L'Artisan's Tea for Two.

Personally, I don't understand Versace's Black Jeans.
post #41 of 80
Quote:
Originally Posted by AnthonyDG View Post

I struggle to see what turns people off about Black Jeans, quite frankly. Not that you aren't entitled to your opinion! I can somewhat understand Green Jeans, as the opening reminds me a bit of "Pine Sol"..

Well, it's what I call the 'cooked cabbage' note. Perhaps you agree that it's very similar to Rive Gauche PH? What Give Gauche PH is lacking, that's exactly the part I don't like about Black Jeans.
post #42 of 80
Not sure if they qualify as designer, but both of these are very underrated...

Laura Tonatto - Albi
Laura Tonatto - Iss
post #43 of 80
Quote:
Originally Posted by shamu1 View Post

I strongly second L'Arpege Homme, with a megaphone.

It's not particularly unique, but it is, quite simply, an exceelent fragrance if you like iris and anise in your fragrances. Like petruccijc said, look for it at TJMaxx - I got a 3.4 oz. bottle on clearance for $10. The scent has excellent longevity too (8 - 12 hrs. on my dry skin).

This is one where some people feel the need to "think their way out of." Even foetidus does this in his review (while waxing poetic about Unbound).

I'd like to come up with a fragrance called "Inbound." Or another, "Rebound."
post #44 of 80
Cooked cabbage? Really? I'll have to pull out my sample again. I remember Black Jeans to be mainly spicy/dry with floral top notes. It's quite complex, especially for a designer fragrance. What I don't get is the sandalwood - whatsoever. It's supposedly in there but I think it's hidden by some of the other strong notes.

But I definitely agree that it shares similarities with RG, and I'd rather wear RG than Black Jeans only because Black Jeans brings back memories of the late 90's.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Stereotomy View Post

Well, it's what I call the 'cooked cabbage' note. Perhaps you agree that it's very similar to Rive Gauche PH? What Give Gauche PH is lacking, that's exactly the part I don't like about Black Jeans.
post #45 of 80
Zino Davidoff
Dlish Clean Men
post #46 of 80
+1 to Dirty English. I just found a 15ml of it at Target on clearance and I love it already.
post #47 of 80
My vote goes to Royal Copenhagen (including the Musk). $$$-level quality (ingredients, blending, sillage and longevity) for drugstore $s.

Considering Royal Copenhagen is a certified Purveyor to Her Majesty The Queen of Denmark, the pricing and distribution of this frag baffles me. I was glad to see it on display at Bloomingdales.
post #48 of 80
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stereotomy View Post

Gucci PH II is very underrated. I feel people dismiss it because it's very easy to wear and a designer frag. It would be one of the more popular niche frags if it weren't designer. It shares a lot with L'Artisan's Tea for Two.

Personally, I don't understand Versace's Black Jeans.

I am sort of glad Gucci II is underrated. I love it so much, i don't want snyone else to smell like me. I also think Narciso Rodriguez for him is also underrated. Unfortunatly, many places are discontinuing NR for him. I have been told my several Sephora locations that t hey will no longer be carrying NR for him. I have also been told by several Nordstrom SAs that once they run out of NR for him, they will not be getting more in stock, however some locations will be getting the NR for him EDP. I hope they do not stop carrying NR for him. I have bought enough to last me a lifetime, but I still wish they sold it, so I can use it liberally.
post #49 of 80
Ah, Narciso Rodriguez for him, another one I don't get.

Too grassy for me, as if you're walking with a pocket full of freshly mown grass. I can understand however why people might like it. It's pretty unique.
post #50 of 80
I think most of the Dunhills are underrated. By myself as well as others. They sit in my wardrobe largely ignored until I suddenly get an urge to use one. that happened last night with Desire. It's the kind of frag that's not to everyone's taste, but it surrounds you in a wonderful cloud that sticks around for ever. Fresh is another that I should reach for more than I do.
post #51 of 80
Thread Starter 
wow...so many recommendations. hehe gotta check them out very soon. hehehe
post #52 of 80
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stereotomy View Post

Well, it's what I call the 'cooked cabbage' note. Perhaps you agree that it's very similar to Rive Gauche PH? What Give Gauche PH is lacking, that's exactly the part I don't like about Black Jeans.

I have heard you a few times mention your dislike for Black Jeans, but clearly you do have a scent association with BJ and "cooked cabbage" I don't get that at all, but then again our experiences are different.

I am somewhat in disagreement with the similarity to Rive Gauche pour Homme, as far as smell is concerned. Black Jeans to me is also really dry and RG pH is creamy and somewhat powdery at times. Maybe there is something there in BJ that somehow makes it similar to RG pH...is it structure or the way the notes come about...I'm not sure. I'll give it another sampling.

