The only Demeter I've ever tried is Thunderstorm, and frankly I was not impressed. I was really excited about it because I love the smell of rain and storms, but I remember it smelling very very synthetic, and not really like a thunderstorm.
So I ascribed this hyper-synthetic quality to all Demeter fragrances...even the ones that are not supposed to be abstract representations of events.
Was I wrong in doing that? Do Demeter scents like Patchouli, Bonfire, Mulled Cider, etc. smell less contrived and chemical?
If a highly qualified and tuned nose like mikeperez23's nose sees something in them, I feel like I must have given up on Demeter too soon. Anyway, I hope you like your new ones!