Having spotted your thread, I dug my old Sicily sample vial out. I've been ambivalent about it for as long as I can remember.
Today, however, it smells beautiful on me: yes, soapy and floral, but very richly so, with a distinct honey note. Having had it on my skin for about 4 hours now, I'd even say it was weirdly chypre-y at the base, which is very agreeable.
There have been days when this has smelled less than great on me, but today it is utterly lovely. And, of course, now it has been discontinued (to the best of my knowledge).