Quote:
Originally Posted by AnthonyDG View Post

Cooked cabbage? Really? I'll have to pull out my sample again. I remember Black Jeans to be mainly spicy/dry with floral top notes. It's quite complex, especially for a designer fragrance. What I don't get is the sandalwood - whatsoever. It's supposedly in there but I think it's hidden by some of the other strong notes.

But I definitely agree that it shares similarities with RG, and I'd rather wear RG than Black Jeans only because Black Jeans brings back memories of the late 90's.

Those "...spicy/dry with floral top notes..." are just amazing to me. And yes Black Jeans is a complex scent, which is a nice surprise as I find the vast majority of men's fragrances to be quite linear ( whether niche or designer). Downside for me is the lack of longevity

As far as you not being able to get any sandalwood out of BJ, I believe the reason is that sandalwood in many if not most fragrances just easily blends in with the notes and accords around it. I always thought of sandalwood being more functional in a fragrance rather than for its very own scent. Maybe its a stabilizer in a fragrance, not sure. Or perhaps allows the middle notes to keep persisting for a longer period of time.
post #53 of 80
Black Jeans is only "underrated" if you like it, right? There was a harsh note that I simply could not tolerate in it. I sampled it 3 times, separated by a month or more, then I gave up on it, but it is certainly not a simple frag.
post #54 of 80
Quote:
Originally Posted by archaic View Post

yesss PS Story is wayyy underrated. i love PS Story more than my Mugler Cologne LOL

That's odd. I'm the other way around. I gave away what was left of my TM Cologne to a friend who wanted something subtle for work and he's never worn cologne before. I bought Story to replace it. After several months of wearing it, I gave in, sold it, and ended up buying a new bottle of TM. I just wasn't diggin' the sharp grapefruit beginning in Story and TM just seemed to have better staying power on me.
post #55 of 80
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stereotomy View Post

Gucci PH II is very underrated. I feel people dismiss it because it's very easy to wear and a designer frag. It would be one of the more popular niche frags if it weren't designer. It shares a lot with L'Artisan's Tea for Two.

I agree with this. I think lots of people are quick to dismiss it because it's a designer frag that came out in the last couple years, it's the follow up to a much hyped and loved scent here, and the juice is blue. That usually equals death on basenotes. However, I think it smells fantastic and if this was released by L'Artisan or some other respected niche brand many more people would be singing its praises.
post #56 of 80
Yeah, I'll give my props to GPH II as well even though I don't personally like it, but that's just because I don't get on well with whatever synthetic is used in so many designer tobacco notes. I must be hyperosmic to it.

The frag has an interesting dichotomous personality where the watery and woody coexist for quite some time.
post #57 of 80
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rawk Lee View Post

That's odd. I'm the other way around. I gave away what was left of my TM Cologne to a friend who wanted something subtle for work and he's never worn cologne before. I bought Story to replace it. After several months of wearing it, I gave in, sold it, and ended up buying a new bottle of TM. I just wasn't diggin' the sharp grapefruit beginning in Story and TM just seemed to have better staying power on me.


true that TM has wayyyyy much better staying power than Story but on my skin, TM starts with a healthy dose of neroli (which is gooooood) then it turns to a vetiver-ish powdery notes. very prominent tho. too prominent. but then again..... i used like 10 squirts on my chest. LOL LOL LOL i've become the cologne guy all day long. LOLOLOLOL
post #58 of 80
Another vote for Paul Smith Story...

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dimitrios View Post

Derrick Black by Orlane

Never tried it, but... believe it or not, Derrick (not Black, not Silver) was the fragrance that got me hooked on perfumes when I was 15 or 16, I think! I had a mini which I treasured, since it was impossible to find a bottle in Belgium. It still is, as far as I know. I wonder if I'd still enjoy it after all this time. I should perhaps take a trip down memory lane and buy some from ebay...

Another underrated fragrance, in my book, is my SOTD: Annayake UNDŌ.
post #59 of 80
Versace PH
Boss Soul
Gucci PH 2
Azzaro Onyx/Black Silver
Azzaro Chrome Legend
Joop Thrill man
Joop PH
Lancome Hypnose Man
Givenchy Pi Neo


all quite underrated.
post #60 of 80
Not really a "designer" but an interesting study in how a scent gets caught in the crosshairs...without any of the customary provisos regarding application (go light on the trigger)...or for being being too linear or whatever...and yes, "longevity issues'...

Aspen For Men...most frequently shot down for being too similar of course to either CW or GIT...whilst there are Creeds and even Tom Fords which get treated far more mercificully in that department...

BTW, when applied as a close to skin scent (because of lonegvity and using that flaw) 1 shot or 2...this stuff is a fine sport scent...that avoids the whole obsession with lavender/pakmoss/conifer...lightly applied this stuff adds up to mostly "mint" wintergreen....

whether you like this one or not study the few reviews for some of the mechanisms of being shot down...or taken down a notch even while being recommended...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: MFD Archive
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › MFD Archive › Underrated designers frags for men