Nipz, welcome to Base Notes.
If I were you, I would try them. This is because olfactive perceptions are very personal - you might like what others don't, and viceversa. So go to Macy's and give these two a try. Look for sillage (if the scent projects and can be smelled by others) and longevity.
You might try them on pieces*of papers (or blotters), a good idea if you don't want the fragrance be applied on your skin, but take in mind they don't make justice to the way the fragrance will smell on your skin. Remember to write down the name of the scents applied on each blotter.
Your choice would be the one that makes you feel more comfortable.